Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Bitcoin Discussion => Topic started by: Dimelord on March 09, 2017, 11:48:51 AM



Title: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: Dimelord on March 09, 2017, 11:48:51 AM
It seems around 72% of public is in favour of bitcoin ETF approval.The other 28% have raised the issue i.e., the fear of hard fork.Will Bitcoin ETF will be approved soon?


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: crazyivan on March 09, 2017, 12:04:01 PM
I think we ll have to wait for at least one more year until we see something like that in practice.

I dont know where you get your figures but I think chances re less the less then 15% to see a favorable decision tomorrow.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: Xester on March 09, 2017, 12:15:44 PM
It seems around 72% of public is in favour of bitcoin ETF approval.The other 28% have raised the issue i.e., the fear of hard fork.Will Bitcoin ETF will be approved soon?

We still dont have the answer and so we are but to wait for the decision. Though the majority of the public is in favor of ETF but they are not the one who will make the decision but the SEC. This just means that even if we really wanted it hard we cannot have it if the SEC will not allow it. The best thing to do now is to wait if ETF will be approved or not.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: calkob on March 09, 2017, 12:16:53 PM
It seems around 72% of public is in favour of bitcoin ETF approval.The other 28% have raised the issue i.e., the fear of hard fork.Will Bitcoin ETF will be approved soon?

Can you provide any evidence for these statistics and claims ?  i have been thinking that the sell off over the last couple days would show that people seem to think the the ETF wont be approved, otherwise why would you be selling?  i am agnostic to the ETF myself either way i think bitcoin will continue to grow anyway.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: Rupucers on March 09, 2017, 12:20:06 PM
From what i read most favour that ecision will be negative. And btw it will be on 13th not 11th. As it's saturday.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: KennyR on March 09, 2017, 12:20:50 PM
Nothing Is impossible with technology. Both possibility is found, can get approved else won't get approved. I don't think the polling status to be the effective one, because right now 3-6% of people use bitcoin and the statistical analysis too need to meet the database.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: royalfestus on March 09, 2017, 12:24:20 PM
if not for the weekend, we have less than a week. the agitation is worrisome and everyone like to see the end of it but most approval rating is low, Recent the news are not specific on the approval and no inside information.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: Pamadar on March 09, 2017, 12:39:56 PM
its really hard to say whether its really gain that enough support in terms of etf approval but considering this possibility i guess
more and more people will place their own investment just in case etf got approved, its still early but i'm hoping for the best
coming from this investment system that i'm into.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: szpalata on March 09, 2017, 12:44:43 PM
It seems around 72% of public is in favour of bitcoin ETF approval.The other 28% have raised the issue i.e., the fear of hard fork.Will Bitcoin ETF will be approved soon?

We are all craving for improvement do if the public opinion could ensure that its passed and Bitcoin is entirely changed for the better then I'm all for it. I don't want to be drawn into the politics of it. Anything capable of being a solution will be fine by me.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: bamboylee on March 09, 2017, 01:13:07 PM
I want to know where you got your figures. Is it a reliable source?

We all want the ETF to be approved. It will be a good development for bitcoin, not only for the price but for the overall adoption of bitcoin. But if ever it gets denied tomorrow, they can try again next year. And I think there are two other ETF being pushed.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: iamTom123 on March 09, 2017, 01:21:26 PM
One of the factors favoring the rise of BTC now is the possibility of it being approved by SEC. And there can be some possible repercussions if it will be negative. However, I do believe that BTC is of course long term and though there can be minor setbacks along the way still the future looks bright for this digital coin.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: rayban2 on March 09, 2017, 01:25:46 PM
I hope I'm wrong, but I don't think it will be approved this time. BTC is too volatile for wall street appetites.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: Searing on March 09, 2017, 01:26:12 PM
I'm still sitting on hands. SEC is waiting till last day, to show a statment and slap us 'crypto
upstarts' Down an in our    'Minion Places'. All about controlling the serfs, don't ya know.

My hopefully, too dark and wrong view


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: AngryDwarf on March 09, 2017, 01:29:06 PM
I hope I'm wrong, but I don't think it will be approved this time. BTC is too volatile for wall street appetites.

Traders love volatility. That's how they make their money.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: batang_bitcoin on March 09, 2017, 03:31:57 PM
I want to know where that percentage you got from, any source of it? Well most of the bitcoin community is in favor of ETF though the question is really tough which SEC is the one that will answer it. We don't have choice for now and wait what will be the decision of it. But many of us here are hoping that it will be approved.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: Kprawn on March 09, 2017, 05:13:13 PM
The insider traders have already grabbed their share of the profits.... The people hanging around now, are only people who got swayed by the

hype. We have seen what New York did with the BitLicence and history will repeat itself with this ETF. The masters behind the riches of this world

will not allow the ETF to go through and they think this will stop Bitcoin. They have not seen anything yet, this is just the beginning.  ;)


