Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Development & Technical Discussion => Topic started by: gogodr on June 15, 2016, 04:52:12 AM



Title: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: gogodr on June 15, 2016, 04:52:12 AM
Is there a reason for this?


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: eaLiTy on June 15, 2016, 05:22:26 AM
Is there a reason for this?

what was that.i didnt get you. are you telling that the confirmation gets delayed right now

the main reason is Bitcoin transactions are mined or processed by Miners, higher the transaction fees you provide the faster the confirmation you get


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: Edwardard on June 15, 2016, 05:23:29 AM
Is there a reason for this?
someone maybe creating spam transactions and flooding the network. this could be one of the reasons for this. or there maybe some techincal faults in the blockchain which will be fixed very soon. dont worry, this thing happened many times in the past.
Is there a reason for this?

what was that.i didnt get you. are you telling that the confirmation gets delayed right now

the main reason is Bitcoin transactions are mined or processed by Miners, higher the transaction fees you provide the faster the confirmation you get
but this time even with paying higher fees transactions are not getting confirmed faster. i faced this problem some months before so i know it will fix soon.


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: gogodr on June 15, 2016, 05:26:58 AM
So the answer is no?
No real reason that's known and being discussed?


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: ranochigo on June 15, 2016, 05:37:10 AM
So the answer is no?
No real reason that's known and being discussed?
There are a lot of transactions paying fee, approximately 20k. Confirmation depends on several factors, block time, block space and transaction fee. A miner can only have at max, 1mb of transactions per block and it cannot exceed that. If there are many transactions, the miner would prioritize those with higher fee/kb first in order to maximize the use of their block space.

Currently, I'm seeing quite some blocks being close to the limit while some are not even half filled. This can be because the miner has a stricter policy to not include some transactions not meeting their own criteria.

Tldr; The reason is because the network has a load of unconfirmed transactions or you didn't pay a high enough fee.


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: HotSwap on June 15, 2016, 06:35:06 AM
someone is flooding the network with spam transactions

http://www.bitcoinqueue.com/2d.html

blocks are full .. transaction malleability exploit attack. 


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: gogodr on June 15, 2016, 06:42:18 AM
someone is flooding the network with spam transactions

http://www.bitcoinqueue.com/2d.html

blocks are full .. transaction malleability exploit attack. 

How long can this attack last?


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: jacktheking on June 15, 2016, 06:51:44 AM
I am experiencing this too despite using the recommended dynamic fees set my MyCelium. My transaction is still unconfirmed after two hours.

someone is flooding the network with spam transactions

http://www.bitcoinqueue.com/2d.html

blocks are full .. transaction malleability exploit attack. 

Let's just hope that this attack will end soon.


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: nwfella on June 15, 2016, 07:04:54 AM
I am experiencing this too despite using the recommended dynamic fees set my MyCelium. My transaction is still unconfirmed after two hours.

someone is flooding the network with spam transactions

http://www.bitcoinqueue.com/2d.html

blocks are full .. transaction malleability exploit attack. 

Let's just hope that this attack will end soon.
Also experiencing pretty slow confirmation times here.  Actually had an Economy fee mycelium transaction process faster than a normal fee one. 


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: jaydipmodhwadia on June 15, 2016, 07:14:49 AM
Networks jamming up with spam transactions plus there aren't that many miners mining the new blocks created


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: gogodr on June 15, 2016, 07:28:21 AM
I am experiencing this too despite using the recommended dynamic fees set my MyCelium. My transaction is still unconfirmed after two hours.

someone is flooding the network with spam transactions

http://www.bitcoinqueue.com/2d.html

blocks are full .. transaction malleability exploit attack. 

Let's just hope that this attack will end soon.
Also experiencing pretty slow confirmation times here.  Actually had an Economy fee mycelium transaction process faster than a normal fee one. 

Is there a way to stop a spam transaction from going through?


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: rizzlarolla on June 15, 2016, 07:33:55 AM
Networks jamming up with spam transactions plus there aren't that many miners mining the new blocks created


No.
Network jamming up with recommended fee paying transactions.

