[Guide] Dogie's Comprehensive Manufacturer Trustworthiness Guide [1st Feb 2016]

[dogie]

How is company size determined?

Updated criteria with explanations.

[wpgdeez]

51 Pages. You've been putting in work Dogie! If you broke down all your time I wonder what it would equate to per hour.

[dogie]

51 Pages. You've been putting in work Dogie! If you broke down all your time I wonder what it would equate to per hour.

For this resource? $-XX probably.

[dogie]

Added historical score graphs to give a better idea of momentum. It also highlights quite well the process of an infraction, and then the company being forced to build up reputation again (ie Bitmain and ASICMiner). Click on the graph for 4K/full screen version.

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=456691.msg5035180#msg5035180

[Blazed]

I think for the most part it looks alright, but of course Avalon being higher than SP-Tech just does not seem right to me. Last time I checked SP-Tech never screwed over half the miners on these boards  . Anyways Dogie keep up the good work on this and the guides and have a good holidays.

[dogie]

I think for the most part it looks alright, but of course Avalon being higher than SP-Tech just does not seem right to me. Last time I checked SP-Tech never screwed over half the miners on these boards  . Anyways Dogie keep up the good work on this and the guides and have a good holidays.

ST is due to go up to 100 next time if they follow through [depending when the cycle ends.]

[dogie]

Added score colorings to the first half of the list. Let me know if you like it or if it gives you eye aids. I'll revert or add to the rest of the list depending on feedback in a bit.

[Blazed]

Added score colorings to the first half of the list. Let me know if you like it or if it gives you eye aids. I'll revert or add to the rest of the list depending on feedback in a bit.

The colors are nice I say add it to all of them. Also I agree about SP...it is refreshing to see such a legit ASIC company these days!

[raskul]

Added score colorings to the first half of the list. Let me know if you like it or if it gives you eye aids. I'll revert or add to the rest of the list depending on feedback in a bit.

The colors are nice I say add it to all of them. Also I agree about SP...it is refreshing to see such a legit ASIC company these days!

yes, more colour!
this forum ain't half pretty enough, i'm so glad we have dogie 

[dogie]

Added score colorings to the first half of the list. Let me know if you like it or if it gives you eye aids. I'll revert or add to the rest of the list depending on feedback in a bit.

The colors are nice I say add it to all of them. Also I agree about SP...it is refreshing to see such a legit ASIC company these days!

yes, more colour!
this forum ain't half pretty enough, i'm so glad we have dogie 

Thanks for the feedback.

[CrazyRabbi]

Added score colorings to the first half of the list. Let me know if you like it or if it gives you eye aids. I'll revert or add to the rest of the list depending on feedback in a bit.

The colors are nice I say add it to all of them. Also I agree about SP...it is refreshing to see such a legit ASIC company these days!

yes, more colour!
this forum ain't half pretty enough, i'm so glad we have dogie 

Thanks for the feedback.

Dogie is a Sparkle Doge <3

[dogie]

Added score colorings to the first half of the list. Let me know if you like it or if it gives you eye aids. I'll revert or add to the rest of the list depending on feedback in a bit.

The colors are nice I say add it to all of them. Also I agree about SP...it is refreshing to see such a legit ASIC company these days!

yes, more colour!
this forum ain't half pretty enough, i'm so glad we have dogie 

Thanks for the feedback.

Dogie is a Sparkle Doge <3

[dogie]

Added score colorings to the first half of the list. Let me know if you like it or if it gives you eye aids. I'll revert or add to the rest of the list depending on feedback in a bit.

The colors are nice I say add it to all of them. Also I agree about SP...it is refreshing to see such a legit ASIC company these days!

yes, more colour!
this forum ain't half pretty enough, i'm so glad we have dogie 

Thanks for the feedback.

Added colors to the rest of them.

[Guy Corem]

...

• SpondooliesTech Preorders up from 'Yes' to 'Mix' (1 to 8]. *Although SpondooliesTech is currently selling out of hand, they have not yet demonstrated that their business model can support this into the next generation. On the announcement of next gen preorders, this rating will return to 'Yes'. On the announcement of next gen in hand / batch sales, this rating will increase to 'Batch' or 'No'.

...

In general, I believe you're doing a decent job with the guide.
Regarding our score, we're currently selling from stock all our products line. It seems to me a bit unfair and last minute change of your scoring criteria.

Dogie,
I strongly believe we should get 100 by your criteria. It seems that you avoid publishing an update or come up with new criteria like the above just to avoid what should be rightfully our score by your criteria.

Guy

[dogie]

...

• SpondooliesTech Preorders up from 'Yes' to 'Mix' (1 to 8]. *Although SpondooliesTech is currently selling out of hand, they have not yet demonstrated that their business model can support this into the next generation. On the announcement of next gen preorders, this rating will return to 'Yes'. On the announcement of next gen in hand / batch sales, this rating will increase to 'Batch' or 'No'.

...

In general, I believe you're doing a decent job with the guide.
Regarding our score, we're currently selling from stock all our products line. It seems to me a bit unfair and last minute change of your scoring criteria.

Dogie,
I strongly believe we should get 100 by your criteria. It seems that you avoid publishing an update or come up with new criteria like the above just to avoid what should be rightfully our score by your criteria.

Guy

And what motive would I have for that?

[Guy Corem]

...

• SpondooliesTech Preorders up from 'Yes' to 'Mix' (1 to 8]. *Although SpondooliesTech is currently selling out of hand, they have not yet demonstrated that their business model can support this into the next generation. On the announcement of next gen preorders, this rating will return to 'Yes'. On the announcement of next gen in hand / batch sales, this rating will increase to 'Batch' or 'No'.

...

In general, I believe you're doing a decent job with the guide.
Regarding our score, we're currently selling from stock all our products line. It seems to me a bit unfair and last minute change of your scoring criteria.

Dogie,
I strongly believe we should get 100 by your criteria. It seems that you avoid publishing an update or come up with new criteria like the above just to avoid what should be rightfully our score by your criteria.

Guy

And what motive would I have for that?

I don't know.

[raskul]

so, explain the motive, dogie, oh ye of bitmaintech lapdoggie 

[dogie]

so, explain the motive, dogie, oh ye of bitmaintech lapdoggie 

Bitmain have been about 10 points lower than they used to be since I started doing work from them, and are rank #4. Next idea.

[raskul]

so, explain the motive, dogie, oh ye of bitmaintech lapdoggie  

Bitmain have been about 10 points lower than they used to be since I started doing work from them, and are rank #4. Next idea.

The fact that your employer got their deserve ranking,
while their biggest competition ranking is skew-iff, does raise questions
SP ranking is skewed since you are a BMT employee, put 100 Sp-Tech.  

[dogie]

so, explain the motive, dogie, oh ye of bitmaintech lapdoggie 

Bitmain have been about 10 points lower than they used to be since I started doing work from them, and are rank #4. Next idea.

The fact that your employer got their deserve ranking,
while their biggest competition ranking is skew-iff, does raise questions
SP ranking is skewed since you are a BMT employee, put 100 Sp-Tech. 

Let me get this straight, you're saying that because I lowered the score of a company I've done work for, that I am biased on behalf of that company? By putting 3 other companies above them? Okay.