Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Bitcoin Discussion => Topic started by: ­­­Atlas_ on April 01, 2011, 02:42:08 PM



Title: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: ­­­Atlas_ on April 01, 2011, 02:42:08 PM
I spent a good few hours speaking with the man last night discussing the elimination of the gold standard and competitive private currencies. Eventually the subject came to Bitcoin. After firmly convincing him that Bitcoin is the monetary standard of the future, he wants to back his entire campaign with BTC. I am negotiating with him to become his funding manager when it comes to Bitcoin funding.

Well, this is going to be huge.


Title: Re: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: ksd5 on April 01, 2011, 02:44:29 PM
Unless this is an April Fool's joke, of course...


Title: Re: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: MoonShadow on April 01, 2011, 03:01:53 PM
Unless this is an April Fool's joke, of course...

Here we go, and I have hoped for a little bump in xrate on mtgox  ;D

I'm with the April Fool's joke.  Considering that I live in Rand Paul's district, campaigned for both him and his father (2008 presidential run); and that I am a Kentucky State Delegate, I have more to say about this than the average bear.  I can say for certain that 1) the Pauls are aware of Bitcoin (as well as other alternatives) but don't think too hard on that,(gold is another subject) neither has a couple hours to spend talking to anyone outside of their family or professional teams, and Bitcoin cannot be accepted for a political campaign due to campaign finance laws.  (I checked).


Title: Re: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: Jered Kenna (TradeHill) on April 01, 2011, 04:50:08 PM
Unless this is an April Fool's joke, of course...

Here we go, and I have hoped for a little bump in xrate on mtgox  ;D

I'm with the April Fool's joke.  Considering that I live in Rand Paul's district, campaigned for both him and his father (2008 presidential run); and that I am a Kentucky State Delegate, I have more to say about this than the average bear.  I can say for certain that 1) the Pauls are aware of Bitcoin (as well as other alternatives) but don't think too hard on that,(gold is another subject) neither has a couple hours to spend talking to anyone outside of their family or professional teams, and Bitcoin cannot be accepted for a political campaign due to campaign finance laws.  (I checked).

How's Bitcoin compare to all the however many small donations that Obama received?


Title: Re: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: MoonShadow on April 01, 2011, 06:09:05 PM
Unless this is an April Fool's joke, of course...

Here we go, and I have hoped for a little bump in xrate on mtgox  ;D

I'm with the April Fool's joke.  Considering that I live in Rand Paul's district, campaigned for both him and his father (2008 presidential run); and that I am a Kentucky State Delegate, I have more to say about this than the average bear.  I can say for certain that 1) the Pauls are aware of Bitcoin (as well as other alternatives) but don't think too hard on that,(gold is another subject) neither has a couple hours to spend talking to anyone outside of their family or professional teams, and Bitcoin cannot be accepted for a political campaign due to campaign finance laws.  (I checked).

How's Bitcoin compare to all the however many small donations that Obama received?

1)  I wouldn't call Obama's average donation "small" and...

2)  the campaign finance laws require that they cannot accept donations from anyone that they cannot show is an American citizen; which in practice requires disclosure.  Bitcoin undermines disclosure.


Title: Re: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: MoonShadow on April 01, 2011, 06:22:48 PM
Quote
2)  the campaign finance laws require that they cannot accept donations from anyone that they cannot show is an American citizen; which in practice requires disclosure.  Bitcoin undermines disclosure.

They do not have to accept anonymous donations, do they? This is just a matter of organization to ensure that all the bitcoin donation come from US citizens. You do not argue that this cannot be done when using bitcoin, do you?

No, it could be done.  It's just not (perhaps, yet) worth the work to set up a bitcoin donation system that will not provide the donator a bitcoin address until s/he provides the data, and asking for that data tends to offend the kind of person who might otherwise donate to a Paul.  Using credit card donations, the credit card company provides most of that required data.


Title: Re: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: goatpig on April 01, 2011, 06:33:09 PM
Wouldn't be "too" hard. Setup a donation site, people register there with some sort of IRS approved proof of their identity (let's say social security #), then send a wallet.dat through the site, or burn it on a cd and ship it via the postal office.


Title: Re: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: grondilu on April 01, 2011, 06:35:35 PM
This gives me an idea for a poll (http://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5292.0)



Title: Re: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: river on April 01, 2011, 06:46:52 PM
Instead of check an action against LAWS that are obviously corrupt .. how about checking the action against the 'constitution' of you nation (which most governments intentionally violate).