Spam transactions will not affect your transaction. Unless your sending spam, are you?
If you pay recommended fee, you will be prioritised over spam.
The problem we have just seen, (and will continue to see), is because blocks are full of non spam fee paying transactions.
This is Cores fee market in action.

You say "there aren't that many miners mining the new blocks created" - complete BS.


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: gogodr on June 15, 2016, 07:52:49 AM
I'm understanding a bit more now. But this can not continue to happen if bitcoin grows and adds new users. Who wants to wait so long to get confirmations.
Is there a plan in motion to curb this from happening in the future or is this just one of the drawbacks to bitcoin.


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: ranochigo on June 15, 2016, 07:58:51 AM
I am experiencing this too despite using the recommended dynamic fees set my MyCelium. My transaction is still unconfirmed after two hours.

someone is flooding the network with spam transactions

http://www.bitcoinqueue.com/2d.html

blocks are full .. transaction malleability exploit attack. 

Let's just hope that this attack will end soon.
Also experiencing pretty slow confirmation times here.  Actually had an Economy fee mycelium transaction process faster than a normal fee one. 

Is there a way to stop a spam transaction from going through?
Bitcoin Core does have a policy to reject certain transactions that doesn't meet some criteria (eg. Minimum relay fee, minimum output). If the any of the criteria is not met, the node would refuse to reject it. Miners on their part can also choose to accept certain transactions. It doesn't prevent spam attack but it does increase the cost of large scale attacks.

I'm understanding a bit more now. But this can not continue to happen if bitcoin grows and adds new users. Who wants to wait so long to get confirmations.
Is there a plan in motion to curb this from happening in the future or is this just one of the drawbacks to bitcoin.
Confirmations isn't necessary, one does not wait months at the store to avoid chargebacks anyways. I would say that Segwit can help with this.


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: gogodr on June 15, 2016, 08:05:45 AM
I am experiencing this too despite using the recommended dynamic fees set my MyCelium. My transaction is still unconfirmed after two hours.

someone is flooding the network with spam transactions

http://www.bitcoinqueue.com/2d.html

blocks are full .. transaction malleability exploit attack. 

Let's just hope that this attack will end soon.
Also experiencing pretty slow confirmation times here.  Actually had an Economy fee mycelium transaction process faster than a normal fee one. 

Is there a way to stop a spam transaction from going through?
Bitcoin Core does have a policy to reject certain transactions that doesn't meet some criteria (eg. Minimum relay fee, minimum output). If the any of the criteria is not met, the node would refuse to reject it. Miners on their part can also choose to accept certain transactions. It doesn't prevent spam attack but it does increase the cost of large scale attacks.

I'm understanding a bit more now. But this can not continue to happen if bitcoin grows and adds new users. Who wants to wait so long to get confirmations.
Is there a plan in motion to curb this from happening in the future or is this just one of the drawbacks to bitcoin.
Confirmations isn't necessary, one does not wait months at the store to avoid chargebacks anyways. I would say that Segwit can help with this.

Segwit?


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: smho_16 on June 15, 2016, 08:06:33 AM
Well so far my confirmations in Electrum are usullay in less than 10 minutes one when I receive payments, I haven't send any bitcoins from some time now so don't know the time of sending  regarding the confirmation , but I have seen lately that Electrum always tell me is a lot of blocks behind and my internet connection is very fast.


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: trsampaio on June 15, 2016, 08:28:29 AM
Bitcoin core confirmations are taking forever because: miners are switching to altcoin, huge volume of BTC due to big ICO at the moment.

And if you use a third party service to push a transaction will be worse


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: rizzlarolla on June 15, 2016, 08:38:49 AM
Bitcoin core confirmations are taking forever because: miners are switching to altcoin, huge volume of BTC due to big ICO at the moment.

And if you use a third party service to push a transaction will be worse

More BS.



Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: gogodr on June 15, 2016, 08:41:46 AM
Bitcoin core confirmations are taking forever because: miners are switching to altcoin, huge volume of BTC due to big ICO at the moment.

