Bitcoin Forum

Other => Beginners & Help => Topic started by: KidPoker on November 07, 2014, 09:50:38 PM



Title: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: KidPoker on November 07, 2014, 09:50:38 PM
I need to buy a new laptop anyway so I was wondering if I completely wipe my current laptop (It's a sony vaio) could I then use it as my cold storage laptop? I plan to make a large investment in bitcoins very soon and was wondering if factory resetting my current laptop would be sufficient in terms of security? Cheers.


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: SpanishSoldier on November 07, 2014, 10:00:10 PM
I need to buy a new laptop anyway so I was wondering if I completely wipe my current laptop (It's a sony vaio) could I then use it as my cold storage laptop? I plan to make a large investment in bitcoins very soon and was wondering if factory resetting my current laptop would be sufficient in terms of security? Cheers.

1. Disconnect the laptop from internet.

2. Run Bitcoin-QT or some program to generate your address.

3. Send the wallet to an USB.

4. Remove the USB.

5. Ctrl+Shift+Del your wallet details from the laptop. If possible, format it once.

6. Connect your laptop to the internet and send bitcoin to your address, whose details are in USB.

7. Just keep the USB detouched from all internet connections... and you are safe :)


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: KidPoker on November 07, 2014, 10:10:58 PM
Cheers for the reply. I know about generating wallets/addresses safely and clean booting from ubuntu/tails etc but I want a watch only wallet on my new laptop and have armory installed on my cold laptop. I was under the impression that apart from paper wallets, this is the best option? So I wasn't sure if factory restoring my laptop was be sufficient enough in terms of security to do this?


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: b!z on November 07, 2014, 11:22:27 PM
Remove the wireless card and don't plug anything into it


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: melvinparham556 on November 08, 2014, 01:30:12 AM
I need to buy a new laptop anyway so I was wondering if I completely wipe my current laptop (It's a sony vaio) could I then use it as my cold storage laptop? I plan to make a large investment in bitcoins very soon and was wondering if factory resetting my current laptop would be sufficient in terms of security? Cheers.

you can try something else to check just turn off and turn on...then try again


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: b!z on November 08, 2014, 04:16:45 AM
I need to buy a new laptop anyway so I was wondering if I completely wipe my current laptop (It's a sony vaio) could I then use it as my cold storage laptop? I plan to make a large investment in bitcoins very soon and was wondering if factory resetting my current laptop would be sufficient in terms of security? Cheers.

you can try something else to check just turn off and turn on...then try again

and what will that do?


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: Samthing on November 08, 2014, 04:21:36 AM
I need to buy a new laptop anyway so I was wondering if I completely wipe my current laptop (It's a sony vaio) could I then use it as my cold storage laptop? I plan to make a large investment in bitcoins very soon and was wondering if factory resetting my current laptop would be sufficient in terms of security? Cheers.

1. Disconnect the laptop from internet.

2. Run Bitcoin-QT or some program to generate your address.

3. Send the wallet to an USB.

4. Remove the USB.

5. Ctrl+Shift+Del your wallet details from the laptop. If possible, format it once.

6. Connect your laptop to the internet and send bitcoin to your address, whose details are in USB.

7. Just keep the USB detouched from all internet connections... and you are safe :)

No need to use the Bitcoin-QT and send the dat to a USB. All he need is vanitygen.


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: Brantley on November 08, 2014, 08:49:27 AM
I need to buy a new laptop anyway so I was wondering if I completely wipe my current laptop (It's a sony vaio) could I then use it as my cold storage laptop? I plan to make a large investment in bitcoins very soon and was wondering if factory resetting my current laptop would be sufficient in terms of security? Cheers.

1. Disconnect the laptop from internet.

2. Run Bitcoin-QT or some program to generate your address.

3. Send the wallet to an USB.

4. Remove the USB.

5. Ctrl+Shift+Del your wallet details from the laptop. If possible, format it once.

6. Connect your laptop to the internet and send bitcoin to your address, whose details are in USB.

7. Just keep the USB detouched from all internet connections... and you are safe :)

No need to use the Bitcoin-QT and send the dat to a USB. All he need is vanitygen.
Vanitygen don't allow you to convert it to paper wallet or am I wrong? I believe bitaddress.org is the best for cold storage.


