[AMD] New AMD RX Graphics Cards of 2019 - RX 5700 / XT, RX 600

[JFoxOne]

Profitability calculator for RX 5700 TX.

[1713540731]

1713540731

[prpz]

Can anyone offer any assistances trying to mine with 5700xt stock settings STAK 2.10.6 with currency set to cryptonight_GPU getting close to 1600hs but all shares rejected by nanoonpool, switching to Monero or another algo all shares accepted but 854mhs tried the other which is just terrible
any assistance?
SRBMiner works lovely on my Vega but 0mhs on 5700xt
XMR STAK 2.5 also can't get over 850 stock settings
tried 18.5.2 19.7.2 19.7.3 all drivers across all miners

[swogerino]

I am very impressed with 72 Mhs for Lyra2rev, these cards seems like the new benchmarks for mining with graphic cards.I think that many new persons will come to mining with these cards soon.

[BenjaminWegener]

Can anyone offer any assistances trying to mine with 5700xt stock settings STAK 2.10.6 with currency set to cryptonight_GPU getting close to 1600hs but all shares rejected by nanoonpool, switching to Monero or another algo all shares accepted but 854mhs tried the other which is just terrible
any assistance?
SRBMiner works lovely on my Vega but 0mhs on 5700xt
XMR STAK 2.5 also can't get over 850 stock settings
tried 18.5.2 19.7.2 19.7.3 all drivers across all miners

could be a shot in the dark, but maybe try another pool for cn.gpu?

[prpz]

Yeah maybe, know of a decent pool? or I just might mine until I find something more profitable or etherum miner becomes avail....slightly disappointed but i'll live the 3900x tho 107 watts 1600mh on same miner super stoked about that and with new algo might go up in October!

[BenjaminWegener]

Yeah maybe, know of a decent pool? or I just might mine until I find something more profitable or etherum miner becomes avail....slightly disappointed but i'll live the 3900x tho 107 watts 1600mh on same miner super stoked about that and with new algo might go up in October!

1600mh cpu on which algo?
i use pool.ryo-currency.com

[prpz]

cryptonight_r  XmrStak 2.10.6 3900x 4.3 1.32vcore

[ronnieb]

Can anyone offer any assistances trying to mine with 5700xt stock settings STAK 2.10.6 with currency set to cryptonight_GPU getting close to 1600hs but all shares rejected by nanoonpool, switching to Monero or another algo all shares accepted but 854mhs tried the other which is just terrible
any assistance?
SRBMiner works lovely on my Vega but 0mhs on 5700xt
XMR STAK 2.5 also can't get over 850 stock settings
tried 18.5.2 19.7.2 19.7.3 all drivers across all miners

Try hashvault.pro pool, all my shares get accepted on there. I'm doing around 1600 h/s with a regular 5700 on XMR STak.

are you using default setting or did you modify the amd config file to include 2 threads?

[DDesignE]

Hi guys again,

so, I've been messing around with the Ethminer Opencl Kernel, and I think I found out what is wrong with the RX 5700 family for mining ETH on OpenCL 2.0:

(Gonna need some help fixing it)

Let's Start:

After you download the new release's source code here:
https://github.com/ethereum-mining/ethminer/archive/v0.19.0-alpha.0.tar.gz
Extract it and find the kernels/cl/ folder,
Edit the ethash.cl file, change this line(236):

Code:

    mix = fnv(mix, g_dag[buffer[lane_idx]].uint8s[thread_id]); \

to this:

Code:

   /* mix = fnv(mix, g_dag[buffer[lane_idx]].uint8s[thread_id]);*/ \ 

compile and run the miner!

That line is responsible for bottlenecking the hole code!

I am able to achieve 300+ MH/s without that line of code!
(LOOOOL not mining properly, of course, I get only rejected shares!)

So:

My thoughts on this, and after some testing, the problem is MEMORY ACCESS!
let's get back to the code:

Code:

    mix = fnv(mix, g_dag[buffer[lane_idx]].uint8s[thread_id]); \

if I change

Code:

buffer[lane_idx]

for a defined value eg. '0',
It runs @ ~80MH/s (I assume It's the real Speed),
but of course again, REJECTED SHARES, because

Code:

buffer[lane_idx]

is supposed to change according to 'lane_idx'!
Bottom line is, fetching this piece of code's value from memory is slowing down the hole thing!

Conclusion:

I need Help, since I'm no ETH nor OpenCL Expert...
We can assume from this the Theoretical Seed of ~80MH/s for mining ETH on the RX 5700 XT!
(not bad, but I was Expecting 100+ MH/s)
(maybe with specific optimizations, driver upgrade, etc, we could get better performance)

[prpz]

Can anyone offer any assistances trying to mine with 5700xt stock settings STAK 2.10.6 with currency set to cryptonight_GPU getting close to 1600hs but all shares rejected by nanoonpool, switching to Monero or another algo all shares accepted but 854mhs tried the other which is just terrible
any assistance?
SRBMiner works lovely on my Vega but 0mhs on 5700xt
XMR STAK 2.5 also can't get over 850 stock settings
tried 18.5.2 19.7.2 19.7.3 all drivers across all miners

Try hashvault.pro pool, all my shares get accepted on there. I'm doing around 1600 h/s with a regular 5700 on XMR STak.

are you using default setting or did you modify the amd config file to include 2 threads?

