why is this such a big deal?
blocks are still going to be mined at the same rate right?
even if the block limit is not increased the number of tx on the network will still be the same, so bandwidth required to run a full node will be pretty much the same...
no?
wouldn't miners like to mine a bigger block ( more tx pre block = more fees! )
wouldn't an end user like to have his tx included in the next block ( more tx pre block = for sure your tx will be in the next block )
I could get on board with something tied to the number of transactions paying at least the minimum fee.
If the amount of fee paying transactions rises, the block size is increased on the next adjustment. If the fee paying transactions drop, block size is reduced on the next adjustment.
Basically, we need a way to keep the segment allotted to free transactions to stay roughly the same size, but allow the size to grow and shrink with the paying transaction rate. Free transactions could still take up extra space if there weren't paying transactions, but they wouldn't reserve the space past the adjustment.
we do not have to care about the tx fees...
as it stands today, if miners dont want to process a tx because it has no fee they are free to do so.
keep it that way, its fine... its better then fine its perfect!
if the size of the block is so small that miner will only include tx with fees because he cant fit them all and would rather include the ones that pay a fee! the miner no longer has the choice to include a tx with no fee ( i guess he dose but he'd be crazy too do so -_-)
this is simply unacceptable, it will lead to high fees, and because of the high fees hashrate will go up for no reason at all...
make the max block size
really really big so this never happens!
and let the miners decide for themselves if they want to include free-tx's, just because he has the space doesn't force him to add the free-tx....this way miners of the future ( when the block reward is 0 ) will be mining for fees and he will choose his own cut off, maybe one minner will only include a tx with 0.00005BTC. The users will know if you pay 0.001BTC ALL miners will jump at the opportunity to add your tx, but
if you only pay 0.000005BTC only 50% of the miners will add your tx ( which means it will take longer to confirm )
if the block size limit is to small, what will happen is the
users will start compete for a spot on the block by paying higher and higher fees, NOT GOOD! this will for surely lead to super high fees!