Ban appeal

[UserU]

Who are you to state it?

He's right. You will get similar responses from the rest because rules are rules.

Remember if theymos or some staff sees this topic, it's going to be another ban.

[1714644641]

1714644641

[alaindelon1]

Who are you to state it?

He's right. You will get similar responses from the rest because rules are rules.

Remember if theymos or some staff sees this topic, it's going to be another ban.

Banning this account literally means nothing.

[mk4]

Do we also need to repeat the same thing every time? You will not get unbanned. How difficult is that to understand? Lock the topic already.

Who are you to state it?

Someone who is actually literate enough to clearly understand the rules.

[alaindelon1]

Do we also need to repeat the same thing every time? You will not get unbanned. How difficult is that to understand? Lock the topic already.

Who are you to state it?

Someone who is actually literate enough to clearly understand the rules.

More looks like someone who needs to study how to mind his own business .

[Quickseller]

Can a moderator who would know, confirm if the message quoted in the OP is real?

Theymos explicitly said that merit would not be moderated, but the above seems to contradict that.

[Quickseller]

Maybe so, but everyone else has the right to know what is expected of them in regards to merit.

[stompix]

Can a moderator who would know, confirm if the message quoted in the OP is real?
Theymos explicitly said that merit would not be moderated, but the above seems to contradict that.

That didn't stop him to delete merits  and the above user has received merits from stingers, but he was banned before the scandal so probably not related.

So it's either that the recovery team made a mistake or the admins have been banning people for this silently and the above user is the first that has come in the open and is trying to recover his account, the others thought an appeal is a waste of time.

Out of the many reasons for getting banned I'm also really curious what happened here.

[alaindelon1]

Can a moderator who would know, confirm if the message quoted in the OP is real?

Theymos explicitly said that merit would not be moderated, but the above seems to contradict that.

It is 100% real, I can provide screenshot/video/whatever.

Still waiting for explanation about my merit abusing from admins. Thak you

[nutildah]

Can a moderator who would know, confirm if the message quoted in the OP is real?

Theymos explicitly said that merit would not be moderated, but the above seems to contradict that.

It is 100% real, I can provide screenshot/video/whatever.

Still waiting for explanation about my merit abusing from admins. Thak you

Screenshots aren't 100% proof but they are a lot better than just quoting the message. If you can include a screenshot of the email, with the subject title / to and from email addresses, it might help your case (emphasis on might).

[Quickseller]

The complete email with the headers can prove the email is authentic.

[alaindelon1]

Screenshots aren't 100% proof but they are a lot better than just quoting the message. If you can include a screenshot of the email, with the subject title / to and from email addresses, it might help your case (emphasis on might).

That's why I wrote that I can grab a video, but admins do know that it is legit.
And as I have a newbie account I can not attach photos (as far as I know).
 

upd screenshot

[nutildah]

Screenshots aren't 100% proof but they are a lot better than just quoting the message. If you can include a screenshot of the email, with the subject title / to and from email addresses, it might help your case (emphasis on might).

That's why I wrote that I can grab a video, but admins do know that it is legit.
And as I have a newbie account I can not attach photos (as far as I know).

You can't post URLs to photos? Its been a while since I was a Newbie, I don't remember...

[UserU]

You can't post URLs to photos? Its been a while since I was a Newbie, I don't remember...

AFAIK, Newbies can't, only Junior onwards.

Anyway, here's the image:

[alaindelon1]

Okay, as expected - nothing.

[nutildah]

This is a unique case so I took some time to look into it.

It would appear that the "merit abuse" part has to do with these 4 accounts:

steve_rogers (banned)
timoshani
nastyabor (banned)
dimplit (banned)

sending a total of 10 merit to this account:

AsrRustam (banned)

Here is what the sent merit network looks like:



Its impossible for me to tell whether the posts you merited were of any value because they are all deleted.
I know merits are for the most part subjective, so you will need explicit comment from theymos or else whoever did the banning in order to know more.

[alaindelon1]

This is a unique case so I took some time to look into it.

It would appear that the "merit abuse" part has to do with these 4 accounts:

steve_rogers (banned)
timoshani
nastyabor (banned)
dimplit (banned)

sending a total of 10 merit to this account:

AsrRustam (banned)

Here is what the sent merit network looks like:

https://i.imgur.com/zLvTehb.png

Its impossible for me to tell whether the posts you merited were of any value because they are all deleted.
I know merits are for the most part subjective, so you will need explicit comment from theymos or else whoever did the banning in order to know more.

Okay, finally smth that could be very hardly called merit abusing, but still it's noting. Nevertheless thanks for your job.

[YOSHIE]

If I see you are banned, really object to certain reasons, according to you?
Maybe, the @steve_rogers account, is forbidden because it avoids prohibitions, this is my opinion, maybe.
I see the account name of your account exactly,
Maybe Admin sees this account as one person, because you don't tag, this is my thinking.

1. steve_rogers  (Archived)
2. steve_rogers99  (active)
3. steve_rogers321  (Archived)
4. HaiYan08  (Archived)

Telegram username:  Hai Yan
Ethereum address:0x2F282ae0e7fadA6F3C63AD2df4A3D678355aFc9A
FACEBOOK
Bitcointalk username: HaiYan08

Facebook account: https://www.facebook.com/yenhai.8102
Facebook friends/followers: 5430
Telegram username: Hai Yan
Ethereum address:0x2F282ae0e7fadA6F3C63AD2df4A3D678355aFc9A

( archive )

Post: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=4094452.msg42563361#msg42563361

Bitcointalk Username: steve_rogers321
Bitcointalk Profile: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=2248398
Telegram: @HaiYan08
ETH address: 0x2F282ae0e7fadA6F3C63AD2df4A3D678355aFc9A

( archive

[alaindelon1]

If I see you are banned, really object to certain reasons, according to you?
Maybe, the @steve_rogers account, is forbidden because it avoids prohibitions, this is my opinion, maybe.
I see the account name of your account exactly,
Maybe Admin sees this account as one person, because you don't tag, this is my thinking.

1. steve_rogers  (Archived)
2. steve_rogers99  (active)
3. steve_rogers321  (Archived)
4. HaiYan08  (Archived)

Telegram username:  Hai Yan
Ethereum address:0x2F282ae0e7fadA6F3C63AD2df4A3D678355aFc9A
FACEBOOK
Bitcointalk username: HaiYan08

Facebook account: https://www.facebook.com/yenhai.8102
Facebook friends/followers: 5430
Telegram username: Hai Yan
Ethereum address:0x2F282ae0e7fadA6F3C63AD2df4A3D678355aFc9A

( archive )

Post: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=4094452.msg42563361#msg42563361

Bitcointalk Username: steve_rogers321
Bitcointalk Profile: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=2248398
Telegram: @HaiYan08
ETH address: 0x2F282ae0e7fadA6F3C63AD2df4A3D678355aFc9A

( archive

I have nothing in common with those 3 accounts.