When I click "notify" on a thread, I get a javascript popup asking me to confirm, I choose OK, the page reloads but notify is not enabled for that thread. This is true on both the page itself (link still says notify) and on my subscriptions page (doesn't list any subscriptions).
I haven't received an email to validate my email address yet, and I can't see any way to request that. Do I need to do that before I can subscribe to email notifications? Will it be sent automatically at some point in the next few hours maybe?
The link never text changes, it's always "Notify" even if notify is already enabled.
What's the text of the popup the second time you click on it?
Second, there's no email to confirm your email, the forum doesn't do that.
Finally are you using hotmail? I think emails are not arriving there.