Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Bitcoin Technical Support => Topic started by: depth10 on November 12, 2017, 03:04:52 AM



Title: BTC Legacy vs Segwit wallet
Post by: depth10 on November 12, 2017, 03:04:52 AM
I've learned that most exchanges and wallets support the Segwit chain now, but some do not (Exodus, for example).  Will I run into any issues transferring BTC from, say, Coinbase (Segwit) to Exodus (non-Segwit) to Ledger (Segwit)?  Will the middle link (Exodus which is non-Segwit) mess up the transaction in any way?

See here for Exodus wallet roadmap, scroll all they way to bottom. http://support.exodus.io/article/96-exodus-wallet-roadmap


Title: Re: BTC Legacy vs Segwit wallet
Post by: achow101 on November 12, 2017, 05:16:00 AM
There is no "the Segwit chain". That chain is Bitcoin, and all Bitcoin wallets support it and use it regardless of whether they have implemented segwit itself or not.

Will I run into any issues transferring BTC from, say, Coinbase (Segwit) to Exodus (non-Segwit) to Ledger (Segwit)?  Will the middle link (Exodus which is non-Segwit) mess up the transaction in any way?
There is no problem because it is all still Bitcoin and on the Bitcoin chain.


Title: Re: BTC Legacy vs Segwit wallet
Post by: erk on November 24, 2017, 05:33:21 AM
I've learned that most exchanges and wallets support the Segwit chain now, but some do not (Exodus, for example).  Will I run into any issues transferring BTC from, say, Coinbase (Segwit) to Exodus (non-Segwit) to Ledger (Segwit)?  Will the middle link (Exodus which is non-Segwit) mess up the transaction in any way?

See here for Exodus wallet roadmap, scroll all they way to bottom. http://support.exodus.io/article/96-exodus-wallet-roadmap

Exodus is not really a good BTC wallet, it can't generate a Segwit receive address to help the network fees, but you can't even set BTC fees lower than their default, any BTC movement out of Exodus will cost you a fortune compared to other wallets.



Title: Re: BTC Legacy vs Segwit wallet
Post by: Crypto4K on November 24, 2017, 11:26:31 AM
Why don't get a hardware wallet in the first place?

Armory and Blockchain.info is good too.. they both support both chains


Title: Re: BTC Legacy vs Segwit wallet
Post by: SureLockLoans on November 24, 2017, 12:57:04 PM
Why don't get a hardware wallet in the first place?

Armory and Blockchain.info is good too.. they both support both chains

Blockchain.info is not good. It's a poorly written wallet which has numerous issues including not being able to get fees right which either results in you overpaying or underpaying drastically.

Armory on the other hand is decent at least.


Title: Re: BTC Legacy vs Segwit wallet
Post by: Thirdspace on November 25, 2017, 01:13:22 PM
There is no "the Segwit chain". That chain is Bitcoin, and all Bitcoin wallets support it and use it regardless of whether they have implemented segwit itself or not.

There is no problem because it is all still Bitcoin and on the Bitcoin chain.
Armory and Blockchain.info is good too.. they both support both chains

just like achow101 said, all BTC wallets support & use it regardless
one thing I notice that bc.info explorer doesn't show transaction involving segwit address correctly
it's showing as Unable to decode output address but will show the address correctly on advanced view mode
also I tried to search segwit address on a few explorers and none can give me result
how exactly I can check a segwit address balance on explorer? is it possible?