Bitcoin Forum

Alternate cryptocurrencies => Altcoin Discussion => Topic started by: cat2 on March 19, 2015, 08:19:51 PM



Title: Is staking blackcoin or nxt worth it?
Post by: cat2 on March 19, 2015, 08:19:51 PM
I bought some blackcoin and started staking. The wallet keeps switching from I should get a reward in 2 or 3 days. It's been over a week and nothing. I don't get it. 1 percent isn't very impressive but I was wondering how it is or if it is compounded. Now I'm wondering if it exists at all. Can anybody explain how blackcoin staking pays out?

With nxt I leased my balance to a forging pool and the return so far is nxt to nothing. Anybody know how or if this 1 percent is compounded?

Do all pos coins payout only if your lucky? I don't get it.


Title: Re: Is staking blackcoin or nxt worth it?
Post by: coinpr0n on March 19, 2015, 08:30:07 PM
In my very limited experience staking proof-of-stake coins (NXT and Reddcoin) neither one of them provided any returns. You need large amounts to receive anything or it's not worth it IMO.


Title: Re: Is staking blackcoin or nxt worth it?
Post by: cat2 on March 19, 2015, 08:41:59 PM
How large a stake before returns are more likely? Is it random, luck? I just want to understand how these work. Thought trying it would be best and hate to just give up on it.


Title: Re: Is staking blackcoin or nxt worth it?
Post by: SBOSS on March 19, 2015, 09:18:11 PM
NEM's PoI is a fairer alternative to PoS, comes out in March.


Title: Re: Is staking blackcoin or nxt worth it?
Post by: illodin on March 19, 2015, 09:21:51 PM
The rewards are so small that it doesn't matter. If you don't have many coins you'll earn a dollar in a year or something. And if you have many coins then it doesn't matter if you get a few more anyway.

The only incentive to stake is to support the network.


Title: Re: Is staking blackcoin or nxt worth it?
Post by: d0om on March 19, 2015, 10:11:38 PM
Just trade the coins around smartly = 10x the profit of PoS.

Unless you gather many many weak coins early on in PoS and it's one of the 100s of cryptos that actually break out significantly.


Title: Re: Is staking blackcoin or nxt worth it?
Post by: Miracal on March 19, 2015, 11:27:07 PM
It is nxt forging calculator. Based on this calculator, 10000 nxt could yield 0.05 nxt in 24 hours!
https://www.mynxt.info/forging_calculator.php
But if you stake solely with a few thousand of nxt, you probably get nothing in 24 hours!


Title: Re: Is staking blackcoin or nxt worth it?
Post by: Hollowman338 on March 20, 2015, 12:17:23 AM
NEM's PoI is a fairer alternative to PoS, comes out in March.

12 days and change left for that.  Don't hold your breath.


Title: Re: Is staking blackcoin or nxt worth it?
Post by: coinpr0n on March 20, 2015, 12:31:00 AM
It is nxt forging calculator. Based on this calculator, 10000 nxt could yield 0.05 nxt in 24 hours!
https://www.mynxt.info/forging_calculator.php
But if you stake solely with a few thousand of nxt, you probably get nothing in 24 hours!

When I tried it out I was only forging with less than 100 NXT. Iniatially the ETA for forged coins was a few hours, quickly turned to days, then years so I turned it off.


Title: Re: Is staking blackcoin or nxt worth it?
Post by: speedy1987 on March 20, 2015, 04:30:57 AM
No it doesn´t worth it. It is only cents...


Title: Re: Is staking blackcoin or nxt worth it?
Post by: liquidiser on March 20, 2015, 11:40:45 AM
No it doesn´t worth it. It is only cents...

I found it's not worth it unless you own loads to start with.


Title: Re: Is staking blackcoin or nxt worth it?
Post by: Daedelus on March 20, 2015, 01:06:25 PM
No it doesn´t worth it. It is only cents...

I found it's not worth it unless you own loads to start with.

In Nxt, everyone gets about 0.5% a year over the long term. Even the whales only got ~$65 in an entire year of forging.