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: lite on March 09, 2017, 07:05:35 PM
It seems around 72% of public is in favour of bitcoin ETF approval.The other 28% have raised the issue i.e., the fear of hard fork.Will Bitcoin ETF will be approved soon?
We'll have to wait out and see if gets approved or not. i hope it gets approved, so the price could moon. ::)

I want to know where that percentage you got from, any source of it? Well most of the bitcoin community is in favor of ETF though the question is really tough which SEC is the one that will answer it. We don't have choice for now and wait what will be the decision of it. But many of us here are hoping that it will be approved.
https://cointelegraph.com/news/why-bitcoin-etf-approval-is-likely-72-percent-in-favor-so-far


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: Cereberus on March 09, 2017, 07:15:30 PM
It seems around 72% of public is in favour of bitcoin ETF approval.The other 28% have raised the issue i.e., the fear of hard fork.Will Bitcoin ETF will be approved soon?
We'll have to wait out and see if gets approved or not. i hope it gets approved, so the price could moon. ::)

I want to know where that percentage you got from, any source of it? Well most of the bitcoin community is in favor of ETF though the question is really tough which SEC is the one that will answer it. We don't have choice for now and wait what will be the decision of it. But many of us here are hoping that it will be approved.
https://cointelegraph.com/news/why-bitcoin-etf-approval-is-likely-72-percent-in-favor-so-far

Cointelegraph is well known for promoting even scams as we have seen in it's history of posting . You just pay them a good amount of money and they can write whatever you ask them. 72% sounds not very plausible to me and I think this statistic is wrong. Anyway I am waiting for the 11 March.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: bitcampaign on March 09, 2017, 08:40:59 PM
the key is to stop the debate from two opposite directions or greedy for an argument, to rethink the future of bitcoin at least they really find a solution not to compete who should be heard for Segwit or BU :)


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: BitcoinPanther on March 09, 2017, 08:56:51 PM
It seems around 72% of public is in favour of bitcoin ETF approval.The other 28% have raised the issue i.e., the fear of hard fork.Will Bitcoin ETF will be approved soon?

As much as we wanted to decide it and be approved ourselves, we are in no way capable of doing so.  We have to wait for the authority (SEC) to decide for it.  I hope this 72% will influence SEC to approve that ETF so that we can see another Bitcoin Milestone.  If ever this thing happen (ETF approval), this people who had bought this current dip will certainly celebrating.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: lionheart78 on March 09, 2017, 09:11:44 PM
the key is to stop the debate from two opposite directions or greedy for an argument, to rethink the future of bitcoin at least they really find a solution not to compete who should be heard for Segwit or BU :)

I would rather have them the debate than working silently surprising us of the hidden catch of their plans.  Debating in a  healthful way like pointing out flaws and possible negative effect to the users when time come is good.  Aside from that both party will make their best to deliver the best possible solution even taking each opposing party's point to make the best out of it.



It is good to see 72% are in favor of ETF approval, I think those users who are not in favor are wanting to accumulate Bitcoin more since once ETF is approved, we can see Bitcoin price to gradually increase and it will be much expensive for them to buy BTC.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: richardsNY on March 09, 2017, 09:57:20 PM
The insider traders have already grabbed their share of the profits.... The people hanging around now, are only people who got swayed by the

hype. We have seen what New York did with the BitLicence and history will repeat itself with this ETF. The masters behind the riches of this world

will not allow the ETF to go through and they think this will stop Bitcoin. They have not seen anything yet, this is just the beginning.  ;)

How do you already know that insiders have taken profits, which directly translates into you assuming that the ETF won't come through? If that was really the case, then the price would jump up to far higher levels where the dump would be felt immensely. So far we have gone through normal dumps that most long term Bitcoiners are very familiar with. That aside, this ETF isn't so big that it will do much damage to Bitcoin. At worst a denial will result in a possible test of $1000 which I believe will hold.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: FiendCoin on March 09, 2017, 10:04:53 PM
The insider traders have already grabbed their share of the profits.... The people hanging around now, are only people who got swayed by the

hype. We have seen what New York did with the BitLicence and history will repeat itself with this ETF. The masters behind the riches of this world

will not allow the ETF to go through and they think this will stop Bitcoin. They have not seen anything yet, this is just the beginning.  ;)

How do you already know that insiders have taken profits, which directly translates into you assuming that the ETF won't come through? If that was really the case, then the price would jump up to far higher levels where the dump would be felt immensely. So far we have gone through normal dumps that most long term Bitcoiners are very familiar with. That aside, this ETF isn't so big that it will do much damage to Bitcoin. At worst a denial will result in a possible test of $1000 which I believe will hold.

