I'll assume you're directly your comment toward Matthew with UABB and not the OP (me, Phinnaeus Gage, Bruno, or whatever my name is this week).
I just read the post you provided:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=33478.msg418895#msg418895 Maybe hypercritical, maybe not. Either way, the advise he provided sounded sound to me. Spearheading donations could of been a no-no. I missed that post. No need to provide it for I'll take your word on it that he did unless shown otherwise. A slower adaptation could have been a wiser choice.
I want to thank you too, kookiekrak for your comments and insight.
Here's him asking for donations to fund the investigation:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=26224.msg421382#msg421382Just in case you guys didn't already read it, it seemed pertinent to add it here as well.
The UABB is spearheading a legal and unbiased investigation into MyBitcoin.com but needs your support. Discussion about MyBitcoin.com is very healthy for the sharing of ideas and suggestions on how to tackle this very serious and difficult problem, but
nothing will be done about it through forum posts.
Please start contributing to the actual investigation by adding your affidavit, attaching evidence of funds lost, and
contributing to the fund to pay for international investigators. Thank you.
http://uabci.org/redmine/projects/mbci[/size]
Here's him backtracking and claiming that they don't ask for donations:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=33761.msg423776#msg423776
The UABB is a not-for-profit organization to promote safe, honest and secure transactions between consumers and merchants, provide a proper method of consumer complaints, as well as optional escrow and dispute resolution services.
The investigationattempt to gather information to help lead to an investigation by the UABB does not require, ask for, nor allow donations at this point and will hopefully never need to. It is merely a campaign to find the truth of the MyBitcoin situation. Ordinarily it is not in the boundaries of the UABB to do such a thing unless MyBitcoin had been an accredited member. It is being treated as a special case due to the high public interest and the relevance to both consumers and business owners across the Bitcoin community.
It is already a failing attempt however, as the previously vocal victims of MyBitcoin have signed up to participate in the project, but have provided absolutely no data of any kind to date. If things move on in this direction much longer, the UABB will cancel its efforts and let the community once again handle it in its own unorganized way.
Matthew N. Wright
Heres where he claims that they'll never request donations unless needed because they can pay expenses on their own. Except he solicited donations earlier without any expenses yet...
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=26224.msg423078#msg423078
Not a lawyer. Participating in this purely for personal curiosity. I work with the Korean government in academic fraud investigations primarily, but do not bring that to the table. I am a CS major who has owned an international college prep school in South Korea for over 3 years. I am involved in Bitcoin because it is a reasonable choice for a hobby for the next 10 years. I am not a politician nor am I lawyer, but we will be hiring one when the time comes. Discussions can be done on the forums of course, but resource gathering for investigations can be hard to organize and gets easily cluttered if left to forums only, thus a project management section has been created for the specific purpose.
I do not give guarantees and therefor need no guarantors. Although it appears that I am asking for donations, that was just a very small side note and in other forums (as well as at the link given) I have attempted to make it very clear that donations will never be asked for unless the occasion specifically calls for it, and we are unable to handle the expenses on our own (the UABB that is).
mybad for the quote spam.