Bitcoin Forum

If you take a look at his original post, he sold the 1 BTC coins for 1.25 BTC, and that extra 0.25 BTC was about $2 at time of posting... How was he able to create and sell the coins so cheap?
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=41892.0

That really is the craziest thing.. the brass ones were indeed made by a car wash token manufacturer - hence them being so cheap to produce and sell. The security of these coins is down to the holograms, as I would imagine the brass tokens would be pretty easy to replicate.

The silver coins were produced by a mint (don't know which one) and were therefore of a much better quality. Again, the security of Casascius coins is the holograms. If those were easy to counterfeit, then I imagine we would have seen some a decent amount of fakes by now. There have been instances of fake holograms, but to the trained eye, they were easy to tell apart from genuine ones. Any Casascius collector would be able to tell the difference. The manufacturer of Casascius holograms is unknown (to me anyway), and I hope it stays that way actually.

That's crazy!  And yet, they are such valuable coins today.  Does anyone know how much casascius originally sold the coins produced by a mint for? 
It's just that the premiums coins sell for nowadays cost so much more than what Mike was selling them for.

Hmmmm what if the casascius hologram maker kept the dies.......most of them do for reorders.  Has mike mentioned anything about this?

Personally, I take possession of my dies after coins are produced.  While I can't speak for Mike, given his stance on security, I would imagine he also took possession of his dies.

As for how he was able to sell them so cheap...  The brass is only worth about $0.05, I imagine it probably cost $1 per unit for the minting fee, and at $2 he could have been doubling his money (see my below post w/ link showing that his total cost could have actually been lower than $0.50 each).  The question you should be asking, is how are current coin producers able to get away with copying Casascius' idea and then charging a $75-$500 markup for what is essentially a knock off.

To be honest that was the point I was getting at.  Any idea, anyone? ???

Great points. Maybe some current physical coin producers can chime in? thanks!  :)

On this topic, wondering who has the best prices for custom gold and silver rounds with holograms? Would love to price some out for promos.

Golds are tough but silver....silver wallets are always a good choice and also i believe f*d has some silvers for a nice price.  I also think og has some nice silvers at a cheap price but without holos.

Looking for custom, though, as opposed to those they already made. The thought is to get some made for promoting a couple sites, with unique rounds that can't be bought, only won, :).

They were cheap for the above reasons (cheap metal and made as a car wash token) but also because so many were produced. I'm not sure of the mintage of each year respectively, but there are about 20000 brass 1BTC coins in total. Correct me on the estimate. I imagine he actually purchased more though.

If the car wash token story is legit (I had no idea) then this might be relevant.

tokensdirectstore.com/..... (http://www.tokensdirectstore.com/ItemForm.aspx?Item=X260-665-001&ReturnURL=/Tokens1.aspx?Id=d03b3aeb-d1f0-48e4-b845-1b4fceea8e59&Category=d03b3aeb-d1f0-48e4-b845-1b4fceea8e59)

Those original coins could have been made for close to $0.25 each...

I think it's quite simple really. Mike started Casascius as a means of showing that BTC wasn't limited to something digital but was something you could also put in your pocket and hold (correct me if I'm wrong).
Today's coin producers have nothing to prove and most of them are in it purely for the business aspect of it, hence the high markups.
I just think that Mike wasn't looking to make a lot of money on it. It was his personal project for something he genuinely believed in.

Just my 2 satoshis...

And i thought the idea for the thread was that you may be looking to produce your own coins soon  ;)

That's really cheap and looks pretty neat, are car wash tokens still used at car washes?

Mike did something special with these coins and I always look forward to future innovations by any user.   :)

People are weird. I've been a numismatist in non Bitcoin collectibles for a while now, and the premiums associated with Bitcoin collectibles is unheard of. The most valuable silver coin I've ever gotten a hold of was one of seven that existed, it was produced by a government mint in a pretty collectible series, graded MS70, and it sold for ~$300 over spot. Tuvalu isn't a super well known mint, but I'd conservatively estimate there are at least 100,000 people that collect their coins world wide.There are ancient roman/greek silver coins graded and with historical significance that sell for less than that of what mint produced silver blank pressed physical BTC are selling for.

The free market is what it is, obviously a business is going to charge the most it can while maintaining its customers patronage, but if you try to explain the Bitcoin collectibles market to someone who deals in rare coins, they will just look at you dumbstruck when you start talking about the prices. I've seen the same baffled look three or four times now.

Just FYI, you can contact Sunshine Mint, OPM, or any number of generic bullion mints and get a quote for a run of custom coins. Depending on the complexity of the coin and the min order size, you could probably pay as little as $2 over spot / oz + $200-300 for the dies.

I think a lot of this is to do with the wealth effect (http://www.investopedia.com/terms/w/wealtheffect.asp). I also think physical bitcoin collectors generally think 1BTC = 1BTC regardless of the current USD value. So the premiums in USD are much higher today but in terms of BTC they're pretty much the same (BTCC 1BTC has a .15BTC premium for example)

I think the premiums measured in USD are going to get even crazier if BTC goes to the moon.