Bitcoin is just currency .. hence it is lawful to use as currency ... not because I said so .. but because it does not violate constitutional rights or liberties.  It's just money.  Only the corrupt laws made my high treasonous central bankers make it 'illegal' .. but it's still lawful, depending on it's application.


Title: Re: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: rezin777 on April 01, 2011, 07:10:15 PM
Instead of check an action against LAWS that are obviously corrupt .. how about checking the action against the 'constitution' of you nation (which most governments intentionally violate).

Bitcoin is just currency .. hence it is lawful to use as currency ... not because I said so .. but because it does not violate constitutional rights or liberties.  It's just money.  Only the corrupt laws made my high treasonous central bankers make it 'illegal' .. but it's still lawful, depending on it's application.

Unfortunately, for the average citizen, it doesn't matter whether a law is corrupt or not, they will be punished all the same for breaking said law. Especially since most jurors probably don't even know what jury nullification is (by design I suspect), not to mention the perversion that is case law. Knowing a law is corrupt is one thing, intentionally ignoring it because of that knowledge is another. While this can be an exciting undertaking for activists, it's something the grey man wishes to avoid. Of course, avoid it for too long and you can only try to enjoy your slavery. 


Title: Re: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: goatpig on April 01, 2011, 07:15:27 PM
Instead of check an action against LAWS that are obviously corrupt .. how about checking the action against the 'constitution' of you nation (which most governments intentionally violate).

Bitcoin is just currency .. hence it is lawful to use as currency ... not because I said so .. but because it does not violate constitutional rights or liberties.  It's just money.  Only the corrupt laws made my high treasonous central bankers make it 'illegal' .. but it's still lawful, depending on it's application.

The issue isn't that Bitcoin is illegal, actually it isn't (yet). The issue is that you have to prove you are an American citizen to donate to an American political party. The true issue actually is that such a party has to prove it received its donation from American citizens only. This is obviously a law to prevent the involvement of non American interests in national politics, but then again, given the USA involvement in the world, maybe foreigners should have their word in American politics.


Title: Re: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: rezin777 on April 01, 2011, 07:30:09 PM
maybe foreigners should have their word in American politics.

Right after American citizen's get theirs!  ;D


Title: Re: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: river on April 01, 2011, 07:44:08 PM
I am American .. I'm Canadian .. duh!
You guys really need a name for your Nation, instead of taking the Continents name.


Title: Re: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: MoonShadow on April 01, 2011, 08:01:45 PM
I am American .. I'm Canadian .. duh!
You guys really need a name for your Nation, instead of taking the Continents name.

aren't they study geography using globe of united states, it's a miracle that they do not call it united states of earth  or better yet united states of solar system ;)

Patience...


Title: Re: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: goatpig on April 01, 2011, 08:22:53 PM
I am American .. I'm Canadian .. duh!
You guys really need a name for your Nation, instead of taking the Continents name.

Actually im French =O


Title: Re: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: MoonShadow on April 01, 2011, 09:20:59 PM
2)  the campaign finance laws require that they cannot accept donations from anyone that they cannot show is an American citizen; which in practice requires disclosure.  Bitcoin undermines disclosure.

Unless it is a Bitcoin funded U.S. corporation.

Corporations, unions and PACs have different political donation rules altogether.  I don't know them well, but I doubt that this would work.


Title: Re: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: river on April 01, 2011, 09:24:33 PM
Or if you are a United States citizen.  And send it with a published address linked to yourself.
As I said .. it all depends on how you APPLY it.


Title: Re: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: Anonymous on April 01, 2011, 11:52:02 PM
bitcoinusa requires ID to use their service. It would be easy for them to say who is a US citizen or not.



Title: Re: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: MoonShadow on April 02, 2011, 01:12:38 AM
bitcoinusa requires ID to use their service. It would be easy for them to say who is a US citizen or not.



Very good point.  In my defense, they didn't exist when I brought this up.  Perhaps bitcoinusa is a solution.


Title: Re: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: danglybits on June 02, 2011, 07:55:22 PM
If there were a way to verify donations made to a candidate then you could pay american citizens to make donations.

I suspect that many people who would support Paul do not because they do not want to end up on a "list" that gets published.  Many others do not care about the "list", but have no money.   

Solution:  make a donation, get a receipt, get reimbursed via bitcoin and keep a small percent.


Title: Re: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: MoonShadow on June 02, 2011, 09:34:03 PM
Is it leagal to give cash to a campaign?

Only if the campaign can record all of the data that campaign finance laws require.  In effect, no.


Title: Re: I am in negotiations with presidential candidate Ron Paul...
Post by: technowizard12 on June 02, 2011, 11:18:05 PM
This thread made me picture a troll in an Italian jester hat.