What Do You Want in a Signature Campaign?

[marcotheminer]

UPDATE

I am looking at your comments now. I will be working hard to make sure that from the next term onwards, the BIT-X campaign will be the best ever (as it has been already). Automated weekly payments, no minimum/maximum posts, no tough rules, automatic registration , payments to your own personal addresses and, of course, the highest payments per post on the board will be the things I will aim to include. Stay tuned.


I'm interested to know to make changes the community wants to the BIT-X signature campaign (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=877765.0).

What would make you change signature campaigns?

Things that are currently in place:
Highest rates
0.1BTC x 10 bonuses to highest posters
Monthly payments
Payments made to addresses from user BIT-X.com accounts

[1714965118]

1714965118

[1714965118]

1714965118

[1714965118]

1714965118

[1714965118]

1714965118

[superSTAR777]

Though i know i wont be accepted in this campaign but i would like -

1) faster payment - weekly or bi-weekly

2) Payment automated ( if possible )

[redsn0w]

Maybe a page where we can see our "activity" , posts made each day, how much "btc we can earn each day". Thanks for the attention !

[Ume]

Maybe a page where we can see our "activity" , posts made each day, how much "btc we can earn each day". Thanks for the attention !

If anyone cares, I have just released my Chrome browser extension that keeps track of how much you have earned right now. The source code can be found on Github. Why post it here? Because people might like it and I'm to lazy to create a [ANN] thread.

Old screenshot:

this will help you !

[erwin45hacked]

I'm interested to know to make changes the community wants to the BIT-X signature campaign (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=877765.0).

What would make you change signature campaigns?

Things that are currently in place:
Highest rates
0.1BTC x 10 bonuses to highest posters
Monthly payments
Payments made to addresses from user BIT-X.com accounts

1. Weekly Payment if possible
2. Payment to user select address,

bit-x is pretty much great sig campaign, highesh paying sig campaign up to date by now, hope to join the sig campaign once i hit FM 

[redsn0w]

Maybe a page where we can see our "activity" , posts made each day, how much "btc we can earn each day". Thanks for the attention !

If anyone cares, I have just released my Chrome browser extension that keeps track of how much you have earned right now. The source code can be found on Github. Why post it here? Because people might like it and I'm to lazy to create a [ANN] thread.

Old screenshot:

this will help you !

Thanks , I already use that extension . I've discovered it a few months ago (maybe before august) thanks to bitcoininformation aka Mitchełł  . However my it was a request for a "page", as the bitmixer site but with more features.

Maybe marcotheminer can link his actual bot to a page wherein we can insert our forum account id and see all the stats.

[foxkyu]

Things that are currently in place:
Highest rates
0.1BTC x 10 bonuses to highest posters
Monthly payments
Payments made to addresses from user BIT-X.com accounts

maybe you can change the payment from monthly weekly or bi-weekly
faster payment will be good
so user can use their btc for trading or shopping

[Exmortem]

Weekly payments. The rates are magnificent it's just that the payday comes once every month.

[yahoo62278]

payments to users wallets, not to their bit-x accounts. my opinion but forcing ppl to sign up for a service they may or may never use is an invasion. thats just my opinion. also weekly or bi weekly payments. not to mention maybe changing pay structure depending on the current btc price. the bonuses are a good add.

[Quickseller]

The ability to receive payment to your own bitcoin address (this is a must).

Special rates for special members

[TriggerX]

On time payment no late payment

[feryjhie]

The ability to receive payment to your own bitcoin address (this is a must).

Special rates for special members

agree with payment to the bitcoin address not on the bit-x wallet

special rate for special member I do not agree because it would not be fair to the other members of the same rank

[Quickseller]

special rate for special member I do not agree because it would not be fair to the other members of the same rank

Well if you are highly respected within the community then you can potentially command a premium for your signature space. The reason being is that people tend to look at/read your posts more closely then they look at others, when they see that you posted something they will be more likely to read a thread/post they would not have otherwise look at

[botany]

I am very uncomfortable giving my mobile number out.
Don't want to link my online and offline ids. 