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: shorena on November 08, 2014, 11:07:20 AM
I need to buy a new laptop anyway so I was wondering if I completely wipe my current laptop (It's a sony vaio) could I then use it as my cold storage laptop? I plan to make a large investment in bitcoins very soon and was wondering if factory resetting my current laptop would be sufficient in terms of security? Cheers.

To answer your question: Yes, a wiped machine with disabled WiFi (as someone allready posted) can be used as cold storrage. Just make sure you format all drives before (or durring setup) installing the new OS.


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: Zawamiya on November 08, 2014, 01:02:07 PM
I need to buy a new laptop anyway so I was wondering if I completely wipe my current laptop (It's a sony vaio) could I then use it as my cold storage laptop? I plan to make a large investment in bitcoins very soon and was wondering if factory resetting my current laptop would be sufficient in terms of security? Cheers.

Yes you can do that, and be sure to keep some backup for your wallet..


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: notlist3d on November 08, 2014, 02:11:47 PM
It could I would get rid of the crap they include with most computer's.

Also I would still put a good anti-virus on it and malaware protection before moving in.


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: KidPoker on November 08, 2014, 02:15:38 PM
Thanks for the advice everyone, greatly appreciated.


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: lamaze on November 08, 2014, 02:34:20 PM
I need to buy a new laptop anyway so I was wondering if I completely wipe my current laptop (It's a sony vaio) could I then use it as my cold storage laptop? I plan to make a large investment in bitcoins very soon and was wondering if factory resetting my current laptop would be sufficient in terms of security? Cheers.

1. Disconnect the laptop from internet.

2. Run Bitcoin-QT or some program to generate your address.

3. Send the wallet to an USB.

4. Remove the USB.

5. Ctrl+Shift+Del your wallet details from the laptop. If possible, format it once.

6. Connect your laptop to the internet and send bitcoin to your address, whose details are in USB.

7. Just keep the USB detouched from all internet connections... and you are safe :)

By the way, is this 100% safe?


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: shorena on November 08, 2014, 02:55:58 PM
-snip-

1. Disconnect the laptop from internet.

2. Run Bitcoin-QT or some program to generate your address.

3. Send the wallet to an USB.

4. Remove the USB.

5. Ctrl+Shift+Del your wallet details from the laptop. If possible, format it once.

6. Connect your laptop to the internet and send bitcoin to your address, whose details are in USB.

7. Just keep the USB detouched from all internet connections... and you are safe :)

By the way, is this 100% safe?

Nope, an advanced trojan could be transmitted to the offline system via USB, snatch your private keys and call home when possible (e.g. using your online machine to broadcast the signed TX). So this might be compromised the moment you try to spend the bitcoins (e.g. connect the USB stick to an online machine). You also have a single point of failure (the USB stick) if it breaks your coins are gone.

On the other hand: nothing is 100% safe.



Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: KidPoker on November 08, 2014, 03:35:05 PM
-snip-

1. Disconnect the laptop from internet.

2. Run Bitcoin-QT or some program to generate your address.

3. Send the wallet to an USB.

4. Remove the USB.

5. Ctrl+Shift+Del your wallet details from the laptop. If possible, format it once.

6. Connect your laptop to the internet and send bitcoin to your address, whose details are in USB.

7. Just keep the USB detouched from all internet connections... and you are safe :)

By the way, is this 100% safe?

Nope, an advanced trojan could be transmitted to the offline system via USB, snatch your private keys and call home when possible (e.g. using your online machine to broadcast the signed TX). So this might be compromised the moment you try to spend the bitcoins (e.g. connect the USB stick to an online machine). You also have a single point of failure (the USB stick) if it breaks your coins are gone.

On the other hand: nothing is 100% safe.



So if your private keys are air gapped and if even using a usb to sign transactions isn't 100% safe, what is the alternative to signing transactions from an offline computer?


