RADEON rx570 8GB vs Rx580 8gb 2018

[DIXxX]

Hi,

 I have one rig with gtx 1070 but thinking to add 6xSapphire Nitro from Radeon to build another one. We have option to get Radein rx570 or rx580 8gb...the prices exceed 600€....so I wanted to check which card would be best to buy and which can give me best ETH return. Or is 4gb still good investment also?

Please need your help guys, my brother has lost both his kidneys and I sold my car to invest into mining hopefully to buy him kidney by next year since the waitlist can be years. I am not asking for result over night and I know it is a long wait but being desperate leaves you with little choice and  hopefully give him some hope it will be sooner than later. Thank you for understanding.

[1713981723]

1713981723

[1713981723]

1713981723

[1713981723]

1713981723

[1713981723]

1713981723

[CryptoDocker]

They both hash ETH around the same only differences in memory matter.

600€ is too much for either of those cards.

If you can get cheaper 4GB cards they are good until at least 2020 unless ETH goes POS before then.

[DIXxX]

Hello,

Thank you for answer. Yes I agree that they are overpriced, because resellers are manipulating the price bringing it higher and higher each day, literally.

So you think 570 8gb is just as good. I know 580 have better clocks setting it higher than 580, but if there is little hashing difference than 570 is good if easier obtainable.

[CryptoDocker]

Hello,

Thank you for answer. Yes I agree that they are overpriced, because resellers are manipulating the price bringing it higher and higher each day, literally.

So you think 570 8gb is just as good. I know 580 have better clocks setting it higher than 580, but if there is little hashing difference than 570 is good if easier obtainable.

If you can get them at the same price then get the 580 as you can re sell them for more maybe a year or two down the track for better value

If the 570's are marginally cheaper then buy them

Are Vega's also priced very high where you are? If they are 100€ more or something it would be better to get them since you are paying top dollar anyway

[Branko]

All Polaris cards but RX580 8GB use 1750MHz memory, RX580 8GB uses 2000MHz

Of course, its the same memory, just handpicked at factory, so if you're really lucky

maybe you can get 1750MHz that clocks really high, but on average 2000MHz one

should get you higher clocks (and hashrate)


Exception is Sapphire RX580 8GB SE that's rated at 2100MHz

[DIXxX]

Vegas are 800-900€ 56 and 64 respectively...if I am not wrong

Edit: hvala Branko na odgovoru...thnx for replying Branko

[Iamtutut]

All Polaris cards but RX580 8GB use 1750MHz memory, RX580 8GB uses 2000MHz

Of course, its the same memory, just handpicked at factory, so if you're really lucky

maybe you can get 1750MHz that clocks really high, but on average 2000MHz one

should get you higher clocks (and hashrate)


Exception is Sapphire RX580 8GB SE that's rated at 2100MHz

My mems run @2080MHz on both RX 570 4GB (gigabyte gaming & Sapphire Pulse ITX). The Gigabyte can hold 2100MHz but I din't see any difference in hashrates.

[Branko]

All Polaris cards but RX580 8GB use 1750MHz memory, RX580 8GB uses 2000MHz

Of course, its the same memory, just handpicked at factory, so if you're really lucky

maybe you can get 1750MHz that clocks really high, but on average 2000MHz one

should get you higher clocks (and hashrate)


Exception is Sapphire RX580 8GB SE that's rated at 2100MHz

My mems run @2080MHz on both RX 570 4GB (gigabyte gaming & Sapphire Pulse ITX). The Gigabyte can hold 2100MHz but I din't see any difference in hashrates.

Depends a lot on memory type and memory cooling solution...my RX560 Microns are rated 1750, but run at 2240...
I wish I have some of those micron based Sapphire rx580 SE cards to test how high they go

[tg88]

You can buy the nitro 570 that will not lose anything in relation to nitro 580.

[DIXxX]

Guys just a general question about FAN speeds...I have set the voltage treshold to about 50% and now all cards dropped temperature to about 55c from 62c...without losing hasrate.

