Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Hardware => Topic started by: Frizz23 on April 02, 2013, 06:42:49 PM



Title: Spare a coin for Butterfly Labs (BFL)
Post by: Frizz23 on April 02, 2013, 06:42:49 PM
Dear Butterfly Labs,

10 month ago you started to take our pre order money. Since 10 month we are waiting for the ASICs that you still advertise all over the Internet:

http://www.bilder-hochladen.net/files/k9l5-1g-2838.jpg

Will we ever see such a product? 60 GH/s on one single PCB, with this tiny heatsink that you have in your Ad.

I would like to offer my help and give you a quarter so that you can go and purchase a clue. (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UlWrmIqGs3Y&t=2m48s)

Here is my first clue. And it's for free: Clue #1 (http://lmgtfy.com/?q=Prototype) (hint: this is what you do before you go into mass production and produce tons of PCBs, boxes with fans and heatsinks that you can throw away afterwards).

Sincerely,
Frizz


Title: Re: Spare a coin for Butterfly Labs (BFL)
Post by: crazyates on April 02, 2013, 07:00:10 PM
Will we ever see such a product? 60 GH/s on one single PCB, with this tiny heatsink that you have in your Ad.
You know that the heatsink in the picture is for their old FPGA Single. The newer SC Singles use a different, slightly larger heatsink.


Title: Re: Spare a coin for Butterfly Labs (BFL)
Post by: Frizz23 on April 02, 2013, 07:15:09 PM
You know that the heatsink in the picture is for their old FPGA Single. The newer SC Singles use a different, slightly larger heatsink.

So they advertise their old FPGA products as ASIC products? I'd call that malicious deception.


Title: Re: Spare a coin for Butterfly Labs (BFL)
Post by: SkRRJyTC on April 02, 2013, 07:16:35 PM
Will we ever see such a product? 60 GH/s on one single PCB, with this tiny heatsink that you have in your Ad.
You know that the heatsink in the picture is for their old FPGA Single. The newer SC Singles use a different, slightly larger heatsink.

Thats clearly deceptive.


Title: Re: Spare a coin for Butterfly Labs (BFL)
Post by: nathanrees19 on April 02, 2013, 11:28:44 PM
Oh no! It doesn't match the picture!

Big macs don't either. Do people get refunds from mcdonalds?


Title: Re: Spare a coin for Butterfly Labs (BFL)
Post by: repentance on April 03, 2013, 12:49:47 AM
It's not a secret that they've changed the heatsinks which they were originally going to use for their ASICs - Josh posted about it the other day.

I'd say that BFL_Steven's comments in Shoutbox are probably more relevant to actual issues than whether or not the photos on the product website have been updated (yes, they should be but I doubt anyone is ordering an ASIC based solely on images of the heatsink).

Quote from: BFL_Steven
* Chips count per device may change, depending on results this week

Quote from: BFL_Steven
* Power affects everything. Jalapeno may have to ship with external power. And possibly air cooling.

Quote from: BFL_Steven
* New boards testing this week.  (...)  I'd guess shipping next week.

Quote from: BFL_Steven
Overclocking is not a supported option. Custom enabling of chip cores or speed adjustments are not supported at this time.

https://twitter.com/BFL_News


Title: Re: Spare a coin for Butterfly Labs (BFL)
Post by: Frizz23 on April 03, 2013, 05:56:14 AM
Oh no! It doesn't match the picture!

Big macs don't either. Do people get refunds from mcdonalds?

If you really wanna use that analogy for BFL: People who ordered a Big Mac 10 month ago now get two Chicken Nuggets instead.


Title: Re: Spare a coin for Butterfly Labs (BFL)
Post by: Phinnaeus Gage on April 03, 2013, 06:11:38 AM
Oh no! It doesn't match the picture!

Big macs don't either. Do people get refunds from mcdonalds?

If you really wanna use that analogy for BFL: People who ordered a Big Mac 10 month ago now get two Chicken Nuggets instead.

