Title: Anyway to fix a radeon 5870 ? Post by: mores on July 16, 2012, 02:36:59 AM Yesterday I had an AMD/ATI radeon 5870 working just fine. ( never overclocked )
Today the computer will not complete POST. I have tried the card in 2 different systems: - Award BIOS postcode stops at 26 - AMI BIOS postcode stops at 2A The computer boots up with other video cards, just not the 5870. Is there anything I can try to get this card working again ? Title: Re: Anyway to fix a radeon 5870 ? Post by: squall1066 on July 16, 2012, 01:00:45 PM both codes point to ram!, strange but true.
asuming ami bios is pheonix then 2A - Initializes different devices through DIM. are they paired or are you clocking the memory? If another card works in this system then i'm stumped. Title: Re: Anyway to fix a radeon 5870 ? Post by: exotime on July 17, 2012, 05:48:27 PM Have you been overclocking? What were the temperatures like when mining? It looks like you've damaged one of the memory chips - in which case, there's probably not much you can do.
Title: Re: Anyway to fix a radeon 5870 ? Post by: mores on July 17, 2012, 11:41:34 PM The card is working again. I think this card has to "warm up" before it will complete the POST.
On a cold boot it stopped at 2A. Seeing that it was broken I just kept rebooting it and noticed the post code got a little farther than 2A. I waited some more to heat up, rebooted and it finally booted into the OS. ( Either that or the position of one of the PCI express power connectors was under a little pressure. ) I saw posts online of people baking their gpu in the oven to fix it. Before I went that far I was going to try a few other things. Now it is back to mining. Title: Re: Anyway to fix a radeon 5870 ? Post by: mores on July 18, 2012, 01:11:10 AM My GPU has been running at 85 degrees.
I wanted to mine at a safe level without any overclocking. So I followed the executive summary of: Single pool, dedicated miner: cgminer -o http://pool:port -u username -p password -I 9 That results in gpu running at 85 degrees. The readme said all the defaults should be safe values. I have now added --auto-fan so that the temp comes down to 75 degrees. What is a safe temperature to mine at ? Title: Re: Anyway to fix a radeon 5870 ? Post by: John (John K.) on July 18, 2012, 01:46:00 AM The lower the better. I usually run mine at 75, but that's just me.
Title: Re: Anyway to fix a radeon 5870 ? Post by: Portnoy on July 18, 2012, 03:54:47 PM The lower the better. I usually run mine at 75, but that's just me. Me too. Title: Re: Anyway to fix a radeon 5870 ? Post by: Sekioh on July 18, 2012, 04:06:53 PM I'm pissed, I just lost a card yesterday too.
Noticed I checked on my mining and had no shares submitted in like 20hrs, and go to restart the machine and couldn't remote, it was hard locked so I restarted it and it had like 5 rapid beeps and the GPU fan started at 100% throttle. Powered fully down and turned off PSU, turned all on, and it starts to windows (no monitor so software-wise) and I can log in remotely since VNC uses software rendering, but as soon as I try to start mining fan jumps up and computer hard locks. :| It was running 80-85 under normal conditions of full mining, I had fans set with a 85 ramp up as it approached up to 100% so that it kept that as a ceiling. I find it really interesting that it's letting it POST from a cold boot until put under load. A warm restart is the only time it doesn't post after an error locked it up. Title: Re: Anyway to fix a radeon 5870 ? Post by: grue on July 18, 2012, 04:31:18 PM I'm pissed, I just lost a card yesterday too. well there's your problemNoticed I checked on my mining and had no shares submitted in like 20hrs, and go to restart the machine and couldn't remote, it was hard locked so I restarted it and it had like 5 rapid beeps and the GPU fan started at 100% throttle. Powered fully down and turned off PSU, turned all on, and it starts to windows (no monitor so software-wise) and I can log in remotely since VNC uses software rendering, but as soon as I try to start mining fan jumps up and computer hard locks. :| It was running 80-85 under normal conditions of full mining, I had fans set with a 85 ramp up as it approached up to 100% so that it kept that as a ceiling. I find it really interesting that it's letting it POST from a cold boot until put under load. A warm restart is the only time it doesn't post after an error locked it up. Title: Re: Anyway to fix a radeon 5870 ? Post by: mores on July 18, 2012, 04:36:19 PM Perhaps the default settings in the miners should have a lower temperature to run the hardware safely. ( 75 sounds like the recommended temp )
Then only allow the overclockers to run it hotter. How long had you been running the card from 80-85 ? Title: Re: Anyway to fix a radeon 5870 ? Post by: Portnoy on July 18, 2012, 07:36:15 PM Perhaps the default settings in the miners should have a lower temperature to run the hardware safely. ( 75 sounds like the recommended temp ) Then only allow the overclockers to run it hotter. You can overclock a 5870 and still keep it at 75 or lower. I use MSI Afterburner (http://event.msi.com/vga/afterburner/download.htm). Title: Re: Anyway to fix a radeon 5870 ? Post by: mores on July 18, 2012, 09:43:17 PM From the cgminer docs:
Quote EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ON USAGE: Single pool, dedicated miner: cgminer -o http://pool:port -u username -p password -I 9 That maintains an 85 degree gpu. All I am saying is that when that exact command is issued it should keep the gpu at 75 degrees. Title: Re: Anyway to fix a radeon 5870 ? Post by: mores on July 19, 2012, 10:05:46 PM The card worked for about 24 hours and now it stopped again.
I see people are selling GPUs as parts or repair.... how much is a 5870 worth when sold as parts/repair ? Title: Re: Anyway to fix a radeon 5870 ? Post by: on9isrock on July 20, 2012, 07:30:49 AM you can go to electronics shops/services to change the gpu part
Title: Re: Anyway to fix a radeon 5870 ? Post by: mores on July 21, 2012, 11:46:39 AM I guess they do have some value. Here is a non-working one currently bidding about $50 http://www.ebay.com/itm/HIS-ATI-Radeon-HD-5870-AS-IS-non-working-/221075979574 (http://www.ebay.com/itm/HIS-ATI-Radeon-HD-5870-AS-IS-non-working-/221075979574)
|