Disappearing posts

[takuma sato]

Has anyone noticed that sometimes you are pretty sure you made certain posts, but then check again some hours later and they are missing? im not sure exactly which ones, but im pretty sure I had a number of posts, which are now missing. There is no notification, message, or anything that informed me that anything was deleted so I don't get it.

[Hazink]

If the entire thread where you made the post is deleted, you won't get notified about it, I guess, unless you activate to receive notifications for nuked posts, which is when your Telegram bot can send you such a notification, but if the post is being deleted by mods, I usually get a notification.

But sometimes the time when I usually notice that some of my posts are missing is when I might complete making the post, hit the submit button and not go back to confirm if it was posted or not network could obstruct it, and I will not notice, and within me, I might think the post was submitted successfully.

[Odusko]

Has anyone noticed that sometimes you are pretty sure you made certain posts, but then check again some hours later and they are missing? im not sure exactly which ones, but im pretty sure I had a number of posts, which are now missing. There is no notification, message, or anything that informed me that anything was deleted so I don't get it.

Some times such post deletion are from old threads that get deleted and significantly it be a mega thread where you may have made a lot of comments on, you don't get notified for such deletion, you just noticed that you total posts amount decreased, from what it used to be, but if you are talking about a new posts let say you made the comment today and checking back you can't find it again and no records of posts deletion and also if you check you history you fine it there, this type is a Forum technical glitch, just like it happens sometimes with your merits history, it's all forum glitches, but in reality your post were never deleted.

[TryNinja]

If you know the wording of your post, try searching them on my archive: https://beta.ninjastic.space/search

For example, if it's a post where you mentioned the bitcoin pizza day, you should find it by filtering by authors (add youself) and the search term "pizza".

After finding them, you can ask here for a mod/admin to answer why it was deleted (if it really was).

[Stalker22]

~
 but if you are talking about a new posts let say you made the comment today and checking back you can't find it again and no records of posts deletion and also if you check you history you fine it there, this type is a Forum technical glitch, just like it happens sometimes with your merits history, it's all forum glitches, but in reality your post were never deleted.

I have never experienced, nor do I remember reading anywhere about, such a forum glitch.  You are saying you make a comment, it vanishes, theres no record of it being deleted, but then it shows up in your history?

[Odusko]

~.

I have never experienced, nor do I remember reading anywhere about, such a forum glitch.  You are saying you make a comment, it vanishes, theres no record of it being deleted, but then it shows up in your history?

In the real sense I used to suspect poor Internet reception to be the cause of the inaccuracy in post history, or merit's history number, just as I mentioned in that comment, is not as if the post is deleted but just won't be able to see it at that moment tracking through the thread, but when you manually check your posts history you discovered it there, just like in merit's history inaccuracy, if toh keeo refreshing the page, the righr number shows up, I dont have a screenshot to show for example, but reat assured i will call your attention whenever i experience issues again.

[Charles-Tim]

Hazink answered his question correctly. He can use Ninjastic Telegram bot if he wants to be notified of his posts deletion after a thread is removed.

I have never experienced, nor do I remember reading anywhere about, such a forum glitch.  You are saying you make a comment, it vanishes, theres no record of it being deleted, but then it shows up in your history?

Not common at all but it has also happened to me ones before. I knew what I posted was good and I went to check it and I saw the post there. I am not referring to the posts that moderators are recently deleting and merged with your other post.

[BitMaxz]

You are not the only one who experience this I have some posts gone recently and 2 days ago without notifications.

I am trying to look for them what topic is it but I only manage to find a few topics deleted by the OP.

He can use Ninjastic Telegram bot if he wants to be notified of his posts deletion after a thread is removed.

It seems it only notified you if your posts is deleted by mods but not for topics deleted by its author because I enabled it since last year but it doesn't notified me about my two deleted recent posts.

[OcTradism]

Has anyone noticed that sometimes you are pretty sure you made certain posts, but then check again some hours later and they are missing

There are three reasons for your post deletion

- Moderator deleted a whole (entire) thread including your posts in that thread.
- Moderator deleted your posts only while that thread was not deleted.
- Topic creator in self-moderated thread deleted your thread.

Now, let's see when you receive notification for your deleted posts.
You only receive notifications in 2nd and 3rd cases while with a 1st case - a whole thread was deleted - you will not receive any notifications.

[Charles-Tim]

It seems it only notified you if your posts is deleted by mods but not for topics deleted by its author because I enabled it since last year but it doesn't notified me about my two deleted recent posts.

If my post was deleted by a moderator, I will get the forum notification for it.

Here is an example of what I mean which was recent and this is from the Ninjastic Telegram bot:

[Peanutswar]

Has anyone noticed that sometimes you are pretty sure you made certain posts, but then check again some hours later and they are missing? im not sure exactly which ones, but im pretty sure I had a number of posts, which are now missing. There is no notification, message, or anything that informed me that anything was deleted so I don't get it.

Base on my experience those thread or post have been replied and once the OP deleted the main thread there's no notification about deleting it, just get reflected to your activity count it will reduce and for somehow for sure you wonder what thread is that get deleted. Basically I'm using the archived list with Loyce.club or the Ninjastic.space for checking if history post, deleted and edited archives.

