Bitcoin Forum
November 18, 2026, 06:58:41 PM *
News: Latest Bitcoin Core release: 32.1 [Torrent]
 
   Home   Help Search Login Register More  
Pages: [1]
  Print  
Author Topic: First time Multisig advice  (Read 79 times)
seolein (OP)
Member
**
Offline

Activity: 102
Merit: 28


View Profile
November 17, 2026, 03:26:06 PM
Last edit: November 17, 2026, 03:40:31 PM by seolein
Merited by ABCbits (1), DireWolfM14 (1), Mia Chloe (1)
 #1

hello all,

I was one of the pretty lucky users who managed to save his (...and parent) funds from the coldcard hack by having a (super weak, I only found that out later....) passphrase. I was on holiday and left immediately to drive home 6hours in the middle of the night to move the funds back to my old ledger nano s wallet... my crazy story for this year and since then I have been getting super paranoid with self custody, especially with all those AI hacks accelerating...

I got a bitbox a month later but still, there is a constant feeling of unease lurking by having to trust one device/one vendor, so I decided it is time to setup multisig, since i am also quite tech savy. after some research my idea for the setup is to use my old hardware wallets as well as the bitbox.. appreciate any advice, if this is good enough or I am missing something...

2-3 Multisg with latest version of Sparrow 2.5.6 (verified dmg file) on Mac

Device 1: Bitbox02 (24 word device generated seed I currently use for single sig setup)
Decice 2: Coldcard MK3 (updated to the latest firmware, already generated a 12 word seed with old macbook and TailOS completely offline, then imported into Coldcard)
Device 3: My old Ledger Nano S (24 word device generated seed I have been using before for single sig) - if the device at some point is causing issues I plan to replace it with a simple blockstream jade

Initially I wanted a 12 word seed for each device to make it "easier", but since I already have the two 24word seeds of the bitbox and Ledger Nano S backed up in mutliple locations, it would be easier to just use them now for the multisig as well, also they both seem to only be able to generate a new seed with 24 words, not 12... so I would have to use TailOS again for them to have 12 word seeds.

The wallet descriptor I plan to print out and put it in all backup locations, and also have it in my 1password manager and also uploaded to ProtonMail (encrypted).

I will run bitcoin core in prune mode and connect with Sparrow for added privacy.

any further tips much appreciated..!

DireWolfM14
Legendary
*
Online Online

Activity: 3052
Merit: 6144


فلسطين


View Profile WWW
November 17, 2026, 04:44:25 PM
Merited by ABCbits (1), Mia Chloe (1)
 #2

I was one of the pretty lucky users who managed to save his (...and parent) funds from the coldcard hack by having a (super weak, I only found that out later....) passphrase.

It doesn't take much, but the stronger the better, of course.

Initially I wanted a 12 word seed for each device to make it "easier", but since I already have the two 24word seeds of the bitbox and Ledger Nano S backed up in mutliple locations, it would be easier to just use them now for the multisig as well, also they both seem to only be able to generate a new seed with 24 words, not 12... so I would have to use TailOS again for them to have 12 word seeds.

I've gotten to the point where I don't want to trust any device to generate seeds for me.  I'm not saying that all devices are untrustworthy, but if you have an opportunity to not rely on trust; why trust?

Since you'll be generating seeds, you might as well go the extra step and use dice rolls or coin flips to generate your own entropy.  Sure, it takes some extra time and care, but in the long run it'll provide invaluable peace of mind.  Use Sparrow in an off-line configuration to derive the 24th word.  Use strong passphrases as well.

Sparrow can also help you set up the multi-sig wallet.  Don't forget to extract the XPUBs (and ZPUBs for Electrum) if you want to create a watch only wallet on your main PC.

The wallet descriptor I plan to print out and put it in all backup locations, and also have it in my 1password manager and also uploaded to ProtonMail (encrypted).

A well hidden document safe coupled with some fire/water resistant bags is the best storage strategy for your seeds and passphrases.  Again, a few hundred dollars worth of invaluable insurance to make sure your assets are protected.  Don't rely solely on digital backups.

I will run bitcoin core in prune mode and connect with Sparrow for added privacy.

Good strategy.