If there is a rejection, which at this point is highly unlikely I think, there will be a 20-50% temporary drop in price. Again, a TEMPORARY drop. The price will recover by the end of the year regardless, unless BU splits the blockchain, then all bets are off as far as how far we drop and how long we stay there.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: Skarner21 on March 09, 2017, 10:24:40 PM
The insider traders have already grabbed their share of the profits.... The people hanging around now, are only people who got swayed by the

hype. We have seen what New York did with the BitLicence and history will repeat itself with this ETF. The masters behind the riches of this world

will not allow the ETF to go through and they think this will stop Bitcoin. They have not seen anything yet, this is just the beginning.  ;)

How do you already know that insiders have taken profits, which directly translates into you assuming that the ETF won't come through? If that was really the case, then the price would jump up to far higher levels where the dump would be felt immensely. So far we have gone through normal dumps that most long term Bitcoiners are very familiar with. That aside, this ETF isn't so big that it will do much damage to Bitcoin. At worst a denial will result in a possible test of $1000 which I believe will hold.

If there is a rejection, which at this point is highly unlikely I think, there will be a 20-50% temporary drop in price. Again, a TEMPORARY drop. The price will recover by the end of the year regardless, unless BU splits the blockchain, then all bets are off as far as how far we drop and how long we stay there.
I'll hope that ETF won't affect the price of bitcoin if ETF will rejected since i think this is not the reason why the price for bitcoin right now are still increase back after down yesterday.. 
And i think ETF approval has only small chance to be approve..


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: richardsNY on March 09, 2017, 10:55:01 PM
The insider traders have already grabbed their share of the profits.... The people hanging around now, are only people who got swayed by the

hype. We have seen what New York did with the BitLicence and history will repeat itself with this ETF. The masters behind the riches of this world

will not allow the ETF to go through and they think this will stop Bitcoin. They have not seen anything yet, this is just the beginning.  ;)

How do you already know that insiders have taken profits, which directly translates into you assuming that the ETF won't come through? If that was really the case, then the price would jump up to far higher levels where the dump would be felt immensely. So far we have gone through normal dumps that most long term Bitcoiners are very familiar with. That aside, this ETF isn't so big that it will do much damage to Bitcoin. At worst a denial will result in a possible test of $1000 which I believe will hold.

If there is a rejection, which at this point is highly unlikely I think, there will be a 20-50% temporary drop in price. Again, a TEMPORARY drop. The price will recover by the end of the year regardless, unless BU splits the blockchain, then all bets are off as far as how far we drop and how long we stay there.

It's fantastic that the ETF will be a great help to get institutional investors on board, but it's not such a major development that it will crash down the price with 50% in case of a denial. Even not for a very short time. Especially when you consider that it's the demand that accounts for the majority of the growth that the price experienced so far. The only thing that has the ability to push the price down that far is the ongoing block size "war" between different sides. And then more the negative results.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: Wesimon on March 10, 2017, 12:30:32 AM
It seems around 72% of public is in favour of bitcoin ETF approval.The other 28% have raised the issue i.e., the fear of hard fork.Will Bitcoin ETF will be approved soon?

It is better if we just wait for the decision of ETF's approval. No speculations. Whatever the result is, bitcoin is in good path.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: batang_bitcoin on March 10, 2017, 04:02:45 AM
I want to know where that percentage you got from, any source of it? Well most of the bitcoin community is in favor of ETF though the question is really tough which SEC is the one that will answer it. We don't have choice for now and wait what will be the decision of it. But many of us here are hoping that it will be approved.
https://cointelegraph.com/news/why-bitcoin-etf-approval-is-likely-72-percent-in-favor-so-far

Cointelegraph is well known for promoting even scams as we have seen in it's history of posting . You just pay them a good amount of money and they can write whatever you ask them. 72% sounds not very plausible to me and I think this statistic is wrong. Anyway I am waiting for the 11 March.

Those cases you are mentioning is different from this and well the real is that I don't know if that 72% is believable. Though this is for the good of us if approval does have higher approval rate rather than decline. 1 more day to go or I've read somewhere here on forum that ETF approval will on the 13th? Well regardless of the date, it's coming near.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: piloder on March 10, 2017, 06:12:23 AM
It seems around 72% of public is in favour of bitcoin ETF approval.The other 28% have raised the issue i.e., the fear of hard fork.Will Bitcoin ETF will be approved soon?
Only public is in favour of bitcoin ETF but not the SEC (Securities and Exchange Commission ) and they are the one who have to give approval. So i don't think bitcoin ETF will be approved today (March 10) by them. I am thinking about buying more bitcoin if there will be some price correction after this.


Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: Searing on March 10, 2017, 07:39:08 AM
Still think there is no way the ETF will pass. As a Bureaucracy...ie keep our gov't jobs with as little risk as possible..why add to the work?...the safe bet is to punt it down the road and say you are looking other alternative ETF's down the road..and everything has to 'simmer' longer on a decision...just what I think

then again 800 usd BTC again would be 'rather nice'

on the other hand

1500 plus BTC would also be nice

I see no way to lose on this ..whatever they decide :)



Title: Re: Bitcoin ETF approval 72% favour?
Post by: Idrisu on March 10, 2017, 07:46:41 AM
From what i read most favour that ecision will be negative. And btw it will be on 13th not 11th. As it's saturday.
I also think in line with what you have read if favour of that decision will be negative then what is the need of approving it now? But because of the panic and speculation it has generated disapproval will create havoc to bitcoin as many will sell off bitcoin out of panic.