Has anyone actually asked signature campaign managers why they choose to make participants' BTC addresses public?
We already have campaigns that keep addresses private, such as AntiSwap, and plenty of campaigns that publish them. So both approaches are clearly possible, and managers are free to choose.
I'd be particularly interested in hearing from managers who run campaigns with public addresses. Have they considered the private approach and deliberately rejected it? If so, what were their reasons? Or is it simply a matter of following the established practice?
I think their firsthand experience would be more useful here than our speculation about what might or might not be convenient for them.
Something like this?
[OPEN] AntiSwap Signature Campaign | 10+ slots | up to 125/w. in BTC | 5$ Bonus this campaign practice exactly what you're proposing in your Op. You don't even know who are the participants and how much they are being paid because the application process is through external platforms. The campaign is still on Open status but there's no more applications since Oct 23rd. I don't know maybe people are not longer interested to participate in it or they're just not comfortable with that format.
As for convenience for users, I can share my own experience.
This summer, Bitfinex asked me to provide proof of the source of funds I had deposited there. At the time, I was participating in the b1exch signature campaign managed by
icopress. I provided my application post, the manager's post confirming that I had been accepted, and the posts mentioning the payments (it didn't occur to me to show them the spreadsheet). That's rock-solid evidence of where the funds came from.
Then, in the autumn, the electronic wallet provider emoney.ge asked me for the same thing. But this time, the funds came from the AntiSwap campaign, where that information isn't public. I submitted screenshots of my conversations, and I was worried they wouldn't be enough, since screenshots are easy to fake. They turned out to be sufficient, but I have to admit that I felt much more comfortable when everything was public. I knew for sure that as long as the exchange's compliance team was doing its job honestly, they would have absolutely nothing to question.
Bitcoin's transparency is one of its most underrated strengths.