To MtGox, Intersango, etc : This would make your APIs much more secure

[Jason Ling]

Please allow me to restrict the IP addresses that API calls for particular keys are allowed to originate from.

[1713974292]

1713974292

[paraipan]

Please allow me to restrict the IP addresses that API calls for particular keys are allowed to originate from.

+1

[shtylman]

Please allow me to restrict the IP addresses that API calls for particular keys are allowed to originate from.

Do you believe you or someone else has successfully been compromised by having their API accessed from an IP which was not theirs? If you only access from a given IP, why not keep the API key only on that box and not floating around in other places?

To be clear, I am not against this feature but do want to flush out the use case a bit more. Sometimes things that seem like security really just add more headache and little security.

[davout]

Sometimes things that seem like security really just add more headache and little security.

+1

[gweedo]

Please allow me to restrict the IP addresses that API calls for particular keys are allowed to originate from.

that is why they have api keys so that you can remove the key and access stops from the places you use that key

[BitBuster]

Please allow me to restrict the IP addresses that API calls for particular keys are allowed to originate from.

that is why they have api keys so that you can remove the key and access stops from the places you use that key

Yes, but if a key has been compromised, its more preferable that the hacker must break into your server as well to use it, rather than being able to use it from anywhere.

At the very least this should be an option and isn't difficult to implement.


BB.

[Jason Ling]

Please allow me to restrict the IP addresses that API calls for particular keys are allowed to originate from.

Do you believe you or someone else has successfully been compromised by having their API accessed from an IP which was not theirs? If you only access from a given IP, why not keep the API key only on that box and not floating around in other places?

To be clear, I am not against this feature but do want to flush out the use case a bit more. Sometimes things that seem like security really just add more headache and little security.

It really is simply security in depth.

Now by stealing my API keys, an attacker has pretty much full access to my account and all funds in it.

If IP address is restricted, this way he needs to gain control of the IP address as well.

[BCB]

This is implemented in more mature sites, like Perfect Money and Liberty Reserve.
Have they experienced any major hacks?  I don't know.   I think it's easier to to launch a warhead then it is to log in to liberty reserve.

We need current and future bitcoin business to mature.

It is also like fraud at fiat banks and credit card companies.  They expect a certain amount of fraud and write it off and until the pain of writing it off become greater then increasing the security practices.

As long as they are making money and clients use they services there will be little change.

[BCB]

Also, I've discovered a potential security issue with Mt. Gox's Google Auth OTP.  I alerted support last week.  I'm waiting to see if they respond.