Watchlist - Wrong sorting

[micaman]

If you check your Watchlist, all the sorting options on the table header have "unreadreplies" instead of "watchlist" on the url, "redirecting" you out of the "watchlist" into the "Unread Replies / Updated Topics" section.

Manually inserting "watchlist" as the action parameter makes it work correctly, so I think this could easily be fixed.

[1715675757]

1715675757

[1715675757]

1715675757

[1715675757]

1715675757

[1715675757]

1715675757

[mexxer-2]

Lost you there for a minute, but I get it now. Seems so, I'd inform about this to the admins though, but well seeing as the new forum might be coming in a few months, and that (lets be honest) no one uses Watch-list, I'd not be sure that it will be fixed anytime soon

[shorena]

Lost you there for a minute, but I get it now. Seems so, I'd inform about this to the admins though, but well seeing as the new forum might be coming in a few months, and that (lets be honest) no one uses Watch-list, I'd not be sure that it will be fixed anytime soon

How do you follow anything here without a watchlist? No one uses it, preposterous!

[mexxer-2]

Lost you there for a minute, but I get it now. Seems so, I'd inform about this to the admins though, but well seeing as the new forum might be coming in a few months, and that (lets be honest) no one uses Watch-list, I'd not be sure that it will be fixed anytime soon

How do you follow anything here without a watchlist? No one uses it, preposterous!

I never miss a thread/post because of "Show unread posts since last visit. " , I am omnipresent(in this context, always online)
Seriously though, there's the Bitcointalk script and "Show new replies to your posts." that majority use.

[shorena]

Lost you there for a minute, but I get it now. Seems so, I'd inform about this to the admins though, but well seeing as the new forum might be coming in a few months, and that (lets be honest) no one uses Watch-list, I'd not be sure that it will be fixed anytime soon

How do you follow anything here without a watchlist? No one uses it, preposterous!

I never miss a thread/post because of "Show unread posts since last visit. " , I am omnipresent(in this context, always online)
Seriously though, there's the Bitcointalk script and "Show new replies to your posts." that majority use.

Thats >500 posts for me, my watchlist is only ~50. I never sort it though so I never had the issue micaman has.

It looks like its working though if the link is manually replaced.

By subject: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=watchlist;start=0;sort=subject
By starter: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=watchlist;start=0;sort=starter
By replies: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=watchlist;start=0;sort=replies
By views: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=watchlist;start=0;sort=views
By last post: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=watchlist;start=0;sort=last_post

Descending order:

By subject: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=watchlist;start=0;sort=subject;desc
By starter: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=watchlist;start=0;sort=starter;desc
By replies: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=watchlist;start=0;sort=replies;desc
By views: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=watchlist;start=0;sort=views;desc
By last post: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=watchlist;start=0;sort=last_post;desc

[micaman]

Lost you there for a minute, but I get it now. Seems so, I'd inform about this to the admins though, but well seeing as the new forum might be coming in a few months, and that (lets be honest) no one uses Watch-list, I'd not be sure that it will be fixed anytime soon

How do you follow anything here without a watchlist? No one uses it, preposterous!

I never miss a thread/post because of "Show unread posts since last visit. " , I am omnipresent(in this context, always online)
Seriously though, there's the Bitcointalk script and "Show new replies to your posts." that majority use.

Thats >500 posts for me, my watchlist is only ~50. I never sort it though so I never had the issue micaman has.

It looks like its working though if the link is manually replaced.

By subject: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=watchlist;start=0;sort=subject
By starter: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=watchlist;start=0;sort=starter
By replies: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=watchlist;start=0;sort=replies
By views: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=watchlist;start=0;sort=views
By last post: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=watchlist;start=0;sort=last_post

Descending order:

By subject: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=watchlist;start=0;sort=subject;desc
By starter: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=watchlist;start=0;sort=starter;desc
By replies: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=watchlist;start=0;sort=replies;desc
By views: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=watchlist;start=0;sort=views;desc
By last post: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=watchlist;start=0;sort=last_post;desc

Exactly!
"Show unread posts since last visit. " returns too many posts, including a lot of "garbage" posts.
"Show new replies to your posts." is useful, but too few posts for me as I don't post that much.
"Watchlist" is what I usually go to, it's perfect for me...

