If all of these solutions are 'stopgap' then what would you suggest, oh wise one?
Thank you. You may get up now.
Not being able to have a large flashy signature doesn't impair someone's freedom of speech.
The very fact that Theymos opens this thread to hear ideas about how to influence what visitors say means that he does not want to let everyone totally free in their linguistic expression. I support restriction of expression. But I suggest that it must be based upon clear principles and visions, which seem to be lacking.
Because the two systems are completely separate and irrelevant to each other. Forum moderaters and DT members are not the same, and therefore one has no need to follow the guidelines of the other. It's shocking that someone questioning principle and free speech cannot grasp this extremely simple concept.
By the rules, scamming is allowed on this forum. Do you suggest that we stop tagging scammers, just because the forum rules (which aren't even official) don't explicitly say it's wrong? If that's the case, why bother even having a trust system? Are you starting to understand how silly and misinformed your argument is yet?
You summerize it well. Thank you. Stopping with tagging presupposed scammers because the forum rules don't say it's wrong is exactly what I am suggesting. I am suggesting that punishment must be rooted in clear principles and not in the subjective whims of a couple of moderators who also abuse the trust system for their own agenda. Don't you see? In the current situation we have punishment without rules. Either you install clear forum rules and punish objectively according to these rules or you install everyone with the power to punish so innocent victims of guilty moderators can defend themselves against them. Or you simply take away that power from everyone. If you leave the situation as it is you do not run the forum from principles, unless some kind of oligarchy (power to a few, subjectively utilized by a few) is the principle on which you want to base your forum structure. We have an animal farm here where all members are equal but some members are more equal. Of course the more equal ones want to keep it like that, and they're lurking for even more difference.