Most members are already used to the current system. There are still plenty of ways to maintain anonymity and privacy, so I don't think keeping wallet addresses private needs to become a new standard for signature campaigns.
(...)
You can only maintain anonymity only if you take the right precautions from your very first day on the forum. If you ever linked your forum profile with your real identity, you are not and will never be anonymous again, unless you start a new forum account.
Linking your forum profile with your identity can be as trivial as buying something with btc or using KYC exchange and transacting from an address you posted as yours on the forum, even just once in the past.
Already in many jurisdictions CEXs are forced to keep records of users' crypto addresses and might be asked to hand the details over to authorities even for routine checks where there's no active investigation.
I don't think many people fully realise the potential implications of having "an extra income on the side". Especially in the poorer countries where income from high-paying campaigns can be viewed as significant and can attract the attention of the tax man.
In some jurisdictions, reporting extra crypto income (and paying tax on it) can be really straightforward, while in others you would be required to register as a business/self-employed (which could come with a requirement of making full social service contributions etc), and even if you do that, you would have to comply with all the record-keeping requirements, like storing invoices etc, which you won't have as a campaign participant, making it effectively impossible to be compliant.
As the AI/tracking technology grows, tracking can be done routinely and fully automatically in the near future (if not done already), without the need to start an investigation against a specific individual.
And that's just one example of why some would (or should) want to keep their income private.
I read a thread recently about a user who had to submit source of funds to an exchange or a casino. He did this by putting together the campaign spreadsheet, thread showing he was accepted and payment details, if I remember it right.
(...)
Well, a very similar thing happened to me over a year ago on one of the exchanges (which was meant to be KYC-free). I posted on that here:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5535311.0To be fair, I don't think a lot of those services know what they're doing in terms of checking the origins of your funds, and they would accept any explanation as long as it somewhat makes sense. Also, you could prove your campaign earnings without making your address public, i.e. by showing your account got accepted and proving that you own that account (there are simple ways of doing that).
Some have mentioned that having payment addresses public helps detect those who abuse the rules by using multiple accounts. That's a good argument, but I'm not sure how common this problem is and if it's a good trade-off for increased privacy. Plus, campaign abusers would probably learn eventually not to link their payments to one wallet/address.