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: shorena on November 08, 2014, 04:18:27 PM
-snip-

So if your private keys are air gapped and if even using a usb to sign transactions isn't 100% safe, what is the alternative to signing transactions from an offline computer?

#1 QR Code, e.g. the bither app uses them
#2 sound [1]
#3 type the TX by hand, which is IMHO the safest way, unless your brain was hacked [3].  That level of security is almost never needed. On the other hand its not that hard unless you create a TX with 100 outputs/inputs. The nasty part would be the signed TX, which is just hex code and typos can happen easily.
#4 floppy [2]
#5 CD/DVD which is costly and has the similar problems USB has

Edit: In case this wasnt clear, I think for the majority of bitcoin users an USB stick is fine to transport data from cold to hot wallet. Not everyone needs/has a tinfoil hat.


[1] https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=735111.0
[2] https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=813295.0
[3] http://www.turnkeylinux.org/files/images/blog/i-know-kung-fu.jpg


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: KidPoker on November 08, 2014, 04:26:17 PM
-snip-

So if your private keys are air gapped and if even using a usb to sign transactions isn't 100% safe, what is the alternative to signing transactions from an offline computer?

#1 QR Code, e.g. the bither app uses them
#2 sound [1]
#3 type the TX by hand, which is IMHO the safest way, unless your brain was hacked [3].  That level of security is almost never needed. On the other hand its not that hard unless you create a TX with 100 outputs/inputs. The nasty part would be the signed TX, which is just hex code and typos can happen easily.
#4 floppy [2]
#5 CD/DVD which is costly and has the similar problems USB has

Edit: In case this wasnt clear, I think for the majority of bitcoin users an USB stick is fine to transport data from cold to hot wallet. Not everyone needs/has a tinfoil hat.


[1] https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=735111.0
[2] https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=813295.0
[3] http://www.turnkeylinux.org/files/images/blog/i-know-kung-fu.jpg

What a fantastic post. The sound option is fascinating to read about. Thanks a lot!


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: Dabs on November 08, 2014, 04:32:55 PM
Some malware have been known to cross or bridge the air gaps. But those are extreme.

To answer the question, I would probably nuke the old computer using DBAN (Darik's Boot and Nuke), with at least 1 full pass. Then I would create partitions or format it fresh.

I would not use a factory reset. I will just use a linux CD/DVD/ISO or even WinXP/7/8.1.

It's not ever going to connect to the internet right? So you don't need any other drivers. You don't even need the anti-virus stuff. The nice thing about ISO files is you can check the SHA256 or MD5 and know the installation media is clean. More or less.


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: KidPoker on November 08, 2014, 04:37:38 PM
Some malware have been known to cross or bridge the air gaps. But those are extreme.

To answer the question, I would probably nuke the old computer using DBAN (Darik's Boot and Nuke), with at least 1 full pass. Then I would create partitions or format it fresh.

I would not use a factory reset. I will just use a linux CD/DVD/ISO or even WinXP/7/8.1.

It's not ever going to connect to the internet right? So you don't need any other drivers. You don't even need the anti-virus stuff. The nice thing about ISO files is you can check the SHA256 or MD5 and know the installation media is clean. More or less.

Thanks for the DBAN tip and idea to just use a linux CD after verifying the sha256. That sounds like a much better idea. Yeah it's never going to connect to the net.


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: neurotypical on November 08, 2014, 05:03:35 PM
-snip-

1. Disconnect the laptop from internet.

2. Run Bitcoin-QT or some program to generate your address.

3. Send the wallet to an USB.

4. Remove the USB.

5. Ctrl+Shift+Del your wallet details from the laptop. If possible, format it once.

6. Connect your laptop to the internet and send bitcoin to your address, whose details are in USB.

7. Just keep the USB detouched from all internet connections... and you are safe :)

By the way, is this 100% safe?

Nope, an advanced trojan could be transmitted to the offline system via USB, snatch your private keys and call home when possible (e.g. using your online machine to broadcast the signed TX). So this might be compromised the moment you try to spend the bitcoins (e.g. connect the USB stick to an online machine). You also have a single point of failure (the USB stick) if it breaks your coins are gone.