Forging was never designed to make you a millionaire, precisely to avoid the centralisation of bitcoin. A coin has to survive on its own merits and not because it continues to enrich a few (if you think $65 a year is enriching the few then maybe you should close the laptop and spend some time in the real world for a while).

Forging takes 2-3% of systems resources more than your computer just idling so you forge because you want the coins you hold to have value in the future. Mining mentalities need not apply.


Title: Re: Is staking blackcoin or nxt worth it?
Post by: shanem on March 20, 2015, 03:05:59 PM
Staking coins is not worth it.
You will use up more of your computer power and the amount of coins you get is very little.


Title: Re: Is staking blackcoin or nxt worth it?
Post by: autodiv on March 20, 2015, 03:06:25 PM
I bought some blackcoin and started staking. The wallet keeps switching from I should get a reward in 2 or 3 days. It's been over a week and nothing. I don't get it. 1 percent isn't very impressive but I was wondering how it is or if it is compounded. Now I'm wondering if it exists at all. Can anybody explain how blackcoin staking pays out?

With nxt I leased my balance to a forging pool and the return so far is nxt to nothing. Anybody know how or if this 1 percent is compounded?

Do all pos coins payout only if your lucky? I don't get it.

With NXT you are better off buying an Asset that pays dividends. The return will be much higher than staking.


Title: Re: Is staking blackcoin or nxt worth it?
Post by: Derek492 on March 20, 2015, 05:01:50 PM
Get some Mintcoin

You don't need a lot and the payout is higher.

I've minted from a balance of only 1000 coins before with mintcoin and it pays 15% APR currently.

With only 15 million coins (worth about 2 BTC), I'm minting about 187,000 MINT every month...seems to be worth it. And it compounds so u get more and more, as you mint more.

 :)

Here is a wallet example on YouTube http://youtu.be/g04yHPY6Xik


Title: Re: Is staking blackcoin or nxt worth it?
Post by: chennan on March 21, 2015, 03:34:23 AM
Get some Mintcoin

You don't need a lot and the payout is higher.

I've minted from a balance of only 1000 coins before with mintcoin and it pays 15% APR currently.

With only 15 million coins (worth about 2 BTC), I'm minting about 187,000 MINT every month...seems to be worth it. And it compounds so u get more and more, as you mint more.

 :)

Here is a wallet example on YouTube http://youtu.be/g04yHPY6Xik
Mintcoin have got a lot of potential. we hold Mintcoin in our wallet and earn up to 15% for this year, 10% the second and 5% Interest every year thereafter as a reward for securing the network.


Title: Re: Is staking blackcoin or nxt worth it?
Post by: Daedelus on March 21, 2015, 09:34:12 AM
Get some Mintcoin

You don't need a lot and the payout is higher.

I've minted from a balance of only 1000 coins before with mintcoin and it pays 15% APR currently.

With only 15 million coins (worth about 2 BTC), I'm minting about 187,000 MINT every month...seems to be worth it. And it compounds so u get more and more, as you mint more.

 :)

Here is a wallet example on YouTube http://youtu.be/g04yHPY6Xik
Mintcoin have got a lot of potential. we hold Mintcoin in our wallet and earn up to 15% for this year, 10% the second and 5% Interest every year thereafter as a reward for securing the network.

You aren't comparing like for like. The OP is interested low/no inflation cryptos. If you're happy with your stake being inflated away at 15% then why not 30% or 300%? The only thing that changes is the time it takes for you to become poor.


Title: Re: Is staking blackcoin or nxt worth it?
Post by: KevinMalone_ on August 07, 2018, 05:10:58 PM
Hey Guys. I found this guide for top altcoin staking. I think you should check it out.
http://topstaking.com/
http://topstaking.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/Blackcoin.png


Title: Re: Is staking blackcoin or nxt worth it?
Post by: dinoDevon on November 19, 2018, 10:53:34 PM
Found some good BLK information on https://topstaking.com/blk/