So either signing up for a BitX account should not require a mobile number, or payment for the Bitcoin signature campaign should be made to a personal BTC address.

[mriulian]

high rates ...which comes with a bigger limit of posts per week...something like 30-40...of course constructive posts..

[izanagi narukami]

I am very uncomfortable giving my mobile number out.
Don't want to link my online and offline ids.  

So either signing up for a BitX account should not require a mobile number, or payment for the Bitcoin signature campaign should be made to a personal BTC address.

There's are a ton of available mobile number you can buy
Don't use this number for your daily if you fell it disturb your privacy
, use it only when you need to log in into bit-x.

About signature campaign, I prefer monthly pay out with 50 post. (more frugal for bit-x expense) and there will give more participant to join.
The payrate of course base on bitcoin's value recently

example : 0.15 for 50 post per month  

or if you need to keep more exposure, then ppp scheme with weekly payout is the best offer and looks like majority agree with this option

[Dogedigital]

While I understand the requests to be paid immediately to their bitcoin wallet for ease, we must understand that the reason why these signature campaigns exist is to generate sales and drive traffic towards their site.

It takes a minimal amount of time to sign up to the site that is feeding you, and takes a short time to withdraw from their sites to your bitcoin wallets.  If there doesn't stand a chance to convert traffic into sales, then these services where you basically get free money will soon cease to exist.

[doggieTattoo]

While I understand the requests to be paid immediately to their bitcoin wallet for ease, we must understand that the reason why these signature campaigns exist is to generate sales and drive traffic towards their site.

It takes a minimal amount of time to sign up to the site that is feeding you, and takes a short time to withdraw from their sites to your bitcoin wallets.  If there doesn't stand a chance to convert traffic into sales, then these services where you basically get free money will soon cease to exist.

There is no benefit to the website to have campaign participants receive payouts to their account. All that does is create the illusion that more people are signing up for accounts when they are really just using the accounts to receive payouts and nothing more.

Plus they do charge ridiculous fees to withdraw funds.

[Abbey_j]

Higher rate, after the Bitcoin had dropped a lot. And would like to see a weekly payment.

[izanagi narukami]

While I understand the requests to be paid immediately to their bitcoin wallet for ease, we must understand that the reason why these signature campaigns exist is to generate sales and drive traffic towards their site.

Yeah and I know the reason why marco & bit-x doing this, I have no problem with this one.

But what can we said, everyone like an easy money.

There is no benefit to the website to have campaign participants receive payouts to their account. All that does is create the illusion that more people are signing up for accounts when they are really just using the accounts to receive payouts and nothing more.

Plus they do charge ridiculous fees to withdraw funds.

At least we know what we advertise about.
Bit-x can be our reference or consideration for the future to use it as our partner for trading or hashing

[doggieTattoo]

There is no benefit to the website to have campaign participants receive payouts to their account. All that does is create the illusion that more people are signing up for accounts when they are really just using the accounts to receive payouts and nothing more.

Plus they do charge ridiculous fees to withdraw funds.

At least we know what we advertise about.
Bit-x can be our reference or consideration for the future to use it as our partner for trading or hashing

If anyone were to ever ask me anything I am advertising I would probably either ignore them or refer them to the "official" thread.

Their signature campaign participants are not reflecting well on bit-x because they all know about their ridiculous w/d fees so that will probably be the first thing that comes out of their mouth when asked.

 

[Big0Bang]

No language limiti - Yes, wo don't like posters making posts only in their local section, and sure, in their local language, this is absolutely  unqualitified, But if participants makes posts in mutiple section with most in English and some in other languange, I think this could be qualitified, then "English posts only" shouldn't be here.

[onlyyou]

higher rates for full member or below and post in local section is count not only in english because not all
in this forum can speak english include me and my english is still very bad...

[legendster]

I'm interested to know to make changes the community wants to the BIT-X signature campaign (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=877765.0).

What would make you change signature campaigns?

Things that are currently in place:
Highest rates
0.1BTC x 10 bonuses to highest posters
Monthly payments
Payments made to addresses from user BIT-X.com accounts

Two things,
Consider negative rated people, not everyone that gets negative rating is a scammer, some have simply reported a scammer and the scammer has posted a revenge feedback on their profile or someone has taken out a grudge on someone based on their assumptions.