Unless McRibs are in season.


Title: Re: Spare a coin for Butterfly Labs (BFL)
Post by: Frizz23 on April 03, 2013, 07:33:21 AM
clue #2 (http://lmgtfy.com/?q=project+management)


Title: Re: Spare a coin for Butterfly Labs (BFL)
Post by: ny2cafuse on April 03, 2013, 06:40:29 PM
Oh no! It doesn't match the picture!

Big macs don't either. Do people get refunds from mcdonalds?

I can walk into McDonalds right now, buy a big mac, and walk out feeling like I got something for my money.  If I had to wait 10+ months for a big mac, I'd be pissed.


Title: Re: Spare a coin for Butterfly Labs (BFL)
Post by: Bogart on April 03, 2013, 06:44:09 PM
It's not a secret that they've changed the heatsinks which they were originally going to use for their ASICs - Josh posted about it the other day.

The pictured product is clearly an FPGA Single.

That heatsink pictured was never in consideration for use in the SC product line.


Title: Re: Spare a coin for Butterfly Labs (BFL)
Post by: Frizz23 on April 03, 2013, 08:09:42 PM
The pictured product is clearly an FPGA Single.

True. Plus there will never be a 60GH/s miner. According to Dave/BFL most probably people that ordered a Single SC (60GH/s) will get multiple Little Single SC (30GH/s ?) because of power consumption / heat problems.

But BFLs Ad is still online. I'd call that malicious deception.


Title: Re: Spare a coin for Butterfly Labs (BFL)
Post by: Frankie Delaney on April 03, 2013, 09:58:28 PM
The pictured product is clearly an FPGA Single.

True. Plus there will never be a 60GH/s miner. According to Dave/BFL most probably people that ordered a Single SC (60GH/s) will get multiple Little Single SC (30GH/s ?) because of power consumption / heat problems.

But BFLs Ad is still online. I'd call that malicious deception.

The minirig might hit 60GH/s. Luke-Jr has said that the little single he was working with couldn't hit 30GH/s, the pictures josh took showed 24GH/s and 179 watts, which the power supplies can't handle, but stick 10 of those boards in a minirig, underclock them to 25% power, and boom, 60GH/s, 447 watts, and enough fans to keep it cool. All of those specs would be pretty much in line with what avalon has shown is possible, and the difference in power usage accounts for the difference in die size.

The number of chips, hashing power, power usage, unit size would all line up with reality. Granted, with the number of chips they have right now they could only make 25 units.


Title: Re: Spare a coin for Butterfly Labs (BFL)
Post by: BR0KK on April 03, 2013, 10:08:44 PM
The pictured product is clearly an FPGA Single.

True. Plus there will never be a 60GH/s miner. According to Dave/BFL most probably people that ordered a Single SC (60GH/s) will get multiple Little Single SC (30GH/s ?) because of power consumption / heat problems.

But BFLs Ad is still online. I'd call that malicious deception.

The minirig might hit 60GH/s. Luke-Jr has said that the little single he was working with couldn't hit 30GH/s, the pictures josh took showed 24GH/s and 179 watts, which the power supplies can't handle, but stick 10 of those boards in a minirig, underclock them to 25% power, and boom, 60GH/s, 447 watts, and enough fans to keep it cool. All of those specs would be pretty much in line with what avalon has shown is possible, and the difference in power usage accounts for the difference in die size.

The number of chips, hashing power, power usage, unit size would all line up with reality. Granted, with the number of chips they have right now they could only make 25 units.

If they deliver this....

Ist fun and entertaining to see this happen. This is a story to tell my future kids witch i preordered when i was born!


Title: Re: Spare a coin for Butterfly Labs (BFL)
Post by: Flying Hellfish on April 03, 2013, 10:13:51 PM
Oh no! It doesn't match the picture!

Big macs don't either. Do people get refunds from mcdonalds?

