Bitcoin Forum

Economy => Speculation => Topic started by: bitcool on August 08, 2011, 01:05:16 AM



Title: What's wrong with this picture?
Post by: bitcool on August 08, 2011, 01:05:16 AM
US dollar is a mess, euro is a mess, the whole fiat world is a mess.
And yet bitcoin is in a continuous downward spiral?  Give me a break...


Title: Re: What's wrong with this picture?
Post by: vulgata on August 08, 2011, 01:11:05 AM
US dollar is a mess, euro is a mess, the whole fiat world is a mess.
And yet bitcoin is in a continuous downward spiral?  Give me a break...

It's completely unrelated; Bitcoin is still way too small, untested, and "unsafe" for normal people to use.  It's like asking why WOW gold isn't reacting to the recent financial crises.


Title: Re: What's wrong with this picture?
Post by: BillX on August 08, 2011, 01:13:23 AM
US dollar is a mess, euro is a mess, the whole fiat world is a mess.
And yet bitcoin is in a continuous downward spiral?  Give me a break...

It's completely unrelated; Bitcoin is still way too small, untested, and "unsafe" for normal people to use.  It's like asking why WOW gold isn't reacting to the recent financial crises.

Ill take Second Life Lindens any day over WoW gold! :P


Title: Re: What's wrong with this picture?
Post by: evoorhees on August 08, 2011, 01:15:13 AM
US dollar is a mess, euro is a mess, the whole fiat world is a mess.
And yet bitcoin is in a continuous downward spiral?  Give me a break...

It's completely unrelated; Bitcoin is still way too small, untested, and "unsafe" for normal people to use.  It's like asking why WOW gold isn't reacting to the recent financial crises.


+1  This is it exactly. Bitcoin is too niche and "wierd" for it to have much connection with the international market movements (yet).


Title: Re: What's wrong with this picture?
Post by: bitcool on August 08, 2011, 01:33:29 AM
US dollar is a mess, euro is a mess, the whole fiat world is a mess.
And yet bitcoin is in a continuous downward spiral?  Give me a break...

It's completely unrelated; Bitcoin is still way too small, untested, and "unsafe" for normal people to use.  It's like asking why WOW gold isn't reacting to the recent financial crises.
True, bitcoin is too small, young, and somewhat "untested", but there's no comparison between bitcoin and WOW gold.

Its valuation should follow the direction of physical gold and silver, not in the opposite direction.



Title: Re: What's wrong with this picture?
Post by: vulgata on August 08, 2011, 01:55:36 AM
US dollar is a mess, euro is a mess, the whole fiat world is a mess.
And yet bitcoin is in a continuous downward spiral?  Give me a break...

It's completely unrelated; Bitcoin is still way too small, untested, and "unsafe" for normal people to use.  It's like asking why WOW gold isn't reacting to the recent financial crises.
True, bitcoin is too small, young, and somewhat "untested", but there's no comparison between bitcoin and WOW gold.

Obviously they are completely different, but from the mainstream financial world's point of view there is no difference.  Actually, there is; Blizzard is a huge corporation that has time-tested servers running the world's largest MMORPG for years, while Bitcoin is an underground P2P network with a history of repeated thefts, security breaches, scams, black markets, illegal drugs, gambling, and crazy bubbles/speculation/market manipulation.

Its valuation should follow the direction of physical gold and silver, not in the opposite direction.

It "should" only if people treat it similarly, but while the ideas are similar, the trust placed in them by the market are not.  I could draw a piece of modern art by throwing paint on a piece of paper, and it would be impossible to recreate (since only the original is worth anything), rare, stored/transported relatively easy, etc., but I couldn't sell it for the billions a real masterpiece is worth until everyone else agrees.  Actually the art trade is very similar to precious metals/Bitcoin as they also have no value until people say they do.  (Yes, art can be used for decoration and gold can be used for electronics, but we have more than enough gold/art for those needs.)

Don't get me wrong, I am a full supporter of Bitcoins, I believe it is brilliant/revolutionary, and I own some myself, but I think we have to be a little more realistic and not start comparing it to the worlds' major reserve currencies right off the bat...