It was the first time I used those filters, I recognize they might not be very useful or even used by anyone, but that doesn't mean they shouldn't work as intended.

Thanks for the feedback.

[mexxer-2]

Manually inserting "watchlist" as the action parameter makes it work correctly, so I think this could easily be fixed.

-links-

Thats what he said^[1]


#Offtopic: Reference to another type of joke
And damn your writing style is contagious

[theymos]

Hm, I can't believe it took until now for someone to notice that bug. Fixed.

[mexxer-2]

I'd not be sure that it will be fixed anytime soon

Seems I was wrong then

Hm, I can't believe it took until now for someone to notice that bug. Fixed.

Well, nobody really uses it.

[micaman]

I found another "weird" behaviour with the "mark all messages as read" option, not sure I should create a different topic just for this, but here it goes:

"Watchlist" (having multiple pages) -> "mark all messages as read" = All topics from 1st page are marked as read, as the url specifies all topics that should be marked as read.
"Show new replies to your posts." (having multiple pages) -> exactly same behaviour as the above.
"Show unread posts since last visit." (having multiple pages) -> "mark all messages as read" = ALL topics are marked as read. (url does not specify which topics should be marked as read).

I'm not sure if this is supposed to work like this, but it's the main reason I prefer "Watchlist" over "Show unread posts since last visit.", nowadays.

[azguard]

Lost you there for a minute, but I get it now. Seems so, I'd inform about this to the admins though, but well seeing as the new forum might be coming in a few months, and that (lets be honest) no one uses Watch-list, I'd not be sure that it will be fixed anytime soon

How do you follow anything here without a watchlist? No one uses it, preposterous!

i do notify and receive everything on my email then read and reply if i need to

[mexxer-2]

-snip-
"Show unread posts since last visit." (having multiple pages) -> "mark all messages as read" = ALL topics are marked as read. (url does not specify which topics should be marked as read).

Tried, with all in "topic=all" doesn't seem to work. I guess thats a SMF limitation
Edit: Trying other stuff, lets see
This doesn't seem to work either, copied from "All Unread Topics"

[micaman]

-snip-
"Show unread posts since last visit." (having multiple pages) -> "mark all messages as read" = ALL topics are marked as read. (url does not specify which topics should be marked as read).

Tried, with all in "topic=all" doesn't seem to work. I guess thats a SMF limitation
Edit: Trying other stuff, lets see

It doesn't seem to accept "unread" under the "sa" parameter. Specifying topics also appears to be irrelevant.

[shorena]

I found another "weird" behaviour with the "mark all messages as read" option, not sure I should create a different topic just for this, but here it goes:

"Watchlist" (having multiple pages) -> "mark all messages as read" = All topics from 1st page are marked as read, as the url specifies all topics that should be marked as read.
"Show new replies to your posts." (having multiple pages) -> exactly same behaviour as the above.
"Show unread posts since last visit." (having multiple pages) -> "mark all messages as read" = ALL topics are marked as read. (url does not specify which topics should be marked as read).

I'm not sure if this is supposed to work like this, but it's the main reason I prefer "Watchlist" over "Show unread posts since last visit.", nowadays.

Please dont(!) fix that. I was really happy when I once had 10+ page one my watchlist that I could only mark a few very old as read. Took me a while to be brave enough, because I suspected all would be marked as read.

[micaman]

I found another "weird" behaviour with the "mark all messages as read" option, not sure I should create a different topic just for this, but here it goes:

"Watchlist" (having multiple pages) -> "mark all messages as read" = All topics from 1st page are marked as read, as the url specifies all topics that should be marked as read.
"Show new replies to your posts." (having multiple pages) -> exactly same behaviour as the above.
"Show unread posts since last visit." (having multiple pages) -> "mark all messages as read" = ALL topics are marked as read. (url does not specify which topics should be marked as read).

