Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Bitcoin Discussion => Topic started by: angelinus on May 27, 2016, 04:18:20 PM



Title: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: angelinus on May 27, 2016, 04:18:20 PM
Hey guys so I have sent my bitcoins from an exchange to my wallet and it has been 12+hrs and yet it has not been confirmed. I am not really savvy about bitcoins so could you please tell me what will happen? Thanks ..


https://blockchain.info/tx/39aa391f603be5ee0c52fcf01861207c7fa9a0347b5be8211b1830c17c816c8d


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: cryptoheadd on May 27, 2016, 04:29:09 PM
Yes, the transaction fee that you included with the tx, is only 0.00012, whereas the recommended fee is around 0.0002.
Don't worry, if the address that you've sent the btc to is correct, you'll receive your coins soon enough. ;)

Next time, Include more fees.. :D


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: freshman777 on May 27, 2016, 04:31:55 PM
Stop sending spam.


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: angelinus on May 27, 2016, 04:33:02 PM
Yes, the transaction fee that you included with the tx, is only 0.00012, whereas the recommended fee is around 0.0002.
Don't worry, if the address that you've sent the btc to is correct, you'll receive your coins soon enough. ;)

Next time, Include more fees.. :D

Thanks.. So will it by any chance get cancelled? And if it returns, it is an online exchange with many addresses.. Will the funds be returned to the right address?

and also if it ever gets confirmed.. How long does it take on average?

Sorry for the dumb questions. I know I sound stupid am just new to this.


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: cryptoheadd on May 27, 2016, 04:38:53 PM
Yes, the transaction fee that you included with the tx, is only 0.00012, whereas the recommended fee is around 0.0002.
Don't worry, if the address that you've sent the btc to is correct, you'll receive your coins soon enough. ;)

Next time, Include more fees.. :D

Thanks.. So will it by any chance get cancelled? And if it returns, it is an online exchange with many addresses.. Will the funds be returned to the right address?

and also if it ever gets confirmed.. How long does it take on average?

Sorry for the dumb questions. I know I sound stupid am just new to this.

If you withdrew these funds from an exchange, the transaction won't be cancelled. (Exchanges don't double spend)
Usually it takes around 15-20 mins for a transaction to get confirmed.

And there are no dumb questions, bro. ;)


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: Nobitcoin on May 27, 2016, 04:41:59 PM
I once sent BTC to Yobit and that took 1 day so no 12 hours isn't that long


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: Meuh6879 on May 27, 2016, 04:43:02 PM
it's because of the rise on this beginning of friday.

mempool are almost purged now (5500 transactions on my mempool) ... so, it's strange that it don't have a confirmation now.

http://btc.blockr.io/tx/info/39aa391f603be5ee0c52fcf01861207c7fa9a0347b5be8211b1830c17c816c8d


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: AgentofCoin on May 27, 2016, 04:46:39 PM
Yes, the transaction fee that you included with the tx, is only 0.00012, whereas the recommended fee is around 0.0002.
Don't worry, if the address that you've sent the btc to is correct, you'll receive your coins soon enough. ;)

Next time, Include more fees.. :D

Thanks.. So will it by any chance get cancelled? And if it returns, it is an online exchange with many addresses.. Will the funds be returned to the right address?

and also if it ever gets confirmed.. How long does it take on average?

Sorry for the dumb questions. I know I sound stupid am just new to this.

Over time it will be dropped from the network and will "return" to the address or addresses that tried to sent it.
In theory, the exchange should re-credit your account, since the btc "returned".

If in the future, you can no longer find your transaction still pending, and don't see a credit to your exchange account,
you should contact your exchange since they should have re-credited your account. What exchange did you use?

If it does get confirmed, it will still take a long time and is impossible to accurately determine.
If there are no more new transactions by other people added to the network,
I'd guess it will be confirmed in 28 blocks from now. But that is if no new transactions.

Looking at the current mempool, I'll guess it will return and need to be re-broadcasted.
In order to be placed into the next block, the fee should have been around 0.00065


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: Meuh6879 on May 27, 2016, 04:50:19 PM
with 0,0012 of fees, no chance that it will return.
will be confirmed at night after exchange switch daytime period ...


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: zeaderza on May 27, 2016, 05:30:35 PM
Hello,

You  send a medium amount (~2 btc) and you paid a low fee only (10000 satoshis).You need to wait 1-2 days for confirmation depend on network traffic.In some days blockchain work hard because spams attacks.


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: Snorek on May 27, 2016, 05:36:21 PM
Hey guys so I have sent my bitcoins from an exchange to my wallet and it has been 12+hrs and yet it has not been confirmed. I am not really savvy about bitcoins so could you please tell me what will happen? Thanks ..


https://blockchain.info/tx/39aa391f603be5ee0c52fcf01861207c7fa9a0347b5be8211b1830c17c816c8d
Quick question, Op. What wallet are you using? Also did you set that transaction fee manually or your wallet did it on its own?
If you did it, then in the future please let fee tab on default and not tinker with it. As you can see it is not worth the time.


