Bitcoin Forum

Economy => Speculation => Topic started by: rogerwilco on December 23, 2016, 11:04:46 PM



Title: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: rogerwilco on December 23, 2016, 11:04:46 PM
This isn't chart or market depth analysis, just a look at long term perspective.

I always look at log charts when trading anything, not because exponential growth looks like a straight line (though that's useful), not because it makes high values seem close (though that's fun), but because equal vertical distances represent equal percentage changes, which is more useful in trading than linear distances.

With that said, look at the long term path Bitcoin has traded at over on Bitstamp since 2012:

https://i.supload.com/rkjWo7iNl.png

See that purple oval highlighting the last two candles? That's our current rally. Not only is it nothing so far compared to the giant bubbles of 2013, but it's peanuts even compared to the other two major run-ups since the bull run started in late 2015.

Granted, each of those did have some correction after reaching the top of their respective rallies, but the price still leveled off significantly higher than where it started. If this is merely the third of such mini-hypes on this bull run, we're still going a ways up before this is over.

And this is just my gut about a different topic, and I could be wrong, but I feel this may turn out to be a bit more significant of a rally than the last two.

Edit: The snapshot was taken when Bitstamp first hit $910.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: AlexM on December 23, 2016, 11:48:03 PM
Agreed, I think we are way undervalued and when people see that think that they should be selling for $2000 not $900 then the price will continue rising. Today was faster than is usually healthy but we need to get up to $1000-$2500 and stay there for a prolonged period. If we do this then more and more good stuff will be developed for Bitcoin as the economy will be significant enough.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: angaper on December 23, 2016, 11:58:00 PM
I have been a successful forex trader for several years and I still can't understand how there may be some people who still believe that the supposed signals provided by technical analysis and price action can really give us a clear picture of what will happen in the near future.

Apart from subjective guessing and personal desires, I do not see anything reliable in these forecasts.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: rogerwilco on December 24, 2016, 12:02:21 AM
I have been a successful forex trader for several years and I still can't understand how there may be some people who still believe that the supposed signals provided by technical analysis and price action can really give us a clear picture of what will happen in the near future.

Apart from subjective guessing and personal desires, I do not see anything reliable in these forecasts.

Did you read my first sentence?


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: The Sceptical Chymist on December 24, 2016, 12:08:55 AM
Lol, looks like we've gone completely sideways since 2013, but I know that's not the case.  Either way I think we're probably in too steep a rise.  We're due for a correction, though I hate to use an overused term from financial journalism.  There's no other way to describe it.  Too much buying, and who knows if these are just short-term speculators or real investors.  Buying has to come from somewhere.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: BitcoinBarrel on December 24, 2016, 02:56:16 AM
It really looks to me like the beginning of the 2013 rally, but only time will tell.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: CoinCidental on December 24, 2016, 02:56:30 AM
Lol, looks like we've gone completely sideways since 2013, but I know that's not the case.  Either way I think we're probably in too steep a rise.  We're due for a correction, though I hate to use an overused term from financial journalism.  There's no other way to describe it.  Too much buying, and who knows if these are just short-term speculators or real investors.  Buying has to come from somewhere.

your correction might be from 2000 to settle at 1500 ..........


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: akasma on December 24, 2016, 03:00:33 AM
Yes, I agree with you. This race is very interesting . if all members still hold BTC , it will bring more profits as a christmas and new year gifts for all
Merry Christmas to all of you.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: gentlemand on December 24, 2016, 03:16:16 AM
Well, if there is a crapping out after the present run I do hope it doesn't grind on as long as the last one. It's pleasing to see some proper action after what seems like forever. I'm not quite ready to go back to that yet but perhaps I never will be.

I'm not sure where everything stands in terms of near future potential. It's been a rapid rise but it still feels quite a way away from genuine insanity. It might not have even started warming up yet or perhaps it won't happen at all.

In a way I was more content with the nature of the preceding rise. Impressive but steady. True bubbliness in 2013 was amazing to observe but then there was that pesky aftermath.



Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: pooya87 on December 24, 2016, 04:38:35 AM
good analysis and although i am not particularly a fan of log charts but i like anything with a long term scope instead of looking at 1 week :)

also i have to say i think in any analysis you should also factor in the difference between today and those years. for example how different the resistances are and how different the supports are, and also always have in mind that back then there was MtGox's willibot hard at work.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: rogerwilco on December 24, 2016, 05:16:11 AM
good analysis and although i am not particularly a fan of log charts but i like anything with a long term scope instead of looking at 1 week :)

also i have to say i think in any analysis you should also factor in the difference between today and those years. for example how different the resistances are and how different the supports are, and also always have in mind that back then there was MtGox's willibot hard at work.

Part of my point was that this current move is arguably small even when compared to other moves in the last 15 months, but yes, the difference from the 2013 bubble is even more stark.

The interesting thing to think about looking back is the number of actors. The price was more volatile back in the day not just because of the Willy bot, but also simply because there were fewer traders. Fewer traders means smaller changes in emotion affect the market more, adding to volatility. Unfortunately I don't know what the numbers then and now are, and I'm not sure anybody knows (other than there are probably more now).


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: Przemax on December 24, 2016, 02:59:33 PM
The last rally is just a begining it seems. But it might be the end of it. The time has changed. There are now new things:

1. There is no willy.
2. There are a lot of futures options.
3. There is more competition to the bitcoin.
4. More traders.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: zoinky on December 24, 2016, 03:02:17 PM
1. There is no willy.

There is no *detected* willy.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: gentlemand on December 24, 2016, 03:35:36 PM
I believe there are multiple low level willies in China. Look what happens when they turn their volume bots off. Not a great deal. It's more about maintaining the illusion of them being happening places rather than blatant naked pumping.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: pitham1 on December 25, 2016, 04:15:23 AM
The current rally doesn't look huge when you plot it on the log scale, but it is unlikely we will return to the hay days of the past.
Bitcoin is more widely distributed now and there will be a lot more people who are ready to book profits when it rises.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: deadsilent on December 25, 2016, 04:55:17 AM
Now we are down again to $860+. Its a good rally tho. They are dumping their holdings right now so i hope the the price still at $800 barrier. I think $1000 is not possible before this year ends. Hope 2017 is good for bitcoin.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: ethereumhunter on December 25, 2016, 11:58:04 AM
this is what i am thinking too when i look at the poloniex charts, it seems the price is not going to down or up for deep and higher but the rate will be reach in $900 again soon and we only hope its really happen before the new year.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: BTCLovingDude on December 25, 2016, 12:29:14 PM
Now we are down again to $860+. Its a good rally tho. They are dumping their holdings right now so i hope the the price still at $800 barrier. I think $1000 is not possible before this year ends. Hope 2017 is good for bitcoin.

it is the correction phase, and it is perfectly normal in rises such as this last one that prices go down and market calms down for a little while and specially since it is the Christmas days things are more calm.

and who knows there is still a chance to see $1000 to a little chance to see it this soon but it still is there.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: kwukduck on December 25, 2016, 12:33:26 PM
It's not crazy at all considering the level of manipulation and scamming going on, what surprises me is the apparent sheer number of people willingly getting scammed.

It IS crazy however considering all the flawed protocol fundamentals. But nobody looks at that, all most people here care about is to be on top of a pyramid scheme.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: Denker on December 25, 2016, 01:53:25 PM
Now we are down again to $860+. Its a good rally tho. They are dumping their holdings right now so i hope the the price still at $800 barrier. I think $1000 is not possible before this year ends. Hope 2017 is good for bitcoin.

What we are seing now as a good and healthy correction!This is needed otherwise things might really go crazy!
And I don't want another 2014/2015 happening to be honest.
We will stay in the bull market so there is absolutely nothing to worry when we are going down a bit.
I mean people just need to have a look on the weekly charts!!! This speaks for itself!


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: randy8777 on December 25, 2016, 02:00:37 PM
It's not crazy at all considering the level of manipulation and scamming going on, what surprises me is the apparent sheer number of people willingly getting scammed.

It IS crazy however considering all the flawed protocol fundamentals. But nobody looks at that, all most people here care about is to be on top of a pyramid scheme.

may i ask you a serious question? i once saw you post that you have made very nice profits by selling at the peak months ago. doesn't it make you one of the people you mention in the bolded part? i am sure you have made nice profits this time as well. if you strictly look at that, you aren't any better than these people you seem to throw a lot criticism on.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: kwukduck on December 25, 2016, 02:54:04 PM
It's not crazy at all considering the level of manipulation and scamming going on, what surprises me is the apparent sheer number of people willingly getting scammed.

