Wouldn't Slush be better then?
It's 2% Fee Prop and no PPS?
Proportional is only good if you are a hopper. Everyone else loses.
I'll second that.
If you want a steady, reliable pay-out every day then go with a PPS pool with the lowest fee.
If you want to participate in runs of good luck then pick a mining pool that doesn't reward hopping. Prop is only fair if you're a hopper.
This is the best resource for comparing pools:https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Comparison_of_mining_pools