I'm very sorry to see this, bitenvy. I just checked my Adam Smith coin and cracked it open because it was still funded. This is very disheartening.
It looks like 18 inputs of approx 2 BTC were sent into this address:
https://blockchain.info/address/19A5uTjZzip9gmNUVjSifeAeUwMdyYQ4zQIf Alitin wants to gain any sort of credibility here, we need them to publish a full list of all addresses to determine how many may have been compromised. We also need to know the full chain of custody from who generated the keys, who did the engraving, and who performed the final slabbing.
It's odd that they may have only redeemed a small number of coins, so maybe only a subset are at risk. If your coin is still funded, I would strongly consider redeeming it now and forget about losing out on whatever premium you may have gotten. At this point, I doubt people would want to buy these funded or pay any premium at all, so just take your coins if you still can.