AND

Also consider using this tool https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=943440.0

It could be quite handy for you guys.

[Kprawn]

My list

1. Well, automated and no late payments.
2. No more than 50 posts per month to decrease spam on the forum.
3. Easy signup and personal notification, when signature or rules has changed.
4. Rates must be equal or higher than competitors.
5. Reliable Escrow, when the signature campaign has no prior record of hosting a campaign on this forum. 

It bugs me to no end, if I have to constantly work hard to keep up with minimum post limits, when it should only promote the campaign with daily normal posting.

[arallmuus]

My list

1. Well, automated and no late payments.
2. No more than 50 posts per month to decrease spam on the forum.
3. Easy signup and personal notification, when signature or rules has changed.
4. Rates must be equal or higher than competitors.
5. Reliable Escrow, when the signature campaign has no prior record of hosting a campaign on this forum. 

It bugs me to no end, if I have to constantly work hard to keep up with minimum post limits, when it should only promote the campaign with daily normal posting.

yep indeed, it is bugging me aswell, i may/may not have time to post, so having a minimum post is pretty much uncomfortable for me, that is the reason i joined up bitmixer

and also I believe user want their payout straight directly to their address of choice

[hilariousandco]

I'm interested to know to make changes the community wants to the BIT-X signature campaign (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=877765.0).

What would make you change signature campaigns?

Things that are currently in place:
Highest rates
0.1BTC x 10 bonuses to highest posters
Monthly payments
Payments made to addresses from user BIT-X.com accounts

Well personally I'd only change if PrimeDice ceased offering their deal, but I'd go for the highest paying though there are other caveats. I think people like bitmixer because of the following:

Automated payments
Weekly payments
No minimum posting requirement
Simple sign up
Reliable/trustworthy

Even if campaigns pay a little more than your one people would likely stick with it because of the reasons above so I think you'd be better off trying to find a unique angle. 

[irfan_pak10]

I just want two changes
1. Make payment weekly or biweekly
2. Make payments directly to our btc address.

Else every thing is fine for me

Thanks

[aurel57]

I'm interested to know to make changes the community wants to the BIT-X signature campaign (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=877765.0).

What would make you change signature campaigns?

Things that are currently in place:
Highest rates
0.1BTC x 10 bonuses to highest posters
Monthly payments
Payments made to addresses from user BIT-X.com accounts

1. Weekly Payment if possible
2. Payment to user select address,

bit-x is pretty much great sig campaign, highesh paying sig campaign up to date by now, hope to join the sig campaign once i hit FM  

I agree with this!

I also like the idea about limits on numbers of post to fight spam, so as far as I am concerned you can drop the bonus program.

[Muhammed Zakir]

=snip=

1. Weekly Payment if possible
2. Payment to user select address,

bit-x is pretty much great sig campaign, highesh paying sig campaign up to date by now, hope to join the sig campaign once i hit FM 

I agree with this!

I also like the idea about limits on numbers of post to fight spam, so as far as I am concerned you can drop the bonus program.

I agree with you both! Please make weekly or biweekly payments and to user's address. Dropping the bonus and limiting the post count to =<300 would be a good idea too.

   -MZ

[ajaxmoor]

I don't mind being paid to addresses on their site, but the biggest thing that can improve it is Weekly payouts(maybe after automation, that would work out).
Currently, campaigns like bitmixer pay 0.0007 per month.  and BIT-X pays 0.0008. If I was to make say 100 post a month, then that would be a difference of 0.01 per month, and I won't mind giving that up to be paid weekly.