The Fans are on auto working at 28-33% since ambient temperature does not exceed 7C...is that ok or I should set Fan speed to manual %....my wish is to lower power consumption

[BitcoinSupremo]

Where are you located ? If you are in Europe you can use Ebay Italy website and find these cards for a maximum price of 420 Euro and not 600. I would recommend the RX 570 as they consume less energy and have almost the same hashrate, top of the line from these cards is Sapphire Nitro+ but they consume more energy so I would advice to get the Sapphire Pulse RX 570 8GB, hashrate with AMD Adrenaline driver 17.11.1 in Compute mode is 31.4 Mhash. I hope you reach your goal as it is truly a noble one.

[DIXxX]

Where are you located ? If you are in Europe you can use Ebay Italy website and find these cards for a maximum price of 420 Euro and not 600. I would recommend the RX 570 as they consume less energy and have almost the same hashrate, top of the line from these cards is Sapphire Nitro+ but they consume more energy so I would advice to get the Sapphire Pulse RX 570 8GB, hashrate with AMD Adrenaline driver 17.11.1 in Compute mode is 31.4 Mhash. I hope you reach your goal as it is truly a noble one.

Bosnia at the moment working there...I just made arrangement to buy a rig 2200 Eur with 4x 570 nitro+ 8gb with flashed Bios for undervolting total MH/s 124...seems ok

Btw thank you for your support it is much appreciated. Do you have any advice to my question about voltage and power consuption?

[RYXES]

Where are you located ? If you are in Europe you can use Ebay Italy website and find these cards for a maximum price of 420 Euro and not 600. I would recommend the RX 570 as they consume less energy and have almost the same hashrate, top of the line from these cards is Sapphire Nitro+ but they consume more energy so I would advice to get the Sapphire Pulse RX 570 8GB, hashrate with AMD Adrenaline driver 17.11.1 in Compute mode is 31.4 Mhash. I hope you reach your goal as it is truly a noble one.

Bosnia at the moment working there...I just made arrangement to buy a rig 2200 Eur with 4x 570 nitro+ 8gb with flashed Bios for undervolting total MH/s 124...seems ok

If you're not sure how to build a rig and the time taking to research how to make them and errors etc then 2200€ is pretty good because time is money.

The first rig took me about a month off and on to o get up and running finely tuned.

Could of spent that time doing far greater things.

[miningchamp93]

The Sapphire Radeon RX 580 8GB provides hashrate of 800 Hash/s for CryptoNote at Coreclock 1150 MHz and Memoryclock 2150 MHz while consuming 90 watts.
 Gpu Specs

The AMD Radeon RX 580 8GB is a graphics card by AMD. It comes with GDDR5 memory and has 256 bit memory interface or bus width.


The Sapphire Radeon RX 570 8GB provides hashrate of 25 MHash/s for Ethereum at Coreclock 1420 MHz and Memoryclock 2250 MHz while consuming 130W watts.


 Gpu Specs

The AMD Radeon RX 570 8GB is a graphics card by AMD. It comes with GDDR5 memory and has 256 bit memory interface or bus width.

here is the link fore more info


https://miningchamp.com/gpus/130/Sapphire-Radeon-RX-580-8GB-hashrate

https://miningchamp.com/gpus/150/Sapphire-Radeon-RX-570-8GB-hashrate

[Branko]

The Sapphire Radeon RX 580 8GB provides hashrate of 800 Hash/s for CryptoNote at Coreclock 1150 MHz and Memoryclock 2150 MHz while consuming 90 watts.
 Gpu Specs

The AMD Radeon RX 580 8GB is a graphics card by AMD. It comes with GDDR5 memory and has 256 bit memory interface or bus width.


The Sapphire Radeon RX 570 8GB provides hashrate of 25 MHash/s for Ethereum at Coreclock 1420 MHz and Memoryclock 2250 MHz while consuming 130W watts.


 Gpu Specs

The AMD Radeon RX 570 8GB is a graphics card by AMD. It comes with GDDR5 memory and has 256 bit memory interface or bus width.

here is the link fore more info


https://miningchamp.com/gpus/130/Sapphire-Radeon-RX-580-8GB-hashrate

https://miningchamp.com/gpus/150/Sapphire-Radeon-RX-570-8GB-hashrate

Thats with stock bios-es, but how much with modified ones?

