List of Best Campaign Managers in BCT (09/6/2016)

[geopolisch]

No big comment..
just a small suggestion. include a link of Overview of bitcointalk signature ad campaigns in OP.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=615953.new#new

although both are in same board but it would be still good to add it in OP.

[1714829322]

1714829322

[1714829322]

1714829322

[1714829322]

1714829322

[1714829322]

1714829322

[1714829322]

1714829322

[1714829322]

1714829322

[NeuroticFish]

Thanks for listing me here. It feels great to hear compliments from guys out here. This will certainly help me in getting better and improve in my campaign managing style.

There are some suggestions that I want to give: -

1) Add poll to the thread. In that way it will make easier to those to vote for their favourite campaign managers and will also help users who are seeking for a campaign mannager to handle their signature campaign.

2) As SFR10 suggested,I also think that you should put other campaign managers as well like ajarsalede just recently started his service and grtthegreat also has his service available now.

3) Adding a TipJar  . Most of the users admire the work behind these kind of thread. Its upto you though if you want to add it or not  

I think that a poll could hurt. Not all campaign managers are loved and making new accounts only to vote is easy.
Adding as many as possible campaign managers, good and bad too could help especially the newer ones.
Good luck with this, you'll need it, because sooner or later people will start to argue over this or that manager.

[Omegasun]

No big comment..
just a small suggestion. include a link of Overview of bitcointalk signature ad campaigns in OP.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=615953.new#new

although both are in same board but it would be still good to add it in OP.

Ok i will add the thread to the OP. But i will contact first the owner of the thread to get his permission regarding this matter.


About poll regarding best campaign manager, I still thinking about that, But i'm just worrying about many arguments of other members in the thread. Chaos might happen. But still it is a good idea to easily know the true ranking based on peoples choice. I will update tomorrow. Thanks for subscribing here

[Omegasun]

Updated the thread! feel free to suggest any useful tips. thanks!
 

[NeuroticFish]

Updated the thread! feel free to suggest any useful tips. thanks!
 

I think that's the time to make the first post nicer.
I'd suggest you improve the font sizes, colors, maybe add tables.. make it easier to read.
I'm not good at designing things, but I can say for sure that it should be easier to read.

[Omegasun]

Updated the thread! feel free to suggest any useful tips. thanks!
 

I think that's the time to make the first post nicer.
I'd suggest you improve the font sizes, colors, maybe add tables.. make it easier to read.
I'm not good at designing things, but I can say for sure that it should be easier to read.

Noted. Just need some time to improve the thread because i'm still busy on my job. Im still preparing and finishing the details of the table. And i need too a lot of practice in designing using BBCODES because im still noob on it. 

[Supercrypt]

- What are the factors taken into consideration for such a ranking system for campaign managers.
  Openness is very important for a discussion. That will show how a manager is evaluated across factors for a rank.

- Without contribution from public, how a discussion will fulfill it's significance.
  But no one here will be ready to complain about a campaign manager. But everyone will be ready to say merits.

Over all, this seems OP's personal list. Instead of here, it deserves a better place in reputation board.

Edit:

But this thread will help a new advertiser to choose his preferred one.

That is where I fear, this list may mislead a new advertiser as it is not public opinion.

[justdimin]

- Without contribution from public, how a discussion will fulfill it's significance.
  But no one here will be ready to complain about a campaign manager. But everyone will be ready to say merits.

If this is true, then there is no meaning of maintaining a ranking system. Ranks should be moved based on performances.
But this thread will help a new advertiser to choose his preferred one.

[lemipawa]

- What are the factors taken into consideration for such a ranking system for campaign managers.

I didnt realize that those numbers besides the campaign managers name is the rank. I guess it should be "not in order" every campaign participant has their own top 3, my top 3 may not be your top 3 amd everybodys top 3. It depends on each expectation to any campaign manager.

[NeuroticFish]

- What are the factors taken into consideration for such a ranking system for campaign managers.

I didnt realize that those numbers besides the campaign managers name is the rank. I guess it should be "not in order" every campaign participant has their own top 3, my top 3 may not be your top 3 amd everybodys top 3. It depends on each expectation to any campaign manager.

This is not a bad approach, but it needs improvement.
At this point I know 3 campaign managers from the list. And I feel like I'm not very new in this forum.
The point is .. others will know 1, maybe 2. I think that the ones that know more than 2-3 are either very old, either had problems. I don't know a good rule, but we need one.
Then if 3 people tell "X is great" and another 3 tell "Y is great", how you can chose which is better? There are some rules needed. But I agree, some sort of voting is necessary. And maybe only Full Member+ should vote?

Did I make some sense? If I have to improve my explanation, please tell me.


edit: Avirunes' no ranking, just good and bad idea solves the issues I presented, it's a good approach.

[Avirunes]

- What are the factors taken into consideration for such a ranking system for campaign managers.

I didnt realize that those numbers besides the campaign managers name is the rank. I guess it should be "not in order" every campaign participant has their own top 3, my top 3 may not be your top 3 amd everybodys top 3. It depends on each expectation to any campaign manager.

