Bitcoin Forum

Other => Meta => Topic started by: Mc_Moneysack on April 04, 2018, 02:34:51 PM



Title: I was just offered a merit trade-off
Post by: Mc_Moneysack on April 04, 2018, 02:34:51 PM
A member of this forum just approached me via personal message and suggested to me to "trade" merits. So for giving him merit he would give me the same amount back.
While I was at first inclined to accept this offer, I have decided to do the right thing and raise awareness for this issue, since I am quite sure that things like these happen all the time.

Any suggestions on what would be the appropriate steps to take? I am not a fan of naming and shaming but maybe this would be the right thing to do.

I am also not very enthusiastic about the merit system but still think that we should all play by the rules and earn our merit.


Title: Re: I was just offered a merit trade-off
Post by: RYXES on April 04, 2018, 02:36:08 PM
No one likes a rat.


Title: Re: I was just offered a merit trade-off
Post by: Jet Cash on April 04, 2018, 02:46:03 PM
Do you really want to risk your reputation for four merits. That's 2 sMerits you might have, and 2 more from the four that he sends you.

I'm not sure why you even felt that it was worth asking the board.


Title: Re: I was just offered a merit trade-off
Post by: Cobalt9317 on April 04, 2018, 03:05:24 PM
A member of this forum just approached me via personal message and suggested to me to "trade" merits. So for giving him merit he would give me the same amount back.
While I was at first inclined to accept this offer, I have decided to do the right thing and raise awareness for this issue, since I am quite sure that things like these happen all the time.

Any suggestions on what would be the appropriate steps to take? I am not a fan of naming and shaming but maybe this would be the right thing to do.

I am also not very enthusiastic about the merit system but still think that we should all play by the rules and earn our merit.
Luckily you didn't get involve in hippie dippy shenanigans just remember the old way of this forum to get known each other is the only way and don't worry such flaws of merit system is inevitable (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=3243502.0) and having a good judgement about the matter saves your well being, you will feel physically good in the next following days for such acts that you exposed.
 
No one likes a rat.
And we are preventing it for uploading an avatar that resembles a cat, I might get one of those avatar soon.  ;D

Do you really want to risk your reputation for four merits. That's 2 sMerits you might have, and 2 more from the four that he sends you.

I'm not sure why you even felt that it was worth asking the board.
Speaking of cat I thought you were going to used the Talk Merit alt to talk about merit?


Title: Re: I was just offered a merit trade-off
Post by: Mc_Moneysack on April 04, 2018, 03:06:12 PM
Do you really want to risk your reputation for four merits. That's 2 sMerits you might have, and 2 more from the four that he sends you.

I'm not sure why you even felt that it was worth asking the board.

No of course I don’t,  but I suppose there would be subtle ways of hiding the trade. Being tempted by an easy gain is quite human I would say.

I have asked the board for advice since I didn’t want to overstep by rating out another member. As I saw, there seem to be different views regarding the trade with merits.




Title: Re: I was just offered a merit trade-off
Post by: Talk merit on April 04, 2018, 03:10:04 PM
>..<
Speaking of cat I thought you were going to used the Talk Merit alt to talk about merit?
[/quote]

I was/am, but I only had one browser open at the time. I was cruising the boards looking for posts to merit, but I didn't have much luck.


Title: Re: I was just offered a merit trade-off
Post by: TMAN on April 04, 2018, 03:10:54 PM
Do you really want to risk your reputation for four merits. That's 2 sMerits you might have, and 2 more from the four that he sends you.

I'm not sure why you even felt that it was worth asking the board.

No of course I don’t,  but I suppose there would be subtle ways of hiding the trade. Being tempted by an easy gain is quite human I would say.

I have asked the board for advice since I didn’t want to overstep by rating out another member. As I saw, there seem to be different views regarding the trade with merits.




you did the right thing fella, don't worry about it - although dependent on who it is you may want to forward the PM to someone on DT, but that is totally your call.


Title: Re: I was just offered a merit trade-off
Post by: Mc_Moneysack on April 04, 2018, 03:31:20 PM
Just click "Report To Admin" hyperlink on that PM offer and fill in the reason (which is merit trade attempt in this case), problem solved.

Cheers will do that!


Title: Re: I was just offered a merit trade-off
Post by: KingScorpio on April 04, 2018, 03:32:50 PM
A member of this forum just approached me via personal message and suggested to me to "trade" merits. So for giving him merit he would give me the same amount back.
While I was at first inclined to accept this offer, I have decided to do the right thing and raise awareness for this issue, since I am quite sure that things like these happen all the time.

Any suggestions on what would be the appropriate steps to take? I am not a fan of naming and shaming but maybe this would be the right thing to do.

I am also not very enthusiastic about the merit system but still think that we should all play by the rules and earn our merit.

the merit system is broken garbage, it will get destroyed for good reasons, and the admins will become surveilance monsters.... then sooner or later no one will like to use this forum anymore.

i compare the merit system with central banks, you are loosing against them if you are not part of the elite that is controlling and faking a "just" system with them

this forum has no interest in giving merit, at all, everyone seeks to gain trusted attention only "god" can help you in this.


Title: Re: I was just offered a merit trade-off
Post by: Vod on April 04, 2018, 03:41:12 PM
A member of this forum just approached me via personal message and suggested to me to "trade" merits. So for giving him merit he would give me the same amount back.
While I was at first inclined to accept this offer, I have decided to do the right thing and raise awareness for this issue, since I am quite sure that things like these happen all the time.

Any suggestions on what would be the appropriate steps to take? I am not a fan of naming and shaming but maybe this would be the right thing to do.

I am also not very enthusiastic about the merit system but still think that we should all play by the rules and earn our merit.

Post a screenshot of the message here, and to be helpful, a link to his profile.

I will tag it, as trading merits goes against the intention of the system.


Title: Re: I was just offered a merit trade-off
Post by: Vod on April 04, 2018, 03:42:03 PM
No one likes a rat.

I love rats.  :)

If no one reported anything, this forum would be overrun with Quicksellers.  :/