[thebitcoinquiz.com]

Your campaign has everything except for two things-
1) Weekly Payments
2) Automated Payments

[cazkooo]

I don't mind being paid to addresses on their site, but the biggest thing that can improve it is Weekly payouts(maybe after automation, that would work out).
Currently, campaigns like bitmixer pay 0.0007 per month.  and BIT-X pays 0.0008. If I was to make say 100 post a month, then that would be a difference of 0.01 per month, and I won't mind giving that up to be paid weekly.

bitmixer is 0.0007/post max 0.035 which is 50 post
so if a week you post up 50,
50 post x 4 weeks = 0.035 x 4 = 0.14
then you will get 0.14/month

and bit X paying 0.0008/post
if you are making 200 posts also
u will gain
0.0008x200 = 0.16

which is only 0.02 difference but bitmixer got no minimum post and autmated payment, so people tend to go to bitmixer

in short bit-x is good for heavy poster while bitmixer without minimum post is pretty great for those that dont post much

[Mr Tea]

People really don't like signing up to websites to receive their coins though it's good to get some hits from the business side of it. I don't think signing up would be that big of a deal if there was a higher rate for doing so or some sort of incentive.

[monbux]

Weekly payments. The rates are magnificent it's just that the payday comes once every month.

This.  Weekly payments sounds great but tbh its already going pretty well right now.

[pooya87]

Highest rates
this is good

0.1BTC x 10 bonuses to highest posters
i never count on something that might happen!

Monthly payments
i only join if it is weekly

Payments made to addresses from user BIT-X.com accounts
i only join if it is to my own address not on website!

additionally
i like my signature for having automatic payment, no minimum, no hassle, no lies like (i had family emergency so i couldn't prepare the payment list so 5 days delay) etc etc

also i hear you have to register on bit-x and give personal info, thats not cool

[michietn94]

Option 1
Less spamming on this forum, the campaign will still exist for a long time such like luckyb.it

choose : monthly payout with high payrate


Option 2
More exposure for the forum but require more expense

choose : pay per post and weekly


Overall I looked , everybody choose option 2

[Quickseller]

Option 1
Less spamming on this forum, the campaign will still exist for a long time such like luckyb.it

choose : monthly payout with high payrate

luckyb.it is probably the worse campaign the forum has ever seen, at least of the ones that have actually paid.

His rules make it difficult to find enough people to fill his budget while paying participants significiently more then other comparable campaigns. He is giving the owners of luckyb.it the worse of everything just to satisfy his own political beliefs.

[Brewins]

alternative to sms verification.

Took some weeks for me until I got the SMS verification.

I would not complain about receiving in my own address, though.

And of course I would never complain about receiving more by post

[Herbert2020]

i like the weekly payment, also prefer the highest rate but the weekly thing has priority for me. also don't like the whole sign up in our website first thing

[botany]

His rules make it difficult to find enough people to fill his budget

The demand for senior member slots is unbelievable. 

[Quickseller]

His rules make it difficult to find enough people to fill his budget

The demand for senior member slots is unbelievable. 

that is the case now, however I believe he has full member slots open and in the past he has had trouble filling senior slots.

Additionally the GAW canpaign just ended which had over a hundred participants which explains the current demand.

[NeuroticFish]

My votes would go for faster payment rounds (bi-weekly would be already great) and payment to the user's wallet.

However, until now Bit-X is a better signature campaign for me than most - it's more flexible on where to post and also the minimum number of posts is really easy to reach - no stress.

[marcotheminer]

UPDATE

I am looking at your comments now. I will be working hard to make sure that from the next term onwards, the BIT-X campaign will be the best ever (as it has been already). Automated weekly payments, no minimum/maximum posts, no tough rules, automatic registration , payments to your own personal addresses and, of course, the highest payments per post on the board will be the things I will aim to include. Stay tuned.

[Biitcoin]

What could be really good is :

• Paying Directly to Bitcoin Adresses instead of Bit-x account
• Weekly payments (not sure how the top posters system should work here)
• Another extra bonus for people who are top posters for x months (3 months or something)

[marcotheminer]

What could be really good is :

• Paying Directly to Bitcoin Adresses instead of Bit-x account
• Weekly payments (not sure how the top posters system should work here)
• Another extra bonus for people who are top posters for x months (3 months or something)

Top poster bonuses would be removed. It woudn't be needed due to such a high per post rate and weekly payments to your own wallet.

