I love the amount of 'insight' in this set of posts, the basic fact is - if 42 only had 42 coins total, people would dump it all to BTC and stop mining it. Community? Get real.. New coin arrives, people mine/buy and sell, rinse and repeat - don't keep spewing fiction.
It wasn't a miscalculation of total coin-base - the dev just didn't have any conditions set for when supply exceeded 42.
Lets look at
https://github.com/fourtytwo42/42/blob/master/src/main.cpp:
862: if(nHeight == 4242424)
863: {
864: nSubsidy = 0.00042 * COIN;
865: }
866: if(nHeight >= 990382)
867: {
868: nSubsidy = 0.00;
869: }
870: return nSubsidy + nFees
Lines 866-869 were only added 5 months ago; so mining would only receive the fees (tiny) hence making it worthless. Cryptsy has decided to ignore the new code (because they do what they like basically) - so 42 will most likely go on forever.
Least the dev has a sense of humour:
846: if(nHeight == 420) // yay its 420
Time for a smoke
847: {
848: nSubsidy = 0.00042 * COIN;
849: }
Basically, put this behind you - keep trading all your scrypt to BTC like everyone else, and dont read into the hype.