unconfirmed transaction over 1 day

[kiragaz]

Is Electrum for macOS SAFE?

I remember they have some safety issues while ego?

[promise444c5]

what is OP?

I made one transaction/ with 5 24hrs ego-stuck


And made new transaction/from same wallet to my own wallet with more the 20v hour ego stuck to

OP is original poster

Go through the link hosseinimr93 sent you to make the RBF
I believe you were trying to use CPFP with you doing the second transaction, send the transaction id for the second one

[kiragaz]

5ed063414917883aeac8df3ff5fe06b22a4e5ab4fa9a025a42c83376a2c005cd
 last transaction from same wallet

[LoyceV]

Is Electrum for macOS SAFE?

You seem to be asking a lot of questions about things you don't really understand, so I'll only pick this one: you're using a hardware wallet. That means Electrum doesn't know your private keys, as long as you don't enter your seed words. It shouldn't matter if your computer is safe, as long as you verify all addresses on the screen of your hardware wallet.

My advice: take a break, take some time to read up on how Bitcoin, fees and hardware wallets work, and then try again.

5ed063414917883aeac8df3ff5fe06b22a4e5ab4fa9a025a42c83376a2c005cd
 last transaction from same wallet

Sending $5 in Bitcoin is really a waste of transaction fees. So is using legacy addresses.

[promise444c5]

5ed063414917883aeac8df3ff5fe06b22a4e5ab4fa9a025a42c83376a2c005cd
 last transaction from same wallet

It's 20 , wait an hour or 2 more let's see if  both  it gets  confirmed

[hosseinimr93]

I believe you were trying to use CPFP with you doing the second transaction, send the transaction id for the second one

If there was a CPFP transaction, it would be shown on block explorers. There is no unconfirmed child or parent associated with the transaction in question.

5ed063414917883aeac8df3ff5fe06b22a4e5ab4fa9a025a42c83376a2c005cd
 last transaction from same wallet

This transaction has nothing to with the other transaction (the one paying 5.89 sat/vbyte as fee).
It is paying 20 sat/vbyte as transaction fee and it will be likely confirmed soon.

It's 20 , wait an hour or 2 more let's see if  both gets  confirmed before trying RBF

Wrong. Wrong.
That transaction is spending a different coin and can't act as a CPFP transaction.

[kiragaz]

ok ill wait for cpl hours

if 5v AND 20v both still stuck

with one to rbf in Electrum

[promise444c5]

It's 20 , wait an hour or 2 more let's see if  both gets  confirmed before trying RBF

Wrong. Wrong.
That transaction is spending different coins and can't act as a CPFP transaction.

Thanks for the corrections didn't noticed the CPFP  that but his aim was to do a CPFP doing the second transaction I think .
OP you can just do the RBF then following the instructions, don't make the mistake to select the 20sat/vb transaction , do it on the first transaction (5 sat/vb ) because you're having 2 unconfirmed  transaction  already

ok ill wait for cpl hours

if 5v AND 20v both still stuck

with one to rbf in Electrum

That's a good idea but it's likely the second transaction  gets confirmed soon but its your choice you can choose to wait

[kiragaz]

second with 20sat got confirmed

So ill rbf later 5sat

In any chance can it be Trezor wallet problem this is new wallet?

[promise444c5]

second with 20sat got confirmed

So ill rbf later 5sat

In any chance can it be Trezor wallet problem this is new wallet?

No im not sure it's  Trezor , i think it's just your fee,  at the time you made your transaction  there were more fees like 27+ so it has to wait on the que

Your transaction is not a  high one(I guess you're using it as test) use the 11 sats/vbyte  for the RBF and wait for it to get confirmed

Make sure you learn more about how the whole stuff really works just as LoyceV mentioned this will help you... Next time you can test using testnet  mode
 https://trezor.io/learn/a/bitcoin-testnet =>Trezor
https://coinguides.org/ledger-testnet/  =>Ledger

[dkbit98]

How much time more it will take you think?

I don't remember last time I saw such low fees below 6 sat/vB so you could be waiting a long time for confirmation.
Since RBF was used you can increase fee to confirm transaction, but next time better check current fee estimations at mempool.space.
It's always good to use Electrum wallet with ledger when making bitcoin transactions.

