Maybe I am missing something here, but wasn't initial bounty pool 1,000,000 BIRB and not 300,000?, like @speedforce claims?


While it's true that they reserved the right to adjust bounty pool, don't you think its a little bit too drastic, to lower it from 1 million/300k ~5k? If we take that 300k number, that's like 98% decrease. I am fully aware of the fact that majority of work done by bounty hunters is subpar, but that's an overkill and BIRB team has an obvious intention to scam bounty hunters, which in the end they did.

Evo ekipa, manager onog Mintlayera je promjenio uvjete tako da se sada prihvacaju i posteri iz naseg dijela tako da @slackovic i @btcltcdigger, prijavite se.

Yep, that's my experience as well when it comes to other forums. Younger generations simply prefer faster means of communications and I don't think that much can be done to change that.


Finally I was faster than you, but looking forward to your overview. As a matter of fact, I checked yesterday have you done it already.


Be my guest

Da, dosta je riskantno napustati Roobet, prvenstveno zbog povoljnih pravila kampanje, ali eno kazu da ce mozda i produziti. Ostavio sam tamo pitanje manageru zasto je uvrstio neke mrtve boardove a ne neke aktivne kao nas pa ko zna, mozda promjeni misljenje i doda i nas board  sto bi bio jos jedan dobar razlog da se neki nasi koji su bez kampanja kao @Slackovic prijave.

Opet, tko ne riskira ne profitira. Ja sam tako riskirao i napustio Bustadice koja je tada bila jedna od najdugotrajnijih i najboljih kampanja i prebacio se u BestChange. Prosla je skoro godina i pol, BC i dalje ide a Bustadice je stao, tako da nikad neznas.




Koliko sam skuzio, poolovi su way to go za ulaganje u altove. Dobijes private sale cijenu i onda dumpas na ove koji su kupili po public cijeni.

I don't know if you are aware of the current situation in local boards, but Chinese and Japanese (that will be counted towards signature quota) are practically dead boards for quite some time, while some that are not included like Portuguese, Filipino and Croatian are consistently among the most active ones. You might wanna take a look at Brief monthly overview of the local boards activity to see the situation in the last ~year and a half.

Maybe I misunderstood your post, but I don't think that @RiniAr is their alt account, as that one is just copy/pasting other people's work. His "post history" (if we consider bounty spam as posts ) is full of that, like this for example. I guess he can be reported for plagiarism as well.

Yeah, its a strange coincidence and this is the first month I started using ninjastic.space for all boards. It started last month with Russian board as it was consistently in the negative (therefore missing  from some of the charts) because their mods kept deleting/moving old posts and topics, so I just expanded it from now on to other boards.

Nothing wrong with using Merit Dashboard for post count as well, especially if your board is clean and without spam like for example mine (Croatian) is, so numbers on ninjastic.space and Merit Dashboard are usually pretty similar.


I see that there were some comments on your overview so I wouldn't say that there is no interest at all. But as long as you like making them, who cares .

Sudeci po izboru lokalnih boardova u kojima se broje postovi, nekako mislim da im manager bas i nije obavjesten o stvarnoj situaciji na forumu. Naime, broje se postovi u Japanskim i Kineskim  boardovima koji su mrtvi godinama, dok je recimo jedan Portugalski izostavljen, iako je jedan od najaktivnijih.



A sigurno da ove dugorocne kampanje dobiju vise nego sto uloze, nisu valjda ludi da bacaju novce u vjetar mjesecima/godinama.

Despite me trying to be on time, I am again a little bit late with the monthly overview, albeit not as late as the previous one, so that's positive. All charts and tables are made thanks to @DdmrDdmr Merit Dashboard and @TryNinja Ninjastic.space.

Reminder: Communities marked with * don't have their own local boards.

---

Post activity per local board during September 2021

Since I started using ninjastic.space for Russian local board, I decided to start using it for all other local boards as it wouldn't make much sense to only use it for one board. Due that, all numbers will be slightly higher as ninjastic.space cunts deleted post.

Regarding the post count, its somewhat similar to 8/2021, with Russian board on top, followed by Turkish and German (whose numbers are constantly decreasing for months now), with Italian and Portuguese closing the top 5. Regarding the languages without local board, Nigerian and Pakistan looks consistently strong; hopefully they can keep up those numbers as that's the only way to get their own local board.