Zaguru12
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1610
Merit: 1344



View Profile WWW
November 17, 2026, 05:01:49 PM
 #3

Great idea for a multi sig, a Separate device (although I don’t like two of the hardware wallet choices) for each signer is something I definitely appreciate because it actually eliminates the problem of having one single point of failure when using one device or two or more signer on one device.

For the seedphrase I will advice if you can have acces to your back up locations to update your seed phrase you should try to generate new seed phrases and not use the already existing one, although with multi sig set up even if one has been compromised you it won’t affect the wallet.

I will also say you should be careful with the wallet descriptor you save on 1password and protonmail. Do not name it anything related to bitcoin wallet descriptor or have any private keys backed up there. Without this if there is any compromization the hacker will only get access to your public key

.◼.◼.Vega.bet.◼.◼.██
██
██
██
██
██
██
██
██
██
██
██
██

...100 FS + 750% BONUS..MAX.WIN.$5,000...

███...FAST PAYOUTS  |  NO KYC  |  10% LOSSBACK...███
██
██
██
██
██
██
██
██
██
██
██
██
██

...Play Now...
Mia Chloe
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1260
Merit: 2323


Contact me for you designs...


View Profile
November 17, 2026, 06:38:25 PM
 #4

~snip
I’ll stick with what direwolfm14 is suggesting. The problem that came from the entire cold card disaster was just weak entropy that was exploited. Although he suggested generating your own entropy , it makes sense but I’ll actually recommend that you do multiple tests first so you get used to it.

Personally for me I’d prefer a regular seed phrase but with a couple of custom words added. I strongly doubt that those who added custom words were affected too. However in this case you are also trusting your entropy from your source to be strong and safe.

BitMaxz
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 4172
Merit: 3706


#kycfree ❎


View Profile WWW
Today at 12:00:11 AM
 #5

That's a good plan to have a secured multisig wallet but there are a few flaws here that I think you need to change/added.

The first thing is reusing the seed phrase from your single sig setup. I prepared to generate a fresh one from a cold storage or offline device. You can later import your old wallet or single sig setup once you complete the multisig wallet.

My reason is we do not know how safe your seed backup is in your #1 and #3 wallets. If those wallets already reach the internet or connect this hardware wallet to a device that is connected to the internet, there's a chance that these two wallets are already compromised that you don't know yet.
So having a fresh one will make them safer than reusing old seeds.

Another flaw that I notice is why you saved your backup on this "1Password manager and also uploaded to ProtonMail (encrypted)." Any cloud-based or even in-encrypted ProtonMain that's not safe to save backup keys.
It's way safer if you have offline backup like paper backup but vulnerable to fire and water, so the best option is to have a 3-cryptosteel capsule.

ABCbits
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 3794
Merit: 10508



View Profile
Today at 08:03:52 AM
 #6

Decice 2: Coldcard MK3 (updated to the latest firmware, already generated a 12 word seed with old macbook and TailOS completely offline, then imported into Coldcard)

Have you checked whether the 12 word was generated with strong RNG source (such as /dev/urandom)?

so I decided it is time to setup multisig, since i am also quite tech savy.
--snip--
any further tips much appreciated..!

Despite you being tech savvy, it has higher complexity. So if i were you, i would also
1. test whether you actually can restore access to your Bitcoin based on the backup you create.
2. write some details of your setup and store it securely.

promise444c5
Legendary
*
Offline

Activity: 1204
Merit: 1271


All things are numbers


View Profile WWW
Today at 09:30:58 AM
 #7

Another flaw that I notice is why you saved your backup on this "1Password manager and also uploaded to ProtonMail (encrypted)." Any cloud-based or even in-encrypted ProtonMain that's not safe to save backup keys.
It's way safer if you have offline backup like paper backup but vulnerable to fire and water, so the best option is to have a 3-cryptosteel capsule.
It depends on how weak the password used for deriving the key is but its almost same as having it just backed up offline as the password still have to be saved offline..  if they lose it, they lose the digital backup as well .

Unless OP chooses a weak one that  they can memorize off-hand, which again defeat the whole purpose of the encryption in the first place [they risk weak password, and a possibility of forgetting the password]

To me, the process itself is just like having an extra means of backup, with the possibility of that harvested backup getting compromised later in the future.. But of course, no one can tell what the future holds.

Pages: [1]
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.19 | SMF © 2006-2009, Simple Machines Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!