Ban Appeal RegulusHr and discussion on topic "good for the forum as a whole".

[Daniel91]

Then, you or anyone else should create a thread that shows how RegulusHr is - as theymos says - "good for the forum as a whole";

OK, as suggested, but in the same thread so that other users can follow more easily, here are the posts from RegulusHr which, in my opinions, shows how good he is for the ''forum as a whole''.
I hope that admins will reconsider now their decision about permaban.

Posts from Regulushr:

Application For Merit Source
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=2828982.msg28997087#msg28997087

Very detailed manual on Croatian, what to do when you get the first, tokens. Required reading for each beginner in the crypto world.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=3196935.msg33165145#msg33165145

Bounty Campaign Altcoin - Signature, Telegram
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=2929934.0

Multisignature address and wallet explanation
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=3154168.msg32608692#msg32608692

Crypto GUI Miner – review
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=3052292.msg31914563#msg31914563

News about opening of the exchange office crypto/fia
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=3671333.msg36747904#msg36747904

Review of the crypto/fiat exchange office
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=3671333.msg46963394#msg46963394

A critical review of the Dropil project drop with reference to the good and bad sides.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=4419051.msg45150312#msg45150312

Testing and Comparison of Mining Software
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=2879234.msg29579473#msg29579473

Hints and help to a beginner in the crypto world.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=4818132.msg43532974#msg43532974

Review of buying IT equipment in Croatia for BTC.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=2518444.msg25721122#msg25721122

Explain why mining is not profitable even when heat is used to warm the room.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1671371.msg48630307#msg48630307

[1713504592]

1713504592

[1713504592]

1713504592

[cryptofrka]

In my opinion, it will be impossible to prove that a member who mostly writes in local board is "good for the forum as a whole".

We have shown strong support here already, the local community is fully behind RegulusHR and we would like to apply again to get his punishment reduced. He already accepted all the possible punishments and apologized multiple times. A temporary signature ban and removing him as a merit source really seems as a fair punishment.

Permanent bans should be reserved for scammers and serious offenders, not for people who copied somebody's post 3 years ago in an irrelevant 'good project' thread.
Well, just my 2 cents. Last try to change something that is really not fair and not deserved.

[big_daddy]

Dear Daniel91, I am busy and really have no extra time to spend on the forum searching for the good and better posts from our great Comrad RegulusHr, cause there are a lot,
but I saw the listed posts above and completely agree with you that those are posts showing how good he was for the ''forum as a whole''.

Best regards

[Daniel91]

In my opinion, it will be impossible to prove that a member who mostly writes in local board is "good for the forum as a whole".

I hope you're wrong here.
We shouldn't have 2 categories of the members here, users who can speak and write good English and others, who write mostly in local sections because of the weak English or other reasons.
All members should be respect equally here and definition "good for the forum as a whole" should apply equally to all.

[Dzeronimo]

We keep asking admins to unban RegulusHR for over 40 days. Does anyone believe we would do that for someone who don't deserve to be a part of this forum? We, who understand his posts, truly believe that he deserve another chance.

[eroejoe]

He even organized meetup for local community of Bitcoin forum with his own money.

I have to quote myself because I do not think that this fact reach to Bitcointalk community enough.
I think that meetups are great way to make community on forum stronger and better connected within each other.

[ovcijisir]

Hope something changed here on forum considering permabans for good contributing members.

Too summarize again why in my opinon RegulusHR should have permaban removed:

• helped a lot of members with his quality posts (see Daniel91 post above).
• gained 140 merit for his posts, and almost ranked up to Sr. member before ban - this speaks for his posts quality. (I guess that RegulusHR would gain much more merit if he wrote in english section, but he chose to help to grow our local forum)
• did a lot in regard to local community (being merit source - he even got promoted right before ban, organizing local meetup) - did all his duties responsibly
• overall good and friendly attitude toward people on forum

This thread is swimming in evidence why RegulusHR should have his ban removed.

Hope it is true that Theymos have loosened up the rules for permaban (for good contributing members).

In my opinion, it will be impossible to prove that a member who mostly writes in local board is "good for the forum as a whole".

I hope you're wrong here.
We shouldn't have 2 categories of the members here, users who can speak and write good English and others, who write mostly in local sections because of the weak English or other reasons.
All members should be respect equally here and definition "good for the forum as a whole" should apply equally to all.

1. It is easy to use google translate to gain rough understanding what the post is about
2. there are a lot of members of local community that confirm that posts are helpful and high quality
3. merit gained for those posts speaks how good they are

[ReguluHr-alt]

Dear community,
Once again I apologize for the mistake in some of my early posts.
I also thanks to the members of the local part of the forum who gave me support in this thread, especially Danijel91. They have written very beautiful things about me and my contribution to the forum. I hope it is enough for the formulation "good for the forum as a whole".
I would ask the administrator to reconsider my case and if is possible replace a permanent ban with a less severe punishment and give me a chance to further take part in the forum topic I find interesting and motivating.

[Daniel91]

Dear community,
Once again I apologize for the mistake in some of my early posts.
I also thanks to the members of the local part of the forum who gave me support in this thread, especially Danijel91. They have written very beautiful things about me and my contribution to the forum. I hope it is enough for the formulation "good for the forum as a whole".
I would ask the administrator to reconsider my case and if is possible replace a permanent ban with a less severe punishment and give me a chance to further take part in the forum topic I find interesting and motivating.

Thank you very much RegulusHr.
We really appreciate you and respect you in our Croatian community and didn't forget you.
As you can see, almost 2 months we fight here for you and we will continue to do so.
Why?
It's very simple, because it's the right thing to do.