---

Merit shared per local board during September 2021

Compared to August, September was slightly better month merit wise, with 6956 merit shared (August having 6850). No changes at the top; Russian board is far ahead the others with 2496 merits shared (decrease from August and 2850), followed by Turkish which is on the rise, and Italian at the 3rd spot. Like with posts, Germsan board keeps going down, as now 4th most merited board while it used to be 2nd for the majotity of these overviews.

By far the biggest "looser" is Pilipinas board with only 19 merits shared, which is very low number for board with that kind of activity (531 posts written). I have no idea what's going on there, but maybe it's time for some of their members to apply for a merit source spot.

---

Merit senders and receivers per local board during September 2021

Everything is pretty obvious here, with some boards sticking out as always, like Pilipinas that had decent amount of members invloved in merit shared despite very low numbers. Same thing can be said about German, but on a much higher scale of course.

---

Merit/Post ratio per local board for September 2021

Last but not the least in this series of charts, merit/post ratio. Like in the previous month, it's nice to see that blue chart keeps dominating which will hopefully continue in the months to come.

---

The most active members per local board during September 2021

And in the end, list of the most active members per local board.

Russian	|	German	|	Turkish	|	Italian	|	Portuguese	|	French	|
_________________	|	_________________	|	_________________	|	_________________	|	_________________	|	_________________	|
D-oN_ [292]	|	mole0815 [128]	|	RaltcoinsB [267]	|	Prova123 [154]	|	joker_josue [161]	|	Saint-loup [55]	|
The0ldl_lser [165]	|	bct_ail [119]	|	MK-74 [265]	|	fillippone [143]	|	TryNinja [117]	|	elma [45]	|
Ratimov [160]	|	-doubleU- [99]	|	trendcoin [263]	|	bitbollo [116]	|	bitmover [111]	|	Danydee [44]	|
klarki [136]	|	cygan [88]	|	ZekiBeyy [255]	|	Paolo.Demidov [107]	|	Disruptivas [86]	|	Melja [37]	|
safar1980 [122]	|	Unknown01 [76]	|	Dolorex [253]	|	babo [107]	|	sabotag3x [83]	|	guigui371 [33]	|
AlexLvov [114]	|	Lakai01 [69]	|	verbakalim [226]	|	jack0m [83]	|	alegotardo [73]	|	perl [33]	|
Julien_Olynpic [104]	|	sam00 [68]	|	meser# [223]	|	duesoldi [71]	|	rdluffy [71]	|	LeGaulois [32]	|
delfastTions [92]	|	hanspeter77 [67]	|	1kodumtek7 [204]	|	Plutosky [64]	|	Lucasgabd [63]	|	Booster1888 [23]	|
Smartprofit [85]	|	Soonandwaite [65]	|	coderben [204]	|	gbianchi [50]	|	gagux123 [45]	|	Halab [20]	|
Bohdan820 [84]	|	Buchi-88 [61]	|	Distraction [203]	|	alexrossi [45]	|	tg88 [34]	|	patrickus [20]	|

Spanish	|	Indonesian	|	Pilipinas	|	Croatian	|	Polish	|	Arabic	|
_________________	|	_________________	|	_________________	|	_________________	|	_________________	|	_________________	|
DdmrDdmr [125]	|	Husna QA [80]	|	blockman [44]	|	slackovic [84]	|	Tytanowy Janusz [20]	|	khaled0111 [43]	|
famososMuertos [73]	|	DroomieChikito [57]	|	mirakal [38]	|	Daniel91 [54]	|	cygan [12]	|	Kavelj22 [38]	|
LUCKMCFLY [50]	|	abhiseshakana [56]	|	peter0425 [27]	|	casperBGD [47]	|	wwzsocki [6]	|	bert1587 [21]	|
Hispo [33]	|	joniboini [51]	|	pilosopotasyo [25]	|	Trofo [44]	|	lokas0506 [5]	|	Coinoplex [16]	|
Artemis3 [31]	|	masulum [42]	|	Eureka_07 [24]	|	FatFork [36]	|	malevolent [4]	|	yhiaali3 [16]	|
PlayBetr [24]	|	MAAManda [41]	|	Peanutswar [24]	|	dkbit98 [33]	|	Rath_ [3]	|	OmegaStarScream [13]	|
d5000 [21]	|	budiwicaksono [40]	|	arwin100 [22]	|	btcltcdigger [29]	|	Flangler [2]	|	Aldeen [9]	|
Silberman [20]	|	blue Snow [37]	|	bisdak40 [19]	|	badger27 [26]	|	Mojon [2]	|	mikeywith [9]	|
MA40 [14]	|	roycilik [35]	|	finaleshot2016 [18]	|	Stalker22 [22]	|	Saniksin [2]	|	malfid- [7]	|
Porfirii [11]	|	mu_enrico [29]	|	Maus0728 [14]	|	cryptofrka [20]	|	andrew99 [2]	|	thugCrypto [5]	|

