I think the idea itself was wrong to begin with, and the fact that it was a success for a short while doesn't mean that they thought it over for every possible scenario.
The idea is pretty simple, if you stick to the basics you're safe and it works wonders even on this forum in the lending section if you just don't offer loans with collateral! One simply rule, that's all!
This is why it failed, bear market does matter in a sense that during bull market a lot of people made profits so they were all capable of paying it back, but when the bear hit, nobody was capable of paying it and that's why they had a lot less customers and a lot less people paying.
Two mistakes with this:
- in a bear market it's actually easier to pay back your loan if you took a crypto loan. If you took 1BTC at a price of 60k you had to pay back $5k a month plus interest for a one-year loan, right now you only have to pay 2k, so it's way easier.
- that's why collateral is in for, if you don't pay the lender gets the collateral, if the collateral goes under 110-120% of the value loaned it gets liquidated and your loan is terminated, you lose your coins but the lender isn't losing a penny
If the lender follows basic self-imposed rules and common sense he can't get rekt.
That's why in crisis in the real world loan sharks thrive, they don't get bankrupt!
No company can stay afloat that way and it is impossible to keep it going.
Then why are others still operating?