[Biitcoin]

What could be really good is :

• Paying Directly to Bitcoin Adresses instead of Bit-x account
• Weekly payments (not sure how the top posters system should work here)
• Another extra bonus for people who are top posters for x months (3 months or something)

Top poster bonuses would be removed. It woudn't be needed due to such a high per post rate and weekly payments to your own wallet.

But there well be no maximum posts ?? I mean if someone makes 5000 posts (example) he gets paid for 5000 posts (contructive of course) , If that's the case then all good and fine .

[chaolang]

I would love to have weekly payments especially for a post based campaign.

[marcotheminer]

What could be really good is :

• Paying Directly to Bitcoin Adresses instead of Bit-x account
• Weekly payments (not sure how the top posters system should work here)
• Another extra bonus for people who are top posters for x months (3 months or something)

Top poster bonuses would be removed. It woudn't be needed due to such a high per post rate and weekly payments to your own wallet.

But there well be no maximum posts ?? I mean if someone makes 5000 posts (example) he gets paid for 5000 posts (contructive of course) , If that's the case then all good and fine .

No maximum posts. If someone does make 5000 constructive posts (I doubt they'd be constructive if someone made so many) they'd be paid for every single one of them.

Of course, if I see a major rise in spam then there will be bans and possible maximums put in place.

[Biitcoin]

Then it's cool .
I just checked your signature compaign , the rules are going to stay the same ? (no Off topic posts , no posts on other languages .. english only) ?

[marcotheminer]

Then it's cool .
I just checked your signature compaign , the rules are going to stay the same ? (no Off topic posts , no posts on other languages .. english only) ?

There will be slight rule changes. Off-topic of course still won't be paid. However local board posts in your own language may be paid if they aren't spam.

[Biitcoin]

Then it's cool .
I just checked your signature compaign , the rules are going to stay the same ? (no Off topic posts , no posts on other languages .. english only) ?

There will be slight rule changes. Off-topic of course still won't be paid. However local board posts in your own language may be paid if they aren't spam.

It's official , there is no PrimeDice or anything else . Bit-x signature is the best I will join next month then when the all those changes are made .

[chaolang]

When will all this be announced in thread/come into effect?
Also what happens if for example I start the campaign as a senior and become hero half way through?

[marcotheminer]

When will all this be announced in thread/come into effect?
Also what happens if for example I start the campaign as a senior and become hero half way through?

For the next term which starts after the 28th of this month.

If you change rank and the payout is automatic weekly you'll be paid at the rank you joined. If I keep an automatic monthly payment then you'll be paid at the rank you have become.

[jarvanIV]

an ideal signature would be something with automatic payment system?

similar to the old bitmixers thing.

[ivonna]

I would like to see the ability to see somewhat real time stats (delayed by ~24 hours should be okay) of earnings and other campaign related stats (for example join date, starting post count, ect).

Another suggestion would be to have it so posts in various sections are wroth different amounts, for example posts in the off topic sections would be worth very little while posts in the marketplace and mining sections would be worth more

[(Lithium)]

Then it's cool .
I just checked your signature compaign , the rules are going to stay the same ? (no Off topic posts , no posts on other languages .. english only) ?

There will be slight rule changes. Off-topic of course still won't be paid. However local board posts in your own language may be paid if they aren't spam.

but how can you verify if local board posts are not spam?

[Muhammed Zakir]

Then it's cool .
I just checked your signature compaign , the rules are going to stay the same ? (no Off topic posts , no posts on other languages .. english only) ?

There will be slight rule changes. Off-topic of course still won't be paid. However local board posts in your own language may be paid if they aren't spam.

but how can you verify if local board posts are not spam?

He will check posts in local boards manually and he can understand what the topic is about  and what the post is by translating it.

   -MZ

[marcotheminer]

an ideal signature would be something with automatic payment system?

Already have that in the plans!

[Blazed]

My only suggestion is the payment to a regular BTC address. I think this campaign is run very well...payment is good. Well done so far Marco!

[BitCoinNutJob]

I guess everyone would say this and only the bitcoin businesses can decide their budget but if the price stays this low i'd vote my number 1 want as higher rates.  Its not like bit-x isn't paying the highest rate vs other campaigns already afaik so understandable to keep pay the same.

