It looks like this is intended for scalping, It's interesting that using a 1:3 ratio sounds logical and we have a better chance here, it's just that my question is what about the real profit? because getting a big profit comes from how many trades you make from that 3% take profit, if the stop loss is touched more than the profit itself, this requires us to take a position which cannot have more fluctuations than the position we take, it also depends on the leverage we use too, right?
I prefer trades that have a long term time and my stop loss is no more than 15% to prevent annoying wicks.
You're absolutely right, it depends on the style.
What I do is closer to scalping/day trading: tighter stops, quicker targets, more trades. With 1:3, I aim for smaller but consistent gains. The profit comes from compounding over many trades, not from one big move.
And yes, leverage matters too. I usually keep it between 5x and 10x, so the 1% stop is still manageable.
Your 15% stop-loss makes sense for swing trading, it gives room to breathe and avoids getting stopped out by wicks. I respect that approach, it's just not my style.
Thanks for sharing your perspective, always useful to see how other traders think.