|
Title: need a 0 fee transaction mined CPFP, resend,... are not an option Post by: pooya87 on November 13, 2016, 05:13:42 PM here is what happened, there is a transaction from an exchange wallet to another exchange wallet so we have no access to the private keys of either addresses.
it is a small (373 byte) transaction which has 0 fees, transferring a rather large amount and it has been days without confirmation. what options do we have apart from waiting and praying :) ? for example can i pay the miners the fee in a separate transaction so that they include this 0 fee tx in a block? Title: Re: need a 0 fee transaction mined CPFP, resend,... are not an option Post by: U2 on November 13, 2016, 05:15:52 PM here is what happened, there is a transaction from an exchange wallet to another exchange wallet so we have no access to the private keys of either addresses. it is a small (373 byte) transaction which has 0 fees, transferring a rather large amount and it has been days without confirmation. what options do we have apart from waiting and praying :) ? for example can i pay the miners the fee in a separate transaction so that they include this 0 fee tx in a block? No you can't change the fee but someone running a full node could rebroadcast it for you. You'll have to find someone on the forum who runs a full node (or from somewhere else of course). Title: Re: need a 0 fee transaction mined CPFP, resend,... are not an option Post by: steven0021 on November 13, 2016, 05:17:56 PM for example can i pay the miners the fee in a separate transaction so that they include this 0 fee tx in a block? Probably. Try contacting Quickseller (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=358020) or macbook-air (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=16114). They can push your tx to F2pool upon request (that doesn't mean they'll always do it though). Edit: Or you can find other pool operators and contact them. Title: Re: need a 0 fee transaction mined CPFP, resend,... are not an option Post by: pooya87 on November 13, 2016, 05:18:32 PM No you can't change the fee but someone running a full node could rebroadcast it for you. You'll have to find someone on the forum who runs a full node (or from somewhere else of course). i can re-broadcast it myself fine, thank you very much! i need it mined, and it is not even my transaction. i am helping a friend out and the sender (which is a shitty local exchange service) is not helping. edit: ~~ Probably. Try contacting Quickseller (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=358020) or macbook-air (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=profile;u=16114). They can push your tx to F2pool upon request (that doesn't mean they'll always do it though). thanks for the links, i sent them both a PM Title: Re: need a 0 fee transaction mined CPFP, resend,... are not an option Post by: shorena on November 13, 2016, 05:44:49 PM here is what happened, there is a transaction from an exchange wallet to another exchange wallet so we have no access to the private keys of either addresses. it is a small (373 byte) transaction which has 0 fees, transferring a rather large amount and it has been days without confirmation. what options do we have apart from waiting and praying :) ? for example can i pay the miners the fee in a separate transaction so that they include this 0 fee tx in a block? No you can't change the fee but someone running a full node could rebroadcast it for you. You'll have to find someone on the forum who runs a full node (or from somewhere else of course). I can do that, @OP can you post a TX-ID or send me a PM with it? Title: Re: need a 0 fee transaction mined CPFP, resend,... are not an option Post by: achow101 on November 13, 2016, 05:53:55 PM You have a few options. You can wait and pray, ask a miner kindly to include it for you, or contact the exchange's support and ask them to resend with a fee. Your best bet would be to ask a miner, (quickseller or macbook-air can do that, as stated earlier). However, it wouldn't hurt to contact the customer support of the sending exchange and see if they can RBF it. If they can't, you could also ask the receiving exchange if they can CPFP it.
I can do that, but it might be better to replace the TX with one that pays a higher fee. Reading, sho:here is what happened, there is a transaction from an exchange wallet to another exchange wallet so we have no access to the private keys of either addresses. @OP can you post a TX-ID or send me a PM with it? Yes, that would be very helpful. Better would be to post the raw transaction in case the transaction does disappear so that people who run full nodes (including myself) can rebroadcast it for you.Title: Re: need a 0 fee transaction mined CPFP, resend,... are not an option Post by: pooya87 on November 13, 2016, 05:59:44 PM thank you all for replies.
as an update i have contacted Quickseller and he already pushed that transaction to f2pool. now i am waiting on confirmation. i did not post the tx because it is not mine so i thought the owner may not want it on public. Title: Re: need a 0 fee transaction mined CPFP, resend,... are not an option Post by: achow101 on November 13, 2016, 06:00:46 PM i did not post the tx because it is not mine so i thought the owner may not want it on public. It's already public, that's how Bitcoin works. My node probably already sees it, I just don't know which of the transactions it is. Once a transaction is broadcast, it is public.Title: Re: need a 0 fee transaction mined CPFP, resend,... are not an option Post by: pooya87 on November 13, 2016, 06:41:28 PM i did not post the tx because it is not mine so i thought the owner may not want it on public. It's already public, that's how Bitcoin works. My node probably already sees it, I just don't know which of the transactions it is. Once a transaction is broadcast, it is public.That is right, maybe i chose my words poorly :) what i meant was more in the area of keeping the privacy and having the pseudonymous state. which is as everyone sees tx 123abcd... but unless i announce it to the world that 123abcd... is mine, nobody can know that unless they do blockchain analysis and ask the exchanges :) and it is already confirmed thanks to Quickseller, i guess i will lock the topic in the morning, maybe someone has something to say. and thanks to everyone here to replied. Title: Re: need a 0 fee transaction mined CPFP, resend,... are not an option Post by: yakuza699 on November 13, 2016, 07:01:57 PM If you wanted to leave the transaction pseudonymous you shouldn't have mentioned the exact size and fee of it (373, 0). A quick search and I know your tx, it starts with c45b6e66a2aa2
Title: Re: need a 0 fee transaction mined CPFP, resend,... are not an option Post by: pooya87 on November 14, 2016, 04:12:02 AM If you wanted to leave the transaction pseudonymous you shouldn't have mentioned the exact size and fee of it (373, 0). A quick search and I know your tx, it starts with c45b6e66a2aa2 oopsie, i did not even think about that. thanks for bringing it to my attention though, it is good to have it in mind for maybe some next time. luckily the owner doesn't mind this though. |