[Free Market Capitalist]

If my post was deleted by a moderator, I will get the forum notification for it.

But there are cases where it does not, as they have explained to you. I am surprised that with the seniority you have in the forum you have not noticed or do not remember it. When an entire thread is trashed and you don't quote the OP you usually don't get notified. The same thing happens for necro bumps that are trashed, if you don't quote the necro bumper.

... but im pretty sure I had a number of posts, which are now missing.

Be more selective with the threads you post in.

[lovesmayfamilis]

Some topics are deleted because they are written using AI. Yesterday I reported a similar topic, and several replies in it were also deleted. If a topic is deleted, all the replies that were in it are deleted automatically, and usually users do not receive notifications. Another option is that the OP's posts could have been complained about; then it is logical to think why they are gone.

https://ninjastic.space/search?title=Bitcoin%20vs.%20AI%3A%20The%20Battle%20for%20Electricity

[BitMaxz]

If my post was deleted by a moderator, I will get the forum notification for it.

Here is an example of what I mean which was recent and this is from the Ninjastic Telegram bot:

Well, mine doesn't notify me I made a post yesterday and it's gone no notification.
The ninjastic bot might have a bug or something else why I don't receive such a notifications.

Or maybe lovesmayfamilis is right it was auto deleted because the author posted an AI post?

I'll try to reset the telegram bot to re-enable this feature and hope I'll to receive a notification same as yours.

Is there any other source to all posts made recently I just want to confirm the topic where I post?
I can't use the ninjastic tool because I don't have the post ID or even the title of the topic.

[Perfectbaby]

Has anyone noticed that sometimes you are pretty sure you made certain posts, but then check again some hours later and they are missing? im not sure exactly which ones, but im pretty sure I had a number of posts, which are now missing. There is no notification, message, or anything that informed me that anything was deleted so I don't get it.

Sometimes post like that either be moved to archive and it will be totally disappeared from your profile. So, when you check the archive you would see it over there using ninjastic.space to see all post that was moved to archive. Though I didn't enable delete post on the telegram bot but if you do you would definitely receive notifications for post deletions.

[AVE5]

Has anyone noticed that sometimes you are pretty sure you made certain posts, but then check again some hours later and they are missing? im not sure exactly which ones, but im pretty sure I had a number of posts, which are now missing. There is no notification, message, or anything that informed me that anything was deleted so I don't get it.

I clearly understand what you're talking about here, I've experienced it in couple of my posts which had been successfully posted unlike those that're likely to be obstructed by network issues.
Sometimes going through my posts history for reference purposes, I notice couple of not (few) of my posts doesn't exist anymore. And at most times, I begin to get self questioned if could it be a cause of the moderator in charge of the act or what? But it's usually skeptic to me because when the Mod takes down post based on my experience, I'm usually getting notifications about my post getting deleted. So on this similar ones of your experience Op, it just ghostly happens without a notification.

[Upgrade00]

Sometimes post like that either be moved to archive and it will be totally disappeared from your profile.

If you mean they get moved to the archival board, that is not the case. Ninjastic scrapes the forum and keeps a log of threads and replies made, this doesn't mean deleted threads are moved there.

Threads which are removed are commonly moved to "trash", which is not accessible to regular users. I think theymos and maybe global mods can restore them to where they were originally posted, but this doesn't happen often.

[nutildah]

Right.

The problem is, as has pointed out already, people reply to OPs that are AI-generated. The OP is reported, the thread is deleted, and your posts are deleted, and you won't get paid for them. Probably in the back of your mind you already know the first post is AI-generated, but you respond anyway. So going forward, don't do that. Its really as simple as that.

[virasog]

Has anyone noticed that sometimes you are pretty sure you made certain posts, but then check again some hours later and they are missing? im not sure exactly which ones, but im pretty sure I had a number of posts, which are now missing. There is no notification, message, or anything that informed me that anything was deleted so I don't get it.

By now, you must have known why this happens, but my question is how to avoid this so our posts aren't deleted when such a thread is deleted.

Most of the time, I noticed that it is the new threads in bitcoin discussions or other discussion boards that are deleted more often. What I do is if I find a new thread that is opened (and the topic is a somewhat generic one), I would not post in that thread. If that thread is to be deleted, it may be done in 24 to 48 hours, and if it is still there, it means that it won't go anywhere. 

[Mrbluntzy]

@takuma sato, other member have already informed you the reason behind what you complained about, but I had to ask, do you use the Bitcointalk Notifier (https://t.me/BTTSuperNotifier_bot) on telegram? If you don't, you can set it up and grant it permission to notify you when any of your post gets deleted. Whether the entire thread got nuked or only your post was deleted in an existing thread, the bot will mention the post that was deleted. See example of what I mean on the post of Charles-Tim.

While setting up the bot, click on the "Notifications" it will show you all the mentions that you should allow, such as "deleted post" Touch it to enable the notification.
How to set the bot is on this thread https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5248878.msg54441882#msg54441882