Romanian	|	Indian	|	Greek	|	Pakistan*	|	Nigerian*	|	Bangladesh*	|
_________________	|	_________________	|	_________________	|	_________________	|	_________________	|	_________________	|
NeuroticFish [24]	|	pakhitheboss [19]	|	chek2fire [10]	|	Sayeds56 [41]	|	Charles-Tim [72]	|	Little Mouse [13]	|
20kevin20 [23]	|	Manish2809 [15]	|	Bisonas [4]	|	UmerIdrees [23]	|	igehhh [30]	|	israt1@ [8]	|
GazetaBitcoin [23]	|	amishmanish [12]	|	BlackHatCoiner [4]	|	5thFear [16]	|	Nathrixxx [22]	|	Cornia [7]	|
geordan173 [17]	|	teosanru [9]	|	TzikakioS [2]	|	GbitG [13]	|	CryptopreneurBrainboss [21]	|	Jontokhan65 [7]	|
Skorillo [15]	|	pawanjain [8]	|	BbisbosS [1]	|	techearn17 [13]	|	Mpamaegbu [21]	|	tokyohd [7]	|
Rizzrack [9]	|	UKprod [6]	|	Fcoiner [1]	|	shahzadafzal [12]	|	BIT-BENDER [13]	|	wtsimis [6]	|
CarPatin [7]	|	libert19 [5]	|	bmxakias [1]	|	Imranbutt44 [11]	|	Issa56 [13]	|	EYC_ONE [4]	|
jedaite [5]	|	ANKIT007 [4]	|	cryptosize [1]	|	CryptoYar [4]	|	Smartvirus [8]	|	Nafisa78 [3]	|
im0rtel [3]	|	Lordshiva [4]	|	dimitris_shenzhen [1]	|	Shaheer Arshad [3]	|	Dragonfund [7]	|	Review Master [3]	|
hikmetsonmez [2]	|	avikz [4]	|	hikmetsonmez [1]	|	Ronzybloch [2]	|	Gozie51 [7]	|	sykt62 [3]	|

Pa ne bi ni ja ulozio u te altcoine koje on promovira, (uostalom niti nisam), u tome i je stvar, mi im nismo target audience. I slazem se da svaka roba nadje svog kupca, samo po dosadasnjem iskustvu mislim da nema previse altcoin kupaca ovdje, te mi zato altcoin kampanje na forumu nemaju smisla. Al eto, sretno im sa kampanjom, i onima koji odluce prijaviti se.

Stvar je u target audience. Mozda grijesim, ali mislim da vecina aktivne ekipe ovdje nije veliki fan altcoina, tj niti ulaze u te rane sale faze, a i ako kupi to je vjerojatno tek nakon listanja. Eto sad smo ti i ja culi za njih, ali da li bi ulozio u to? Ja znam da nebi, i jedini altcoin koji trenutno imam i u kojeg vjerujem dugorocno je ETH. Reklamirati altcoine ovdje mi se cini kao reklamirati svinjske proizvode na nekom islamskom portalu

Bas me zanima tko bi iz naseg lokala uopce bio spreman ubaciti recimo 500 USD u taj njihov sale, te da li ekipa uopce ulaze u IDO/ICO/IEO ili kako se vec zove nakon sto su vidjeli neku reklamu ovdje. Mislim u zadnje vrijeme.