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: cjmoles on May 27, 2016, 06:47:21 PM
Yes, the transaction fee that you included with the tx, is only 0.00012, whereas the recommended fee is around 0.0002.
Don't worry, if the address that you've sent the btc to is correct, you'll receive your coins soon enough. ;)

Next time, Include more fees.. :D

Thanks.. So will it by any chance get cancelled? And if it returns, it is an online exchange with many addresses.. Will the funds be returned to the right address?

and also if it ever gets confirmed.. How long does it take on average?

Sorry for the dumb questions. I know I sound stupid am just new to this.

Actually, a couple of good questions.  A couple of points: you should always keep your coin on an address in which you control the private key.  If you're making a transaction to a third party from the exchange address you could run into problems....many sites know that it's not secure to send transactions back to the "sending" address and will require a signature verification before doing so, or will just push the transaction back without comment....that could be a hassle!  So, never use an exchange as you would a wallet; always move your funds from the exchange to your personal wallet before engaging in a transaction to another party; you have better and more secure control over your coin that way.  exchange != wallet


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: daynomate on May 29, 2016, 06:00:46 AM
Hey guys I sent ~8BTC about 5 hours ago - including the recommended fee of 0.0056BTC and have not got a single confirmation yet. Surely that's not normal??

I sent it from BT 0.8.6 Wallet on Windows to CoinJar

The weird thing is only minutes earlier I'd sent 0.001 (again with the recommended fee) to the same address and it got 1 confirmation within a minute.


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: Enotche on May 29, 2016, 06:31:34 AM
If you decide to save money on fees - then wait longer.
By the way I noticed that when the rate jumps dramatically it is better to make more commission.

Also I found this:
"Well, the fact that" many translations and remain without evidence or rejected by the system "is generally a normal and correct behavior of the system, which was almost always - because the network is constantly circulating heap transactional spam and simply incorrect transactions and all similar and should be either. immediately rejected or hang in the cache miners for long periods with the lowest processing priority and included in the block only if it still has the "extra" space for which no claim no normal transaction and miner it has found "good" and allow such to their units include.

By accounting including transactions which, in general, do not have to be confirmed or can wait arbitrarily long (ie attributable to the spam category) and the transition from secondary media (as the chart blockchain.info) to the arithmetic average-when a small number of transactions are suspended for days significant shift this very average. "(c)


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: daynomate on May 29, 2016, 06:46:05 AM
That's the thing - I included the recommended fee.

And when I go to blockchain to check the TXID it says it doesn't exist :/


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: Nowl1935 on May 29, 2016, 07:13:21 AM
Same problem bro, They said that its blockchain problem again, ive waiting for my gambling payment 10 hours. It is normal


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: daynomate on May 29, 2016, 07:25:35 AM
Okay cheers. So am I ok to delete my client and wallet now? I've emptied it out wanting to reinstall my PC so I transferred it to exchange for safety =D


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: daynomate on May 30, 2016, 03:48:38 AM
Hmmm.... 26 hours so far :/


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: longbob72 on May 30, 2016, 03:52:46 AM
Hmmm.... 26 hours so far :/

Create your own thread and post your transaction ID (though the answer you'll get is probably the same as most cases: Wait). It's not even clear that the users here are replying to you and not OP.


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: bryant.coleman on May 30, 2016, 03:59:02 AM
The same happened to me last week. I transferred BTC0.023 to one of my wallets, and paid a fee of BTC0.001. The transaction almost took 120 hours (5 days) to confirm. I noticed that the file size was a little bit high (it was around 20 KB), but then it would not be economical for me to pay 10% or 15% in transaction fees.


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: daynomate on May 30, 2016, 04:00:16 AM
Yay finally i got 1 confirmation... Took just over 26 hours.

This doesn't fill me with confidence though for bitcoin :|


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: freshman777 on May 30, 2016, 09:59:19 AM
Yay finally i got 1 confirmation... Took just over 26 hours.

This doesn't fill me with confidence though for bitcoin :|

you're a fudster and ethereum shill.


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: daynomate on May 30, 2016, 12:01:16 PM
Yay finally i got 1 confirmation... Took just over 26 hours.

This doesn't fill me with confidence though for bitcoin :|

you're a fudster and ethereum shill.

you wot?? think you've spent too much time on the forums, fool.

i have no interest in ethereum. don't be so precious to criticism - what good is your product without resilience?


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: Cryptonitex on May 30, 2016, 01:00:13 PM
That's the problem with BitCoin... It's slow as shit.


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: VanDeinsberg12 on May 30, 2016, 01:47:56 PM
I once sent BTC to Yobit and that took 1 day so no 12 hours isn't that long
Yeah, the most common problem on bitcoin.  but too long for only a transaction, bitcoin need to repair this problem because many people have the same problem in a transaction and gets disadvantages with it. I have ever got the same problem in a transaction but that took a few days to complete them. Better if bitcoin makes an instant confirmation  and  makes upgradeable on their security at the same time.


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: cryptoheadd on May 30, 2016, 01:51:45 PM
That's the problem with BitCoin... It's slow as shit.

No, it isn't.
You should include sufficient fees in your txs.
If you don't do that, It will take time. :)


Title: Re: So my transaction is not confirming for 12+Hrs.. Is this normal? Pls help
Post by: Bitcoinpro on May 30, 2016, 02:26:55 PM
didnt have to wait that long really

u only paid 7c

and sent $1000