On the other hand: nothing is 100% safe.



Thats extremely far fetched. What are the chances?

A laptop with wifi turned off (dont even need to remove the actual card for fuck sakes) will be safe unless you are someone like fucking Asagne or something.


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: KidPoker on November 08, 2014, 05:17:32 PM
Whats the best DBAN method to use? PRNG stream?


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: shorena on November 08, 2014, 05:39:09 PM
-snip-

Thats extremely far fetched. What are the chances?

A laptop with wifi turned off (dont even need to remove the actual card for fuck sakes) will be safe unless you are someone like fucking Asagne or something.

100% is extreme, yes.

Whats the best DBAN method to use? PRNG stream?

For a magnetical HDD it does not matter nowadays. The old 7 times "rule" was made for disks with a wider track. Thus you can overwrite the disk with any data, 0's, 1's, random bits, your favorite dog pictures.

Edit: you could test how good DBAN works with DEFT [1]


[1] http://www.deftlinux.net/


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: Dabs on November 09, 2014, 12:22:58 AM
I use DBAN with plain zeros. It's a little bit faster.

In fact, if my whole offline drive is full disk encrypted (with truecrypt or diskcryptor), I just use DBAN on Zeros, wait until it reaches 1%, and then stop it.

Then I do the partitions, format, install, etc.


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: KidPoker on November 09, 2014, 12:43:07 AM
Once I've installed the new ubuntu OS how in the world do I manage to install Armory without connecting to the internet. I've just spent the last 3 hours trying to figure this out again. It's driving me crazy. I don't understand why this isnt a widespread issue. Surely a lot of people use ubuntu for cold storage? Connecting to the net to install the package defeats the whole point of having never touched the net.


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: Dabs on November 09, 2014, 12:46:53 PM
Download the package or installation files first. Put it on USB. Verify the GPG signatures or SHA1/MD5 hashes.


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: KidPoker on November 09, 2014, 02:49:06 PM
Download the package or installation files first. Put it on USB. Verify the GPG signatures or SHA1/MD5 hashes.

I need to connect to the internet to download the package and installation files from ubuntu software centre. I've spent hours looking at alternative methods like using synaptic and stuff to get an online computer to download the packages for you and transfer them via usb but they all require to be installed on the offline computer first, thus defeating the point! :(


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: Dabs on November 09, 2014, 05:12:15 PM
Get it from here:
https://bitcoinarmory.com/download/


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: jjacob on November 10, 2014, 12:17:25 AM
I need to buy a new laptop anyway so I was wondering if I completely wipe my current laptop (It's a sony vaio) could I then use it as my cold storage laptop? I plan to make a large investment in bitcoins very soon and was wondering if factory resetting my current laptop would be sufficient in terms of security? Cheers.

Yes, but make sure that you don't connect it to the internet in the future.


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: Iuvenalis on November 10, 2014, 01:46:45 PM
disconnect from the internet, make a paper wallet and reinstall a new copy of windows.


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: Coef on November 11, 2014, 08:08:17 PM
On your laptop,  you can install a fresh copy of windows onto. With a copy replicated with an external hard drive on an offline computer . When  you restore this backup, you could still use the wallet.  ::)
disconnect from the internet, make a paper wallet and reinstall a new copy of windows.

Why would you use windows when you can use a much safer and open-source linux OS? :)


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: leen93 on November 11, 2014, 09:52:35 PM
u could just make a paper wallet? a bit easier  :D


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: FUR11 on November 11, 2014, 10:00:51 PM
It's important to wipe the hard disk and install a clean OS. If you want to be really safe, boot the computer by using a Linux live CD, create you wallet and write down the private key of your wallet by hand(!!!) Never connect the PC to the Internet while doing so, only after it has been shut down.


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: jinxx on November 11, 2014, 11:27:28 PM
just curious whats the purpose when you have paper wallets...


Title: Re: Can a factory reset computer be used for cold storage?
Post by: Dabs on November 12, 2014, 05:13:36 AM
just curious whats the purpose when you have paper wallets...
No one else can get the bitcoins stored on those paper wallets. That's one purpose.