Jedan od najboljih frendova je do nedavno radio za top kripto marketinsku firmu. Kad sam ga pitao zasto vise uopce ne oglasavaju svoje projekte na bitcointalk forumu iako rade isljucivo na legit projektima a ne na nekim pump and dump shitcoinima, rekao mi je da su nakon nekog vremena dosli do zakljucka da je oglasavanje altcoin projekata ovdje totalno neefikasno jer oni koji imaju love i koji ulazu u altcoine (misleci pritom na vece cifre a ne na 100-200 usd) ne da nisu aktivni ovdje, nego nisu nikad ni napravili acc na btctalku.

Isto tako, prilično sam siguran da ni ono thread bumpanje nema smisla i ne donosi nikakve rezultate , pa je altcoin sekcija puna i te gluposti, projekti i dalje bacaju lovu na to jer ih netko nagovori da im baš to treba da se istaknu u moru smeća.

E sad, posto tog covjeka znam 30+ godina, nekako sumnjam da bi mi lagao o takvim stvarima a covjeku je to doslovno posao. Uostalom, pogledaj i sam kakav status imaju altcoini ovdje, svi se toliko razbacuju sa rijecju shitcoin da je totalno izgubila prvobitno znacenje.

Ma znam, kao i one blesave bounty kampanje gdje nepismena ekipa koja ne zna sastaviti recenicu pise clanke, i bezumno shera tweetove, ono reach 0. Ali eto, ti bounty manageri ih nekako uvjere da ce im bas to dovuci investore.  


Slazem se, neke kampanje definitivno imaju smisla kao kasina ili bitcoin mixeri, ali za altcoin kampanje sam sto posto uvjeren da je cisto bacanje novaca na ovom forumu. Top altcoin projekti vise ne jebu btctalk ni 3 posto, sto i ne cudi s obzirom na onaj kaos u altcoin sekciji.

I guess not, hence neutral feedback for those small loans makes sense, but that doesn't mean some won't try to do that. There are smart scammers around that are willing to play long game, not all are imbeciles.

Tko god ih je savjetovao da se kao altcoin projekt oglasavaju na bitcointalk forumu, fino ih je zajebao jer to imho cisto bacanje novaca uzimajuci u obzir status koji altcoini imaju na ovom forumu. Mogli su puno bolje potrositi tih 20k+ USD, koliko ce ih kostati 4 tjedna kampanje.

Another way to see neutral feedback is as sort of "protection" against trust farm. I am sure that scammers would gladly take few hundreds of dollars loan in exchange for a positive feedback from well respected lenders so I am not surprised that they tend to give neutral instead positive feedback.

Call me paranoid, but to me bunch of those little loans look more like a trust farm attempts rather than a real need.

What he meant is that while he knows that price will eventually dump, it keeps going up while he is waiting, so he is not sure whether to wait a little bit more, or sell the rest.

---

@OP with the evidence provided by @Jawhead999, I think its pretty much clear what you should do, and that means sell remaining tokens. Don't be greedy and simply take the profit. What you could eventually do is to keep small portion as a moon bag, if you really want to see how much up can it go, but looking at the chart, dump is bound to happen any day now.

Ma kakvi, ne ocekujem  nikakve velike prelaze iz jacih kampanja, pa cak ni iz onih koje placaju duplo manje kao Roobet. Koliko vidim, vecina prijavljenih je amelj iz altcoina kampanja, uz tek pokojeg solidnog postera. Mislim da bi kvalitetniji clanovi poceli prelaziti tek ako bi kampanja potrajala par mjeseci, kao sto je bio slucaj sa BestChange kampanjom.

It's simple really; if token is not listed on Binance, you can't send it there, and the fact that they are on Binance Smart Chain doesn't change anything. By the way, centralized exchange as Binance is one of the worst places where you could keep your tokens. Remember, not your keys not your coins.

Which proves what I said before, that majority of them are  well aware of the fact that they wouldn't be able to join any other campaign so they accept that kind of behavior.

In one of previous posts @yahoo62278 said it is matter of respect, but I would say that it's a matter of self-respect here; majority of people in those campaigns obviously don't have any when it comes to this, if they are willing to be treated like that.


Based on this, he obviously doesn't give a fuck.



While both of those campaigns had some quality members (they probably still do) they didn't produce anything as there is no incentive inside the campaign to write better (as far as I know). No bonuses for best posters, promotion is on first come first serve basis etc. People got out of there (myself included) because they preferred quality writing instead of filling up max quota and making more money in the short term.