This applies to me. I don't consider the USD value of premium on a coin too much when buying physical btc. I buy in BTC with hopes to get it sold for BTC, and never fiat. Of, course it helps to look at the USD price to follow up on how other people will buy or sell.

1BTC = 1BTC  ;D

That's what happens in a free market when you have people fueled by greed. Absurd markups. There are very few creators/series that do not do this.

---

Don't even try to tell me that slapping a stupid sticker (that you bought on ebay for <20$) on a coin magically makes it worth 3x the spot price (or worse). Numbers in the previous sentence are obvious arbitrary.

Current coin producers are doing it to earn a profit (I have no problem with that btw.).
Mike had a political agenda, his goal was to teach the world about bitcoin.

I agree 1 BTC = 1 BTC. But if you load 1 BTC onto a Physical coin made of $16 worth of metal and sell it for 1.5 BTC, TYPICALLY, and I emphasize that because that is typically the case with collectibles, but seemingly not Bitcoin collectibles, when you go to sell it, it will be worth 1 BTC + current metal value + some premium. These aren't really coins that have tens or hundreds of thousands of people looking to buy and hold them for 20 years like fans of government mint bullion or other collectible coins. These never really leave circulation, because no one peels the sticker, redeems the coins, and melts down the coin, so they aren't ever growing more rare.

It really is a phenomenon in collectibles that defies all traditional rules. The first law of collectibles, is anything made to be collectible often is not. You need a massive evergrowing fanbase to keep something designed to be collectible collectible, otherwise you end up with a van full of beanie babies.

It doesn't defy the first rule of speculation.  “The market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent.”  We are just seeing an irrational market.  These $0.05 poker chips and glorified car wash tokens will not be able to sell with $75-$500 markups forever.  Casascius coins earned those markups with their place in history.  There should be no other <$2 coin selling for >$100 in this community.



While I agree about Mike, I disagree that we are all doing it just for a profit.  I could give numerous examples of how I've personally with great cost taken actions to improve my products and innovate based on Casascius' original idea.  There are good projects out there (at least 1 (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=86854.0) that I know of) that are motivated by building something for the benefit of the community.

I'm very interested in producing some coins to sell and give away to other people, but the markups I've seen businesses charge on this forum seem much higher than the production costs.
I'll probably still go ahead with producing some unique coins, but would never plan to charge such a higher markup for them.

That's true and I think we are all appreciative of what he did.

To those people saying 1 BTC = 1 BTC, very true, but when you purchase a coin, that was paid for in USD, shouldn't you be marking its value in USD as well?

I just find it hard to believe that you'd still be willing to pay $3000 USD worth in markups for a 1 BTC coin if 1 BTC = $10000, and that coin sells for 1.3 BTC. 

Soooo basically when I sold a 2013-minted half-oz round for 15 BTC, I set a world record ;)

We (The Bitcoin Penny Co.) don't make the expensive $75-$100 Fine .999 Silver collectible coins, but I'll add my thoughts. (Please keep in mind that these thoughts apply to TBPCo only, as I have no knowledge of the inner-workings of other coinmakers' businesses.)

The markup is not all profit. In fact, there is very little profit, respectively. Most of the markup covers all the little things such as packaging materials and printing costs, monthly website fees, shipping supplies and actual shipping costs (we lose money on most international sales), all the local, state, and federal retail licenses and sales taxes (if you properly claim the income as a business, which we do), and a bazillion more little things that you'd never, EVER expect. And then there's all the little extra special things you want to do that weren't in the original budget, like free stickers. =)

We lost a good bit of money in our first year (2015), but we learned a lot about small (micro) business. We changed a few things with our next release, and we broke even somewhere in the summer of our second year (2016). Technically, we're still a couple hundred bucks in the black, so we're happy with how 2016 will end for us. =)

We treat this like a legal business, which it is, but it's not really a viable business. I would make a LOT more money working part-time at minimum wage, but it's fun and I like it. =/

I'm rambling again. LOL I guess my point is that there are a LOT of (expected and unexpected) expenses that go into running a small collectible coin business, so a little markup is required.

To put it another way, the minting is the easy part. It's maintaining the business that takes time, effort, and money.

Hope my perspective helps.

Regards,
Chris

Have to agree with Chris here with all of the unforseen costs (including an ungodly amount of gas going back and forth to the post office, lol).....not to mention the time.  It really isnt that profitable enough for anything substantial unless you are mass selling successfully which I think this is still a  micro market so maybe only a handful of people can do that.  For me its more for the fun as well, and to try to add a little to the market and keep it moving forward.

Maybe if someone were able to sell loaded .999 Silver physical bitcoins (which excludes USA makers) at a small .15 BTC premium and limited the run to 100 coins maximum (to increase collectibility), they could make ~$11,500 total premium. And if they sold thru BTForum exclusively, they could avoid all the associated website and hosting costs/fees. And if they did it all under-the-table (without properly notifying the government), then they could avoid a huge amount of city, state, and county license fees, retail sales taxes, and any basic income taxes. In the above case, I could easily see someone making a nice little profit in a short time. Throw in a few new designs per year, and you might be able to squeak out a living for a year or two (based on USA economy).

Regards,
Me