Bitcoin Forum

Bitcoin => Mining => Topic started by: papajo on October 10, 2013, 01:12:13 PM



Title: Nvidia GTX 650 Ti very low hashing rates why?
Post by: papajo on October 10, 2013, 01:12:13 PM
Hello I have a GTX 650 ti GPU and I manage to do only 45 Mh/s I have seen on charts online that a GTX 250 which is a much weaker cards puts out 80 Mh/s so why do I have so low hashing?


Also I have an old 9800 GX2   could I use them both for mining? should I set them up as different workers?


I also have a Dedicated PhysX card is it compatible with any mining software??


Last but not least I can not run mining under CUDA (with cudaminer for example) could anybody give me a little heads up about this? thnx


Title: Re: Nvidia GTX 650 Ti very low hashing rates why?
Post by: RaTTuS on October 10, 2013, 01:25:58 PM
NVidia are good for floating point calcs
ATi are good for Integer
Bitcoin uses integer
yoou would be much better off buying a couple of USB mining sticks than trying to get the GPU to earn anything IMO


Title: Re: Nvidia GTX 650 Ti very low hashing rates why?
Post by: Samir_H on October 10, 2013, 01:38:01 PM
@papajo if you want to mine first read what others use.
Nvidia is not good for this job, so don't waste electricity.


Title: Re: Nvidia GTX 650 Ti very low hashing rates why?
Post by: papajo on October 10, 2013, 02:44:42 PM
yes I know that ati is better than nvdia... its just that GTX 650 ti is a much newer and stronger card than gtx 250 so isnt it stranger to have lower Mh/s than the the GTX 250?


Title: Re: Nvidia GTX 650 Ti very low hashing rates why?
Post by: vpitcher07 on October 10, 2013, 04:08:04 PM
If you mine at that rate i doubt you'll get much more than a few cents a week at this difficulty and it'll only go down from here. If you want to make anything, buy a block erupter but don't expect to make your money back. I have 2 and make a little over a dollar a week with 24/7 mining....and that's at about 660 MH/s.


Title: Re: Nvidia GTX 650 Ti very low hashing rates why?
Post by: Samir_H on October 10, 2013, 05:01:10 PM
yes I know that ati is better than nvdia... its just that GTX 650 ti is a much newer and stronger card than gtx 250 so isnt it stranger to have lower Mh/s than the the GTX 250?

It's not strange because that cards have different architecture so they work differently on different tasks. GTX 600 is gaming series.


Title: Re: Nvidia GTX 650 Ti very low hashing rates why?
Post by: hulk on October 11, 2013, 10:42:09 AM
Cuda miner to increase the hash rate. But anyway dont use nvidia for mining as you are wasting ur electricity and spoiling your card.


Title: Re: Nvidia GTX 650 Ti very low hashing rates why?
Post by: papajo on October 12, 2013, 03:29:51 PM
Well I said that I dont know how to setup cudaminer everytime I tried it either couldnt connect to a pool (like slush) or if connected it didnt had any MH/s rate (I think I manage to connect it to BTC guild)

Also I know that Ati cards are faster.. but my question was different since my 650 TI is a faster model than the 4 year old GTX 250 in any case (Clocks,ram,shaders,pipelines,cores etc) why does it produce less MH/s than the 250... maybe the fault is somewere else....


Title: Re: Nvidia GTX 650 Ti very low hashing rates why?
Post by: kuusj98 on October 12, 2013, 06:32:31 PM
2xx is known for better hash rates, it is theyr architecture, done, nothing left to say.
nVidia is just plain bad for your card and for your utility bill my friend.

They are just optimsed in a other way, you can have a trillion shaders and shizzels but it aint gonna work...


Title: Re: Nvidia GTX 650 Ti very low hashing rates why?
Post by: papajo on October 12, 2013, 08:31:52 PM
Well no it doesnt how did you came up with that... see this too: https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Mining_hardware_comparison#Nvidia


again i am not telling that I should have big MH rate with my nvidia GTX 650 ti I know the rate will suck I just dont know why it sucks that much maybe I need to do some settings? or update something besides the GPU driver... the chart that I linkded does not have my card but it has its previous revision GTX 550ti which puts out more Mh/s than GTX 250 and a stronger card of the 6xx generation that does even better so I should be in the midle..


Title: Re: Nvidia GTX 650 Ti very low hashing rates why?
Post by: Wipeout2097 on October 13, 2013, 01:07:49 AM
It's probably because from the serie 5 onwards, Nvidia "focused on gaming", or in other words abandoned some instructions that are important for mining, or crippled the card.

This benchmark also shows a serie 5 card much faster than the 6:

http://media.bestofmicro.com/Y/M/386158/original/30-OpenCL-FAH-Implicit-Solvent-FP64.png


Title: Re: Nvidia GTX 650 Ti very low hashing rates why?
Post by: cowandtea on October 13, 2013, 01:39:52 AM
Hello I have a GTX 650 ti GPU and I manage to do only 45 Mh/s I have seen on charts online that a GTX 250 which is a much weaker cards puts out 80 Mh/s so why do I have so low hashing?


Also I have an old 9800 GX2   could I use them both for mining? should I set them up as different workers?


I also have a Dedicated PhysX card is it compatible with any mining software??


Last but not least I can not run mining under CUDA (with cudaminer for example) could anybody give me a little heads up about this? thnx

Don't do mining with Nivdia card, not cost efficiency and also you are spoiling your card. I advice selling it off and buying Sapphire 7950.


Title: Re: Nvidia GTX 650 Ti very low hashing rates why?
Post by: fattypig on October 13, 2013, 03:45:58 AM
Hello I have a GTX 650 ti GPU and I manage to do only 45 Mh/s I have seen on charts online that a GTX 250 which is a much weaker cards puts out 80 Mh/s so why do I have so low hashing?


Also I have an old 9800 GX2   could I use them both for mining? should I set them up as different workers?


I also have a Dedicated PhysX card is it compatible with any mining software??


Last but not least I can not run mining under CUDA (with cudaminer for example) could anybody give me a little heads up about this? thnx

Don't do mining with Nivdia card, not cost efficiency and also you are spoiling your card. I advice selling it off and buying Sapphire 7950.

This, just don't do anything funny with GTX 650 ti, you can still play games with it.