If you really wanna use that analogy for BFL: People who ordered a Big Mac 10 month ago now get two Chicken Nuggets instead.

More like:  McD's announce their new Mc Uni burger, a unicorn burger that is only 3 calories and only cost $1.00 and after its digested your farts smell like roses!  They pre sell the hell out of it, ten months later they only have half a unicorn available and they sub it for a couple of Big Macs...

Good god I hate when people us analogies, they are almost always ridiculously bad...

@PG, damn you to hell for mentioning Mc Ribs cause I freakin want one now (I would also settle for a Ribwich!)


Title: Re: Spare a coin for Butterfly Labs (BFL)
Post by: Frizz23 on April 03, 2013, 10:21:16 PM
All of those specs would be pretty much in line with what avalon has shown is possible, ...

I remember when Josh "Loudmouth" Zerlan / BFL was mocking Avalon because of their power consumption. And used BFL ASICs superior power consumption as a selling point. That they are much more future-proof and profitable in the long run ra ra ra ... bullshit.

Now as reality catches up with BFL (or vice versa), and their power consumption is almost the same as Avalons, it might be interesting what Josh has to say.

http://www.bilder-hochladen.net/files/k9l5-1b-d9d4.jpg


Title: Re: Spare a coin for Butterfly Labs (BFL)
Post by: BR0KK on April 03, 2013, 10:23:31 PM
Maybe they just ordered AVALONS and mounted them on their singes?


Title: Re: Spare a coin for Butterfly Labs (BFL)
Post by: Syke on April 04, 2013, 01:38:06 AM
Maybe they just ordered AVALONS and mounted them on their singes?

After sanding off the Avalon logo on the chips.


Title: Re: Spare a coin for Butterfly Labs (BFL)
Post by: Frankie Delaney on April 04, 2013, 01:51:03 AM
Dear Butterfly Labs,

10 month ago you started to take our pre order money. Since 10 month we are waiting for the ASICs that you still advertise all over the Internet:

http://www.bilder-hochladen.net/files/k9l5-1g-2838.jpg

Will we ever see such a product? 60 GH/s on one single PCB, with this tiny heatsink that you have in your Ad.

I would like to offer my help and give you a quarter so that you can go and purchase a clue. (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UlWrmIqGs3Y&t=2m48s)

Here is my first clue. And it's for free: Clue #1 (http://lmgtfy.com/?q=Prototype) (hint: this is what you do before you go into mass production and produce tons of PCBs, boxes with fans and heatsinks that you can throw away afterwards).

Sincerely,
Frizz

I think it's time for BFL to update their advertising.

https://i.imgur.com/o6QHvEa.jpg


Title: Re: Spare a coin for Butterfly Labs (BFL)
Post by: creativex on April 04, 2013, 01:56:19 AM
Dear Butterfly Labs,

10 month ago you started to take our pre order money. Since 10 month we are waiting for the ASICs that you still advertise all over the Internet:

http://www.bilder-hochladen.net/files/k9l5-1g-2838.jpg

Will we ever see such a product? 60 GH/s on one single PCB, with this tiny heatsink that you have in your Ad.

I would like to offer my help and give you a quarter so that you can go and purchase a clue. (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UlWrmIqGs3Y&t=2m48s)

Here is my first clue. And it's for free: Clue #1 (http://lmgtfy.com/?q=Prototype) (hint: this is what you do before you go into mass production and produce tons of PCBs, boxes with fans and heatsinks that you can throw away afterwards).

Sincerely,
Frizz

I think it's time for BFL to update their advertising.

https://i.imgur.com/o6QHvEa.jpg

LOL

You guys!!! :)

It's somewhat surprising that this band of crooks haven't been shut down by human authority figures yet.


Title: Re: Spare a coin for Butterfly Labs (BFL)
Post by: DPoS on April 04, 2013, 02:18:37 AM
Great thread!!  10/10  -  will read again!