This is not a bad approach, but it needs improvement.
At this point I know 3 campaign managers from the list. And I feel like I'm not very new in this forum.
The point is .. others will know 1, maybe 2. I think that the ones that know more than 2-3 are either very old, either had problems. I don't know a good rule, but we need one.
Then if 3 people tell "X is great" and another 3 tell "Y is great", how you can chose which is better? There are some rules needed. But I agree, some sort of voting is necessary. And maybe only Full Member+ should vote?

Did I make some sense? If I have to improve my explanation, please tell me.

What I think is that ranking system shouldn't be there. Every campaign manager has different type of managing and has a different approach and also qualities. I think instead of ranking them just marking up positives and negatives would be enough. And in the same way others can also suggest plus and minus points of a campaign manager. If OP watches most of them agreeing with the plus point or negative point marked up then he can put it up or otherwise let it go.

[neochiny]

Updated the thread! feel free to suggest any useful tips. thanks!
 

I like the thread! It's useful not just for those looking to start a campaign but for users too. I had no idea some of the people listed were managers.    And, users could just go here and check which campaigns are handled by their favorite managers.
Suggestion: could you add more info? Like list all the campaigns they've handled, both the active ones and those that have ended?
            Those should be included in their creds. Keep the ratings. Ha ha.

[Kolder]

No big comment..
just a small suggestion. include a link of Overview of bitcointalk signature ad campaigns in OP.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=615953.new#new

although both are in same board but it would be still good to add it in OP.

Ok i will add the thread to the OP. But i will contact first the owner of the thread to get his permission regarding this matter.


About poll regarding best campaign manager, I still thinking about that, But i'm just worrying about many arguments of other members in the thread. Chaos might happen. But still it is a good idea to easily know the true ranking based on peoples choice. I will update tomorrow. Thanks for subscribing here

Hi OP. I want to inform you that i will be making a poll about campaign manager to help you to properly arrange the proper ranking based on users suggestion. I hope you add mu poll to your thread. Thanks

I will update here the link once it is finished.

__________________________________________________________>,<

Already finish. Here is the link: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1614992.msg16227083#msg16227083

[Lutpin]

What I think is that ranking system shouldn't be there. Every campaign manager has different type of managing and has a different approach and also qualities. I think instead of ranking them just marking up positives and negatives would be enough. And in the same way others can also suggest plus and minus points of a campaign manager. If OP watches most of them agreeing with the plus point or negative point marked up then he can put it up or otherwise let it go.

Rankings are always subjective, it's almost impossible for them not to be.
I respect most, if not all, of the guys listed in this thread, worked together with some in the past or recommended others for a few jobs.
Obviously it's neat being listed at #2 currently, even though I don't know whether or not I would rank myself below or above some.
You're absolutely right that different managers handle things in different ways and I think that's a neat thing.
As we currently stand, every advertiser can find a qualified manager having just the key points they value. And that can only be a good thing for each and everyone of us.
Sure, we're competition in some aspects, but let's not forget that we're fellow campaign managers aswell, we share a common "profession".


On a side note, might consider adding my overview thread to my listing: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1363152.0
I try to keep it complete and include all my references, although the last update has been some weeks ago, so a few campaigns are missing.

[Visin]

There is a voting system now for those that are interested in putting forth your appreciation for who the best campaign manager is:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1614992.0

Enter in your ballot until October 2, 2016 to vote who you think the number 1 manager of 2016 is.

[TraderETH]

There is a voting system now for those that are interested in putting forth your appreciation for who the best campaign manager is:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1614992.0

Enter in your ballot until October 2, 2016 to vote who you think the number 1 manager of 2016 is.

Interisting voting, i will give my voting on there and i hope there is Lutfin on there. Because in my experience he is the best campaign manager, more than 8 weeks i was worked with him and everything was fine.

[izanagi narukami]

If Carra still active manager, I think he's deserve for being in the list of campaign manager
Well congrats for 10 active manager !

[Lutpin]

If Carra still active manager, I think he's deserve for being in the list of campaign manager

Back when I started, you couldn't say signature campaign without naming Carra in the same breath.
I felt like he deserves to be at least named in the thread, and was about to do so, you're absolutely right, Carra used to be the household name for campaign managing.

Far less known, but another honorary mention I want to drop is Adzion.
He only managed one campaign, and that just for short, but I wouldn't be the guy I am right now without him.
Zino, this is for you!

I guess that takes care of the namedropping.
As for active managers, I wouldn't know, besides those I worked with, like notaek who I supported back with ophion or suggested for NakedBitcoin,
Avirunes who did a great job replacing me the last two weeks or SFR10 who I had the pleasure to work with for almost half a year (I think it was that long, right?).

[shield132]

What SFR said you was true, please add also other managers, for example nowdays secondstrade manager is also very good manager. It will be good also if you will make a poll for people to vote for their best manager.

It's not easy to be a campaing manager because you need to review everyone's post and every manager is good despite their decision because they want only good for their campaign.

Wish success everyone and I hope I will be manager also

[unamis76]

Interesting thread. It would be cool if it was possible to manage this thread like the last one. marcotheminer is indeed a good manager, despite having issues in the last few months of the Bit-X/CoinsBank campaign. Good to see guitarplinker there too since I just joined his campaign...

FortuneJack also ran a very good campaign way back when I joined them and I didn't see complains about their campaign so far, maybe a good candidate for the list too.