On ledger support you can find more information about stuck transactions and how to
https://support.ledger.com/hc/en-us/articles/115005198525-Transaction-stuck-in-pending?support=true
https://support.ledger.com/hc/en-us/articles/6183300395037-Speeding-up-slow-Bitcoin-BTC-transactions-using-Electrum
https://support.ledger.com/hc/en-us/articles/14889194133405-Speeding-Up-A-Bitcoin-BTC-Deposit-Using-Child-Pays-For-Parent-CPFP?support=true

[kiragaz]

Is it OK do to RBF now?

It is over a week that transaction stuck

I been busy last 7 days

Thank you in advance

[nc50lc]

Is it OK do to RBF now?

Do it while the average fee is still low.
You can set it from 5.89sat/vB into 11sat/vB to make it to the next block, or set a little higher for some wiggle room.

In any chance can it be Trezor wallet problem this is new wallet?

Such problem isn't caused by the wallet, it's mainly because of the competition in mempools.
It's as simple as: higher fee rate will get confirmed first.
If the number of transactions with higher fee rate than yours keep piling up, then your 5sat/vB transaction wouldn't make it to the priority.

The only issue caused by the wallet is the fee rate that it suggested but that's an "estimation" of the future state of mempools
so no one can really blame the software for suggesting a quite low fee specially if the user set low/eco priority.

[kiragaz]

im trying rbf with electrum
and I did not see stuck transition in electrum wallet transactions list

transaction number:
 
8f7d7adab11e645569dcab8c8cd137654b035692d3151ac455f1f4fcc1cbfcf5

[khaled0111]

Can you see any other transactions on the history tab and does Electrum show the correct balance? If yes, then your issue isn't due to a connection problem.

The reason why you can't see the unconfirmed transaction is, most likely, because it has been dropped from the mempool of the server Electrum connects to. You can fix this by trying to connect to different servers (from Network Settings).
However, there is no need for this if your only aim is to accelerate the transaction. Just create a new one and make sure to pay enough fee this time.

[hosseinimr93]

im trying rbf with electrum
and I did not see stuck transition in electrum wallet transactions list

Maybe, you chose the wrong script type when connecting your hardware wallet to electrum.
Your wallet is nested segwit and you should choose "p2sh-segwit (p2wpkh-p2sh). Did you choose that?

The reason why you can't see the unconfirmed transaction is, most likely, because it has been dropped from the mempool of the server Electrum connects to. You can fix this by trying to connect to different servers (from Network Settings).

Almost all nodes should have OP's transaction in their mempool. The transaction in question was broadcasted only 1 week ago and its fee rate is higher than the purging fee rate.
I guess OP hasn't connected the hardware wallet to electrum correctly.

[nc50lc]

Can you see any other transactions on the history tab and does Electrum show the correct balance? If yes, then your issue isn't due to a connection problem.

Aside from the correct script type, it can also be the derivation path's "account_index".

That's applicable if you created more than one Bitcoin Account in Ledger Live of the same script type and if that transaction belongs to the second account (not second address).
In that case, after selecting 'p2sh-segwit', the last /0h in the derivation path should be edited to /1h when creating a Ledger-connected wallet in Electrum.
If not the second account, set /2h for the third account and so on. (just remember that it starts from 0)

[khaled0111]

Almost all nodes should have OP's transaction in their mempool. The transaction in question was broadcasted only 1 week ago and its fee rate is higher than the purging fee rate.
I guess OP hasn't connected the hardware wallet to electrum correctly.

I guess you are right. I imported OP's address into Electrum and kept changing servers. All of the servers I've tried still have OP's unconfirmed transaction in their mempools.
OP, make sure to select the correct script type and derivation path when connecting your hardware wallet to electrum so it crecreates the right wallet.

[kiragaz]

thank you everyone

I changed derivation path and it get confirmed

But I still see original stuck transaction in the account

[nc50lc]

I changed derivation path and it get confirmed

But I still see original stuck transaction in the account

Okay, changing the path in case it's in your second account will only enable you to see the transaction that's not showing in your previous attempt.
I don't know what you meant by "it get confirmed".

Anyways, you need to right-click on it and select "increase fee" to use RBF.
After selecting the new fee (currently about 10 sat/vB for priority), click "Sign" to sign it with your Ledger, then "Broadcast" to send the replacement transaction to the network.