Can Bitcointalk Detect AI-Automated Posting Bots?

[Fivestar4everMVP]

It's not an AI bot that will accurately detect whether a text was written by AI or not.

There're some AI content detectors that could be very helpful to some extent to find AI phrases but I agree that none of those will accurately detect AI content especially when that content is supported by prompts that make the AI content sound like human written text.

It is you, as a human being who knows the language and how people speak/write, who, upon reading a text, realizes that something doesn't add up. Then, using the tools you deem appropriate, you conduct your analysis and draw the respective conclusions.

At this time there're people who can detect AI written content just by looking at the content but I'm very sure the negative ones who try their best to make AI content undetectable know that thing and they also do their best to trick AI content detectors, and also to trick the humans who're good at detecting AI content.

Sorry but I do not agree that there are human who are accurately detect if a post or written by Ai or not, if the AI detector bots or apps still can't consistently and efficiently detect posts written by Ai, what make you think any human can do it better?

I've once tried an Ai detector tool on few of my own posts which I wrote myself and the Ai detector said the post was written by Ai even when me myself can spot few errors in about one or two of the post, and i wondered if Ai also make mistakes in some of their posts, from that day, I stopped believing 100% in this Ai detection tools used to check if a post was written or generated by Ai or not..

And if this tools arent perfect but still make mistakes, then I won't trust any human to do a perfect job in detecting Ai written or generated posts either.

[Lucius]

~snip~
Recently, I started experimenting with an AI agent to manage some of my social handles. Out of curiosity, an idea came to my mind — what if this same automation was used here?

In translation, this would mean "I don't want to spend too much time on social networks, so AI will do it for me."

This Post has been rephrased by AI not written by AI so Please don't delete this post MOD

I already wrote to you that if you can't write a post without using AI, you shouldn't be writing on the forum. If AI changed only part of what you wrote in your own words, it is no longer your work but partial plagiarism that you and your friends are fighting to make legal.

[alegotardo]

There is ample evidence, all over the internet, of how bad AI is at detecting AI. False positives are enormous.

On the other hand, AI is becoming increasingly intelligent, so it will increasingly produce texts that are more difficult to understand as if they were created by it.

Therefore, it's pointless to have a battalion of bots or a team of special moderators chasing after any posts created by AI. This only consumes time and resources. The best way to combat this is through interaction with the user who may be the offender. Any member can do this if they find something strange, by interacting with the moderator and then reporting it.

Why is interaction minimally effective? Because AI can be very intelligent, but it follows patterns and, to a certain extent, lacks initiative. A human is different. A human expresses thoughts, feelings, and ideas in a logical and coherent way. Besides, and no offense intended, humans can sometimes be a little unintelligent... 

So, if they want to fight AI, they interact with whoever they think makes posts that are 100% AI-powered.

I agree with you!
I've been picking up some random posts that, in my opinion, were is not generated by AI, and their false positives are sometimes impressive, just as other posts with a "strange pattern" go unnoticed with IA.

I've been following the complaint threads in the reputation tab and really nothing replaces human analysis and interpretation. It is very easy compare messages before and after someone starts using AI and see how they suddenly change their writing style.

Or sometimes a really "crazy" paragraph in the middle of a post that makes we read again and again it several times to try understand... those are grotesque errors.

In short, I think AI is a good ally for finding information and helping with a response, but the final writing should always be done by a human, and if it is not... someday it will be caught, we do not need a bot for that.