It IS crazy however considering all the flawed protocol fundamentals. But nobody looks at that, all most people here care about is to be on top of a pyramid scheme.

may i ask you a serious question? i once saw you post that you have made very nice profits by selling at the peak months ago. doesn't it make you one of the people you mention in the bolded part? i am sure you have made nice profits this time as well. if you strictly look at that, you aren't any better than these people you seem to throw a lot criticism on.

I don't claim to be any better unlike many here that try to sell bitcoin as a revolutionary technology which it could be but isn't for this very reason.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: pereira4 on December 25, 2016, 07:29:46 PM
Agreed, I think we are way undervalued and when people see that think that they should be selling for $2000 not $900 then the price will continue rising. Today was faster than is usually healthy but we need to get up to $1000-$2500 and stay there for a prolonged period. If we do this then more and more good stuff will be developed for Bitcoin as the economy will be significant enough.
We are undervalued indeed. When its all said and done, bitcoin is an unique asset and no other asset can deliver a similar experience. Once we solve some problems and release segwit into the wild then we will have a package strong enough to defeat every other asset and currency on the planet. Governments fear segwit and thats why they are paying people to shill BU and be anti segwit, but we will win.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: justdimin on December 25, 2016, 08:23:56 PM
Agreed, I think we are way undervalued and when people see that think that they should be selling for $2000 not $900 then the price will continue rising. Today was faster than is usually healthy but we need to get up to $1000-$2500 and stay there for a prolonged period. If we do this then more and more good stuff will be developed for Bitcoin as the economy will be significant enough.
We are undervalued indeed. When its all said and done, bitcoin is an unique asset and no other asset can deliver a similar experience. Once we solve some problems and release segwit into the wild then we will have a package strong enough to defeat every other asset and currency on the planet. Governments fear segwit and thats why they are paying people to shill BU and be anti segwit, but we will win.
I too agree bitcoin has lot of potential left to be valued when considering the current price levels of it. So, it doesn't make any sense if we are calling the current rally as crazy. No commodity will surge without reasons, so bitcoin too. Strongly believing, this rally will continue toward new ATH at any time.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: kwukduck on December 26, 2016, 12:58:14 PM
Agreed, I think we are way undervalued and when people see that think that they should be selling for $2000 not $900 then the price will continue rising. Today was faster than is usually healthy but we need to get up to $1000-$2500 and stay there for a prolonged period. If we do this then more and more good stuff will be developed for Bitcoin as the economy will be significant enough.
We are undervalued indeed. When its all said and done, bitcoin is an unique asset and no other asset can deliver a similar experience. Once we solve some problems and release segwit into the wild then we will have a package strong enough to defeat every other asset and currency on the planet. Governments fear segwit and thats why they are paying people to shill BU and be anti segwit, but we will win.

Yes... very unique with its forks and hundreds of clones of which some vastly superior and in the progress of taking over the bitcoin economy.
For anybody claiming bitcoin is in its early stages of adoption, you clearly know nothing about technological advancement. Maybe finish highschool first before shouting all this nonsense.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: pereira4 on December 26, 2016, 02:14:09 PM
Agreed, I think we are way undervalued and when people see that think that they should be selling for $2000 not $900 then the price will continue rising. Today was faster than is usually healthy but we need to get up to $1000-$2500 and stay there for a prolonged period. If we do this then more and more good stuff will be developed for Bitcoin as the economy will be significant enough.
We are undervalued indeed. When its all said and done, bitcoin is an unique asset and no other asset can deliver a similar experience. Once we solve some problems and release segwit into the wild then we will have a package strong enough to defeat every other asset and currency on the planet. Governments fear segwit and thats why they are paying people to shill BU and be anti segwit, but we will win.

Yes... very unique with its forks and hundreds of clones of which some vastly superior and in the progress of taking over the bitcoin economy.
For anybody claiming bitcoin is in its early stages of adoption, you clearly know nothing about technological advancement. Maybe finish highschool first before shouting all this nonsense.