[marcotheminer]

My only suggestion is the payment to a regular BTC address. I think this campaign is run very well...payment is good. Well done so far Marco!

Thank you!

[Quickseller]

I guess everyone would say this and only the bitcoin businesses can decide their budget but if the price stays this low i'd vote my number 1 want as higher rates.  Its not like bit-x isn't paying the highest rate vs other campaigns already afaik so understandable to keep pay the same.

The current rates that bit-x is paying are in line with what other pay per post campaigns have paid in the past, and in some cases are higher.

I would say with a good amount of certainty that marco will get a good number of additional participants once he offers payments directly to user's btc addresses

[BitCoinNutJob]

I guess everyone would say this and only the bitcoin businesses can decide their budget but if the price stays this low i'd vote my number 1 want as higher rates.  Its not like bit-x isn't paying the highest rate vs other campaigns already afaik so understandable to keep pay the same.

The current rates that bit-x is paying are in line with what other pay per post campaigns have paid in the past, and in some cases are higher.

I would say with a good amount of certainty that marco will get a good number of additional participants once he offers payments directly to user's btc addresses

It doesnt make much difference to me where the deposit goes, the withdraw took 5 minutes last month. I would prefer payments direct but running away with signature campaign funds must be low % chance if we look at what bit-x's outgoings overall must be.

[Quickseller]

I guess everyone would say this and only the bitcoin businesses can decide their budget but if the price stays this low i'd vote my number 1 want as higher rates.  Its not like bit-x isn't paying the highest rate vs other campaigns already afaik so understandable to keep pay the same.

The current rates that bit-x is paying are in line with what other pay per post campaigns have paid in the past, and in some cases are higher.

I would say with a good amount of certainty that marco will get a good number of additional participants once he offers payments directly to user's btc addresses

It doesnt make much difference to me where the deposit goes, the withdraw took 5 minutes last month. I would prefer payments direct but running away with signature campaign funds must be low % chance if we look at what bit-x's outgoings overall must be.

I think it is more privacy and convenience then the fear of them running away with their money (although many bitcoiners prefer to have 100% control over their funds 100% of the time, especially after what happened with gox). By having to provide their phone number as well as being asked to provide personal identifying information (although there are ways around actually giving this) people are giving up a lot of privacy, privacy that holds a lot of value. 

[Muhammed Zakir]

I think it is more privacy and convenience then the fear of them running away with their money (although many bitcoiners prefer to have 100% control over their funds 100% of the time, especially after what happened with gox).

I agree but if they change to weekly, most of them won't care about the payment to Bit-X.

By having to provide their phone number as well as being asked to provide personal identifying information (although there are ways around actually giving this) people are giving up a lot of privacy, privacy that holds a lot of value.  

I heard Google 2FA will be added soon.

Edit:

There is absolutely no need to provide any other personal identifying information than a phone number to signup and withdraw any signature earnings.

Forgot about this.

   -MZ

[marcotheminer]

I guess everyone would say this and only the bitcoin businesses can decide their budget but if the price stays this low i'd vote my number 1 want as higher rates.  Its not like bit-x isn't paying the highest rate vs other campaigns already afaik so understandable to keep pay the same.

The current rates that bit-x is paying are in line with what other pay per post campaigns have paid in the past, and in some cases are higher.

I would say with a good amount of certainty that marco will get a good number of additional participants once he offers payments directly to user's btc addresses

It doesnt make much difference to me where the deposit goes, the withdraw took 5 minutes last month. I would prefer payments direct but running away with signature campaign funds must be low % chance if we look at what bit-x's outgoings overall must be.

I think it is more privacy and convenience then the fear of them running away with their money (although many bitcoiners prefer to have 100% control over their funds 100% of the time, especially after what happened with gox). By having to provide their phone number as well as being asked to provide personal identifying information (although there are ways around actually giving this) people are giving up a lot of privacy, privacy that holds a lot of value. 

There is absolutely no need to provide any other personal identifying information than a phone number to signup and withdraw any signature earnings.