[Iamtutut]

The Sapphire Radeon RX 580 8GB provides hashrate of 800 Hash/s for CryptoNote at Coreclock 1150 MHz and Memoryclock 2150 MHz while consuming 90 watts.
 Gpu Specs

The AMD Radeon RX 580 8GB is a graphics card by AMD. It comes with GDDR5 memory and has 256 bit memory interface or bus width.


The Sapphire Radeon RX 570 8GB provides hashrate of 25 MHash/s for Ethereum at Coreclock 1420 MHz and Memoryclock 2250 MHz while consuming 130W watts.


 Gpu Specs

The AMD Radeon RX 570 8GB is a graphics card by AMD. It comes with GDDR5 memory and has 256 bit memory interface or bus width.

here is the link fore more info


https://miningchamp.com/gpus/130/Sapphire-Radeon-RX-580-8GB-hashrate

https://miningchamp.com/gpus/150/Sapphire-Radeon-RX-570-8GB-hashrate

My system with 3 RX 570 4GB ETASH bios mod.
Idle: +/- 105W
Etash, +/- 92MH/s: 440W. Around 110W/ 30,6MH/s per card.
CN V1 variant 7 (monero type) around 2750-2800H/s 330-340W. So around 80W per card.

[Mohondoa]

I can suggest you to buy RX 570 because it's more cheaper than RX 580 and also has same hashrate running at ETH mining. And if you want more cheaper try to get 4GB RX 570, this memory can use around until year 2020 before ETH get POS. But if you want long-time you can buy 8GB version. Good luck mining sir.

[kissmarx]

RX 570 8gb is the better choice now when compared to RX 580 8gb. The price of RX 570 is cheaper. But if you can find a good deal with the RX 580, then that would be the choice. But it is almost to find an ideal deal with RX 580. So RX 570 is the better choice. Anyway, both are almost at the same hashing rate.

[markiz73]

RX 570 8gb is the better choice now when compared to RX 580 8gb. The price of RX 570 is cheaper. But if you can find a good deal with the RX 580, then that would be the choice. But it is almost to find an ideal deal with RX 580. So RX 570 is the better choice. Anyway, both are almost at the same hashing rate.

Under the current situation, the issue is not relevant. The difference in price between Rx570 8GB and Rx580 8gb is 20-30 dollars.
But considering that the Rx570 and Rx580 are the same as the Rx470 and Rx480 (although everyone knows that Rx470 and Rx480 are better in the mining).
Rx470 and Rx480 appeared on the market in June 2016 and today this architecture is obsolete and has a payback period of more than 3 years.

[mineroc]

The Sapphire Radeon RX 580 8GB provides hashrate of 800 Hash/s for CryptoNote at Coreclock 1150 MHz and Memoryclock 2150 MHz while consuming 90 watts.
 Gpu Specs

The AMD Radeon RX 580 8GB is a graphics card by AMD. It comes with GDDR5 memory and has 256 bit memory interface or bus width.


The Sapphire Radeon RX 570 8GB provides hashrate of 25 MHash/s for Ethereum at Coreclock 1420 MHz and Memoryclock 2250 MHz while consuming 130W watts.


 Gpu Specs

The AMD Radeon RX 570 8GB is a graphics card by AMD. It comes with GDDR5 memory and has 256 bit memory interface or bus width.

here is the link fore more info


https://miningchamp.com/gpus/130/Sapphire-Radeon-RX-580-8GB-hashrate

https://miningchamp.com/gpus/150/Sapphire-Radeon-RX-570-8GB-hashrate

My system with 3 RX 570 4GB ETASH bios mod.
Idle: +/- 105W
Etash, +/- 92MH/s: 440W. Around 110W/ 30,6MH/s per card.
CN V1 variant 7 (monero type) around 2750-2800H/s 330-340W. So around 80W per card.

monero settings?