[ovcijisir]

Dear community,
Once again I apologize for the mistake in some of my early posts.
I also thanks to the members of the local part of the forum who gave me support in this thread, especially Danijel91. They have written very beautiful things about me and my contribution to the forum. I hope it is enough for the formulation "good for the forum as a whole".
I would ask the administrator to reconsider my case and if is possible replace a permanent ban with a less severe punishment and give me a chance to further take part in the forum topic I find interesting and motivating.

RegulusHR I really hope that your contribution to the forum will be acknowledged, because if someone deserved it it is you.

[Daniel91]

Dear community,
Once again I apologize for the mistake in some of my early posts.
I also thanks to the members of the local part of the forum who gave me support in this thread, especially Danijel91. They have written very beautiful things about me and my contribution to the forum. I hope it is enough for the formulation "good for the forum as a whole".
I would ask the administrator to reconsider my case and if is possible replace a permanent ban with a less severe punishment and give me a chance to further take part in the forum topic I find interesting and motivating.

RegulusHR I really hope that your contribution to the forum will be acknowledged, because if someone deserved it it is you.

Even if admins will not acknowledge his contribution on this forum, his high reputation on our local section, we all did something great here.
Many Croatian and even Ex-Yu btc community members on this forum really acted as one and worked together to show their opinions about this case.
We already fighting almost 2 months for RegulusHr (and we will not give up) and it's extraordinary and very special action on this forum.
Guys, I'm really pride because of you all, thank you for your heart and effort offered.
It will be remembered.

[bernardos]

I hope that admins will find some time to take a look at this case concerning ReguluHr one more time and give him a chance to return on probation with no signature or whatever is needed.

[Daniel91]

Dear Admins

As I see here, almost 2 months since RegulusHr started this topic, and even contacted several times admins with email and pm, still there is no answer.
I understand that admins and moderators are very busy on this forum and there are many such requests daily but after so long time I think that RegulusHr, and whole Croatian community, really deserve some definitive answer about this issue.
I don't think that you will find many (if any) topics here, on Meta, where so many members sharing their very positive impressions and experiences about banned member and asking that you remove permaban, still 2 months after RegulusHr received his permaban.
How long we should continue this discussion, requesting answer from admins/mods?
3.6 months, year or two?
He helped a lot members on this forum personally, organized offline meeting for all of us, earned a lot merits by himself (for good quality posts), was community leader etc.
For more about his great contribution to this forum and why so many forum users feel that his permaban should be removed please read other posts in this topic.

[cryptofrka]

After recent events in which a respected forum member's permaban has been lifted (rightfully, in my opinion), we would like to ask again for reconsideration of permaban punishment to one of our local boards' most respected members as well.

RegulusHr deserves another chance too, please take some time to revise this case.
I feel as if enough has been said already but please feel free to ask if you need any more information regarding his contribution to our board and our local community.

[Daniel91]

I have to share that this case: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5114253.0 gave great hope and expatiation in the Croatian community that permaban for RegulusHr will be removed.
We feel that his case is also good candidate for something like this, based on the all arguments shared in this topic.
At least, we feel that after 3 full months RegulusHr deserve final answer from the admins.
Thank you for understanding. 

[Trofo]

I also feel that we as a community have already said everything worth saying on this topic. IMHO we have managed to show that RegulusHR is outstanding member of Croatian local section. Now we can only hope that somebody will evaluate this case and exchange permaban with a punishment more fit for an individual like RegulusHr.

[big_daddy]

Dear Admins

I'm writing to support our local forum member RegulusHr, who started this topic almost 3 months ago
He contributed to the local but also to the rest of the forum, from my point of view, the contribution was positive

As a forum member and as a local forum member I am kindly asking Admins to give the opportunity to the user RegulusHr for a second chance

Best regards

[Daniel91]

I'm really shocked that after more than 3 months of waiting, admins still didn't answer this request.
I know that RegulusHr several times sent personal messages to admins but also didn't receive any answer.
You could see from previous posts that RegulusHr is well respected member in the local community.
Also, I think that we all shared a lot very good arguments why this permaban should be removed.
We know several cases when admins removed permaban for some other members on the forum.
Because of this we all had great hope that RegulusHr will come back finally but still there is no answer.
Because of this, many members in our local community feel that Regulus didn't have honest treatment and equal chance for forgiveness like some other members on this forum.
Some members feel like ''second class'' members on this forum.
I hope that admins will do right thing here and remove this permaban after more than 3 months.
We will not give up from this case because we feel that RegulusHr also deserve second chance, even if he was active only in the local section on this forum.

[Branko]

I'm really shocked that after more than 3 months of waiting, admins still didn't answer this request.
I know that RegulusHr several times sent personal messages to admins but also didn't receive any answer.
You could see from previous posts that RegulusHr is well respected member in the local community.
Also, I think that we all shared a lot very good arguments why this permaban should be removed.
We know several cases when admins removed permaban for some other members on the forum.
Because of this we all had great hope that RegulusHr will come back finally but still there is no answer.
Because of this, many members in our local community feel that Regulus didn't have honest treatment and equal chance for forgiveness like some other members on this forum.
Some members feel like ''second class'' members on this forum.
I hope that admins will do right thing here and remove this permaban after more than 3 months.
We will not give up from this case because we feel that RegulusHr also deserve second chance, even if he was active only in the local section on this forum.

Actually, specially because of the bold part...local forum seems like 50% less active than before he was banned

[Bokile]

And after three months we are still active in this topic. I'm not sure will I do that for my brother It's simple: Give him one more chance.