[MAID][SIA][STORJ] up/dl test

[Tulsene]

Those following test are not accurate for many reason : I don't have a good internet connection, I've several p2p softwares connected at the same time (BTC core, SIA, STORJ share, MAID) and a lot of internet page are open on my computers (>60). MAID alfa only allow file of less than 25Mb so I used this file to run my test : Name: aaabbb.zip, Type: application/zip, Size: 24848251 bytes. I ran storj on debian, sia & maid on w7. I used default setup for all. Those test are for me just a photo of what's available today, but they are all moving fast to improve their software, feel free to run your own test and share it here

(edit : time is expressed in minutes:seconds)
 
UPLOAD
 
storj
test 1 : 4:21
test 2 : >8:16, canceled
test 3 : 1:00
test 4 : 2:10
 
maid
test 1 : 1:25
test 2 : 1:30
test 3 : 1:30
test 4 : 1:38
 
sia
 
test 1 : ~17:00 file show up in my hosted list, GUI bug (file deleted after more than 1 hours without be used by siad)
test 2 : ~8:00 file show up, after more than 1 hour file seems not totally uploaded I still can delete it, but I can download it
(bored I didn't ran more test)
 
DOWNLOAD
 
storj
test 1 : 0:19
test 2 : 0:45 failed
test 3 : 0:40 failed
test 4 : 0:50 failed
test 5 : failed
test 6 : failed
 
maid
test 1 : 0:21
test 2 : 0:7
test 3 : 0:6
test 4 : 0:6
 
sia
test 1 : 2:39
test 2 : ~2:00
test 3 : 14:02 error

[myferrari]

maid>sia>storj, am I correct? I am not an expert, it is my guess, I estimated from the figure.

[Tulsene]

as you can read there is a limitation of 25Mb file on MAID and, but I didn't wrote it, a limitation of how many PUTS (I trying to figure it out what is it exactly) you can do. SIA & STORJ have both 6 duplication, so you need to upload the file 6 time on SIA network to finish your upload. btw storj release a new version of the software today so it will change soon for them, and SIA do a lot of update too (I'm running on 1.0.1 version)

[Tobo]

it is not apple to apple comparison because the Maid testing network is not a decentralized network yet.  
- "This is a client-only network, meaning that users cannot run vaults (contribute their resources) from home yet, all data will be hosted on a vault (p2p) network managed by MaidSafe." - https://safenetforum.org/t/safe-network-alpha-release/10687

"We will release a separate test network for users who want to try out running their own vault. It will be called TEST 8 and will be enabled on August 23."
"As for TEST 8, its performance will likely not be as good as the Alpha network," - - https://safenetforum.org/t/safe-network-alpha-release/10687

[Tulsene]

thanks for those informations, I'm looking deeper into it. This thread will need a constant update because things are moving fast, I think publish a new test about storj tomorrow, for maid it will be around the 24th August and for SIA as soon as possible

[Tulsene]

Because of newupdate on storj today I wasn't able to run some test before. I used this file to run my test : Name: aaabb.zip, Type: application/zip, Size: 24848251 bytes.

UPLOAD

storj
test 1 : 1:51
test 2 : 0:56
test 3 : 0:56
test 4 : stopped after 7mn, seems stuck but no error message displayed
test 4 bis : 1:14

DOWNLOAD

storj
test 1 : 2:13
test 2 : 1:49
test 3 : 0:27
test 4 : 0:29

My result on download are a bit weird but I think this is because I run 11 drive share on storj in the same time (and there is a lot of activity on the network at the moment). In the other hand upload had a great improvment with the last version.

Stay tuned for other test and feel free to publish your.