Oh yeah, they are in the progress of taking over the bitcoin economy, that's why BTC dominance over all existing cryptos is always above 80% on average. In fact, it is right now at 87.5% as all alts go deep into the red because guess what, when king BTC starts going up, nobody gives a fuck about altcoins, too bad you are just a dumbass that keeps ignoring the facts. Keep dreaming with that altcoin that takes over Bitcoin's #1 spot if that makes you sleep better.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: aardvark15 on December 26, 2016, 02:31:12 PM
The surprising thing to me is how rapidly the price has gone up. It just seems like a pump with such a big increase in a short period of time.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: romero121 on December 26, 2016, 07:01:46 PM
The surprising thing to me is how rapidly the price has gone up. It just seems like a pump with such a big increase in a short period of time.

Price increase is an longtime expectation of users. Also to reach $1000 is really a hard thing, because bitcoin has crossed $1000 very few times as well the price didn't sustain long to give users the targeted earning to be achieved.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: uki on December 26, 2016, 08:40:48 PM
Lol, looks like we've gone completely sideways since 2013, but I know that's not the case.  Either way I think we're probably in too steep a rise.  We're due for a correction, though I hate to use an overused term from financial journalism.  There's no other way to describe it.  Too much buying, and who knows if these are just short-term speculators or real investors.  Buying has to come from somewhere.
It is because of the logarithmic scale the OP used on his chart. The picture is disturbed by what happened in 2012-2013, where the price went exponential all the way to $1200.
Now, if you look at this year and the price doubled, you see it as almost horizontal line, and in fact we did a fantastic progress this year.
I fully agree that a correction would be very healthy right now, to cool down the technical indicators that are in the overbought territory and to find the energy for the next leg up.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: mindrust on December 26, 2016, 08:44:20 PM
Crazy times all over again.

I hope this time it is not a manipulation but a real serious price pump which is going to last for a long time. I think we will see above 1000$+ no matter what. It can't happen in one day but remember, a few months ago we were in 400's. First 550, then 650, then 700+ and now nearly 900$.

We will get there.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: Soros Shorts on December 26, 2016, 09:33:17 PM
The surprising thing to me is how rapidly the price has gone up. It just seems like a pump with such a big increase in a short period of time.

You ought to know by now ... the price goes up (and down) in short spurts. Most of the big price movements happen in just a few days of the year. The rest of the time the price just drifts or goes up and down in a boring trading range.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: lionheart78 on December 26, 2016, 10:40:35 PM


Yes... very unique with its forks and hundreds of clones of which some vastly superior and in the progress of taking over the bitcoin economy.
For anybody claiming bitcoin is in its early stages of adoption, you clearly know nothing about technological advancement. Maybe finish highschool first before shouting all this nonsense.

I don't think a specific item adoption has a direct relation to technological advancement. If it does then this is a new class I guess.  And as far as I know economics is somehow branched out of technology advancement in terms of people adoption.  Because there are items that were created according to ancient technology but was just in an early phase of mass adoption.

Crazy times all over again.

I hope this time it is not a manipulation but a real serious price pump which is going to last for a long time. I think we will see above 1000$+ no matter what. It can't happen in one day but remember, a few months ago we were in 400's. First 550, then 650, then 700+ and now nearly 900$.

We will get there.

I hope too but it was so fast that it breaks $900  and as result, there are dips and rise for how many times, maybe a correction of some sort but I think whales are really manipulating this uptrend and taking advantage of the dip to accumulate more.


Title: Re: Is the current rally really that crazy?
Post by: Skarner21 on December 26, 2016, 11:34:27 PM
Crazy times all over again.

I hope this time it is not a manipulation but a real serious price pump which is going to last for a long time. I think we will see above 1000$+ no matter what. It can't happen in one day but remember, a few months ago we were in 400's. First 550, then 650, then 700+ and now nearly 900$.

We will get there.
I can not still believe with bitco in right now maybe this coming 2017 and my own prediction is march or may we can see that the price will touch in 1k value. and this coming january i fell that the price will decrease more even we are seen that the price is playing from 880-900 above it is because bitcoin right now is in demand  this january if people are going back to work i am sure that the price will decrease again back..