I tried I looked up some guides and failed to do it, how do I do 2 threads? I tried just copy paste the the section after the gpu but didn't work
could you show me what I need to edit and edit to what in the amd config file please? I can post back results

I would love to get 1600hs on that or this card maybe some settings you have are better? what's you power consumption

(long time Ethereum miner with claymore, new to XmrStak and Monero)

[reb0rn21]

DDesignE

you expected 100+ for real man....

same with the one that posted cryptonight speed later we see its cryptonight GPU algo speed...

5700 IS PURE CRAP, if you want gddr6 get RTX2060 super its same memory + tensor core don`t beat the dead cat and spread insane expectations just because its damn shite AMD!

[ronnieb]

Can anyone offer any assistances trying to mine with 5700xt stock settings STAK 2.10.6 with currency set to cryptonight_GPU getting close to 1600hs but all shares rejected by nanoonpool, switching to Monero or another algo all shares accepted but 854mhs tried the other which is just terrible
any assistance?
SRBMiner works lovely on my Vega but 0mhs on 5700xt
XMR STAK 2.5 also can't get over 850 stock settings
tried 18.5.2 19.7.2 19.7.3 all drivers across all miners

Try hashvault.pro pool, all my shares get accepted on there. I'm doing around 1600 h/s with a regular 5700 on XMR STak.

are you using default setting or did you modify the amd config file to include 2 threads?

I tried I looked up some guides and failed to do it, how do I do 2 threads? I tried just copy paste the the section after the gpu but didn't work
could you show me what I need to edit and edit to what in the amd config file please? I can post back results

I would love to get 1600hs on that or this card maybe some settings you have are better? what's you power consumption

(long time Ethereum miner with claymore, new to XmrStak and Monero)

Can you copy and paste your amd config here?

[fmz89]

Released WildRig 0.19.0 preview with RX 5700 series support.

Here some results for stock Sapphire RX 5700 XT(better results can be achieved with undervolt)
blake2b     - 2.1GH/s
lyra2v3     - 72MH/s
lyra2vc0ban - 65MH/s

Download and Details

Can anyone provide numbers for vega 64 / radeon vii in order to compare?

Vega64 is doing 104mhs on lyra2v3 at 300$ new card
I doubt navi will pass vega series

[CharlieCox]

I doubt navi will pass vega series

They have released their midrange card first. Let's see what the 5800 (XT) will bring to the table.

[Branko]

Released WildRig 0.19.0 preview with RX 5700 series support.

Here some results for stock Sapphire RX 5700 XT(better results can be achieved with undervolt)
blake2b     - 2.1GH/s
lyra2v3     - 72MH/s
lyra2vc0ban - 65MH/s

Download and Details

Can anyone provide numbers for vega 64 / radeon vii in order to compare?

Vega64 is doing 104mhs on lyra2v3 at 300$ new card
I doubt navi will pass vega series

Its probably still unoptimized, lets wait few months before making statements about hashrates

[prpz]

Can anyone offer any assistances trying to mine with 5700xt stock settings STAK 2.10.6 with currency set to cryptonight_GPU getting close to 1600hs but all shares rejected by nanoonpool, switching to Monero or another algo all shares accepted but 854mhs tried the other which is just terrible
any assistance?
SRBMiner works lovely on my Vega but 0mhs on 5700xt
XMR STAK 2.5 also can't get over 850 stock settings
tried 18.5.2 19.7.2 19.7.3 all drivers across all miners

Try hashvault.pro pool, all my shares get accepted on there. I'm doing around 1600 h/s with a regular 5700 on XMR STak.

are you using default setting or did you modify the amd config file to include 2 threads?

I tried I looked up some guides and failed to do it, how do I do 2 threads? I tried just copy paste the the section after the gpu but didn't work
could you show me what I need to edit and edit to what in the amd config file please? I can post back results

I would love to get 1600hs on that or this card maybe some settings you have are better? what's you power consumption

Yes I can, I appreciate the help man!

"gpu_threads_conf" : [
  // gpu: gfx1010  compute units: 20
  // memory:4048|4048|8048 MiB (used per thread|max per alloc|total free)
  { "index" : 0,
    "intensity" : 960, "worksize" : 8,
    "affine_to_cpu" : false, "strided_index" : 0, "mem_chunk" : 2,
    "unroll" : 1, "comp_mode" : true, "interleave" : 40
  },
 
],

/*
 * number of rounds per intensity performed to find the best intensity settings
 *
 * WARNING: experimental option
 *
 * 0 = disable auto tuning
 * 10 or higher = recommended value if you don't already know the best intensity
 */
"auto_tune" : 0,

/*
 * Platform index. This will be 0 unless you have different OpenCL platform - eg. AMD and Intel.
 */
"platform_index" : 0,

(long time Ethereum miner with claymore, new to XmrStak and Monero)

Can you copy and paste your amd config here?