And if you use a third party service to push a transaction will be worse

More BS.




Yep, already added him to my ignore list.


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: shield132 on June 15, 2016, 09:05:31 AM
you are right, these days transaction confirms are very slow, but sometimes very fast. 3 days ago I get my money in 3 minutes with bitcoin, but yesterday I made transaction, which has 2 confirmations only.

I think that it's blockchain's technical faults and hope it will be fixed very soon.


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: eaLiTy on June 15, 2016, 09:27:06 AM
Bitcoin core confirmations are taking forever because: miners are switching to altcoin, huge volume of BTC due to big ICO at the moment.

And if you use a third party service to push a transaction will be worse

More BS.




Yep, already added him to my ignore list.

lets give him some chance to voice his BS  :P :P

which wallet are you using,to be frank, i have made transactions for the past three days but i didnt find any delay at all in my transactions ,and i was sending small amounts too through electrum wallet and that too with minimal fee


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: Xialla on June 15, 2016, 09:38:54 AM
last time, I have to wait about 2 hours to have 3 confirmations. sadly, this is how it all works..


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: aliashraf on June 15, 2016, 04:41:28 PM
Networks jamming up with spam transactions plus there aren't that many miners mining the new blocks created


No.
Network jamming up with recommended fee paying transactions.

Spam transactions will not affect your transaction. Unless your sending spam, are you?
If you pay recommended fee, you will be prioritised over spam.
The problem we have just seen, (and will continue to see), is because blocks are full of non spam fee paying transactions.
This is Cores fee market in action.

You say "there aren't that many miners mining the new blocks created" - complete BS.

Transaction malleability is not about fees, it is more dangerous and serious: a whole in the cryptography lets the spammer to replicate a transaction  with different hash (same data) if one of such useless copies happen to be confirmed prior to the original one it will not be confirmed (the transaction has taken place though , the receiver has received her payment and the payer balance has been justified and miner has got her fee, every thing is ok ) BUT the transaction hash , one which is usually used to check all these, seems to be orphan or even having rejected status! (as double spend).

Idk we are experimenting this or not,  but as far as 'transaction malleability' is to be considered, there exists no cost for this attack it has nothing to do with miner fee.



Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: sxafir on June 16, 2016, 01:12:22 PM
My transaction 3 days ago is not confirmed,any solutions?


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: shield132 on June 16, 2016, 01:23:28 PM
My transaction 3 days ago is not confirmed,any solutions?

See this thread: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=186737.0

Here had the same problem one of this forum's member.


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: sxafir on June 16, 2016, 01:31:29 PM
But i have pay fee.


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: ranochigo on June 16, 2016, 02:04:20 PM
But i have pay fee.
There's little difference between paying fee and not paying fee since there are so many transactions that pays a high fee. If possible, post your transaction and the wallet that you are using.


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: sxafir on June 16, 2016, 02:17:39 PM
But i have pay fee.
There's little difference between paying fee and not paying fee since there are so many transactions that pays a high fee. If possible, post your transaction and the wallet that you are using.
first ransaction was kicked buy node,this is second i sent yesterday:
4a10da8f6b5dc4c52186160e613deb7b0b0e46b36ff426c071998cd150dd582b Multibet HD


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: Amph on June 17, 2016, 11:59:09 AM
http://blockspeed.info/

block are costantly full, average of more than 3 tx per second


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: pandalion98 on June 19, 2016, 09:45:51 AM
Is there a reason for this?
Probably because miners aren't confirming your transactions right now.

If you would increase your fee, it will surely get confirmed faster.


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: Monnt on June 19, 2016, 10:03:40 AM
I don't feel any difference. Maybe because of the new bitcoin hype the halving and the increased Chinese interest has caused, the tx volume has risen a fair amount.


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: sxafir on June 21, 2016, 06:08:10 PM
I just paying less fee for transaction,now i set up more fee and work fine.


Title: Re: What are confirms so slow the last few days.
Post by: Skezaz on June 22, 2016, 03:07:00 AM
I Am Also Faceing This Problem Now What I Do All Brother.