I'm not sure if this is supposed to work like this, but it's the main reason I prefer "Watchlist" over "Show unread posts since last visit.", nowadays.

Please dont(!) fix that. I was really happy when I once had 10+ page one my watchlist that I could only mark a few very old as read. Took me a while to be brave enough, because I suspected all would be marked as read.

I agree... just wondering if the huge "Unread Posts" list shouldn't work the same way.

[mexxer-2]

Theymos, did you just mess up "Updated Topics"? Sort according to Views and Last post show a 404 error. Replies was doing the same, some time ago, but seems fine now.
Edit: Its the same with watchboard
Edit 2: I see the error now, there is a "?" missing, shouldn't be hard to fix

[Cyrus]

Links were erroneous: https://bitcointalk.org/index.phpaction=unreadreplies;start=0;sort=views
"replies" was removed.
Both are now fixed.

[theymos]

Edit 2: I see the error now, there is a "?" missing, shouldn't be hard to fix

Fixed, thanks.

[micaman]

I found another "weird" behaviour with the "mark all messages as read" option, not sure I should create a different topic just for this, but here it goes:

"Watchlist" (having multiple pages) -> "mark all messages as read" = All topics from 1st page are marked as read, as the url specifies all topics that should be marked as read.
"Show new replies to your posts." (having multiple pages) -> exactly same behaviour as the above.
"Show unread posts since last visit." (having multiple pages) -> "mark all messages as read" = ALL topics are marked as read. (url does not specify which topics should be marked as read).

I'm not sure if this is supposed to work like this, but it's the main reason I prefer "Watchlist" over "Show unread posts since last visit.", nowadays.

Please dont(!) fix that. I was really happy when I once had 10+ page one my watchlist that I could only mark a few very old as read. Took me a while to be brave enough, because I suspected all would be marked as read.

I think you misunderstood what I was asking if it should be changed:

"Watchlist" (having multiple pages) -> "mark all messages as read" = Only topics from 1st page are marked as read, as the url specifies all topics that should be marked as read.
"Show new replies to your posts." (having multiple pages) -> "mark all messages as read" = Only topics from 1st page are marked as read, as the url specifies all topics that should be marked as read.
"Show unread posts since last visit." (having multiple pages) -> "mark all messages as read" = ALL topics are marked as read.

I think it would be more helpful if this "unread" list action worked as in "watchlist" and "unread replies".

[shorena]

I found another "weird" behaviour with the "mark all messages as read" option, not sure I should create a different topic just for this, but here it goes:

"Watchlist" (having multiple pages) -> "mark all messages as read" = All topics from 1st page are marked as read, as the url specifies all topics that should be marked as read.
"Show new replies to your posts." (having multiple pages) -> exactly same behaviour as the above.
"Show unread posts since last visit." (having multiple pages) -> "mark all messages as read" = ALL topics are marked as read. (url does not specify which topics should be marked as read).

I'm not sure if this is supposed to work like this, but it's the main reason I prefer "Watchlist" over "Show unread posts since last visit.", nowadays.

Please dont(!) fix that. I was really happy when I once had 10+ page one my watchlist that I could only mark a few very old as read. Took me a while to be brave enough, because I suspected all would be marked as read.

I think you misunderstood what I was asking if it should be changed:

"Watchlist" (having multiple pages) -> "mark all messages as read" = Only topics from 1st page are marked as read, as the url specifies all topics that should be marked as read.
"Show new replies to your posts." (having multiple pages) -> "mark all messages as read" = Only topics from 1st page are marked as read, as the url specifies all topics that should be marked as read.
"Show unread posts since last visit." (having multiple pages) -> "mark all messages as read" = ALL topics are marked as read.

I think it would be more helpful if this "unread" list action worked as in "watchlist" and "unread replies".

Well the link says "all" so I expected the fix to indeed mark "all" as read, on all pages, not just the one shown. Maybe rename it to "mark this page as read" for clarification or add two links. It should certainly be consistant over all pages.