I copied this part

{ "index" : 0,
    "intensity" : 960, "worksize" : 8,
    "affine_to_cpu" : false, "strided_index" : 0, "mem_chunk" : 2,
    "unroll" : 1, "comp_mode" : true, "interleave" : 40
  },
Exactly like they tried intensity 960 890 800 480 all of them cause the amd driver to stop responding
Tried running stock underclocked unfervolted
I might just return this card maybe go for 5700 try it see how it goes
Can get vega 56 gigabyte gaming (worst one based off reviews) for 90 CAD less than 5700 and 170 cad less then the 5700xt I got (if the price dropped on the VII I’d do that but it’s double the 5700 price )
Might go Nvidia super 60 or super 70
Didn’t expect the amd to be so mining problematic

[karim_hassan777]

Can anyone offer any assistances trying to mine with 5700xt stock settings STAK 2.10.6 with currency set to cryptonight_GPU getting close to 1600hs but all shares rejected by nanoonpool, switching to Monero or another algo all shares accepted but 854mhs tried the other which is just terrible
any assistance?
SRBMiner works lovely on my Vega but 0mhs on 5700xt
XMR STAK 2.5 also can't get over 850 stock settings
tried 18.5.2 19.7.2 19.7.3 all drivers across all miners

Try hashvault.pro pool, all my shares get accepted on there. I'm doing around 1600 h/s with a regular 5700 on XMR STak.

are you using default setting or did you modify the amd config file to include 2 threads?

I tried I looked up some guides and failed to do it, how do I do 2 threads? I tried just copy paste the the section after the gpu but didn't work
could you show me what I need to edit and edit to what in the amd config file please? I can post back results

I would love to get 1600hs on that or this card maybe some settings you have are better? what's you power consumption

(long time Ethereum miner with claymore, new to XmrStak and Monero)

hi guys wanna someone to help this guy

[reb0rn21]

he is mining cryptonight GPU algo

[prpz]

he is mining cryptonight GPU algo

I stated with cpu 3900X and mined monero algo  but shares were rejected by nanopool I switched to cryponight_r algo solved the problem

I’m running another instance of stak  (I have made sure to set cpu to null and vice versa gpu instance have even ran standalone miners to eliminate any conflict same issue )

On both stak miners running cryptonight_gpu does give me 1600mhs on the 5700s however same problem all shares rejected (tested for 13 hrs)
Setting in the pools.txt to cryptonight_r reduces hashes in half but all shares accepted by nanopool
Dual thread attempts resulted in instant lock up even when halving the intensity on each thread

That’s where I am at currently I have about a week to return the gpu and probably pick up vega for cheaper and run srbminer it works flawless just wanted something newer and with more potential and to play a game once every couple months

[ronnieb]

I copied this part

{ "index" : 0,
    "intensity" : 960, "worksize" : 8,
    "affine_to_cpu" : false, "strided_index" : 0, "mem_chunk" : 2,
    "unroll" : 1, "comp_mode" : true, "interleave" : 40
  },
Exactly like they tried intensity 960 890 800 480 all of them cause the amd driver to stop responding
Tried running stock underclocked unfervolted
I might just return this card maybe go for 5700 try it see how it goes
Can get vega 56 gigabyte gaming (worst one based off reviews) for 90 CAD less than 5700 and 170 cad less then the 5700xt I got (if the price dropped on the VII I’d do that but it’s double the 5700 price )
Might go Nvidia super 60 or super 70
Didn’t expect the amd to be so mining problematic

this is what i have for my normal 5700

 * ],
 * If you do not wish to mine with your AMD GPU(s) then use:
 * "gpu_threads_conf" :
 * null,
 */

"gpu_threads_conf" : [
  // gpu: gfx1010  compute units: 18
  // memory:4048|4048|8048 MiB (used per thread|max per alloc|total free)
  { "index" : 0,
    "intensity" : 864, "worksize" : 8,
    "affine_to_cpu" : false, "strided_index" : 0, "mem_chunk" : 2,
    "unroll" : 1, "comp_mode" : true, "interleave" : 40
  },
  // gpu: gfx1010  compute units: 18
  // memory:4048|4048|8048 MiB (used per thread|max per alloc|total free)
  { "index" : 0,
    "intensity" : 864, "worksize" : 8,
    "affine_to_cpu" : false, "strided_index" : 0, "mem_chunk" : 2,
    "unroll" : 1, "comp_mode" : true, "interleave" : 40
  },

],