It seems i have a huge backlog in writing replys... I'll be adding new replies to this post by editing it!
I wanted to extend a special thanks to both
HCP and
philipma1957 for helping me out, since the inflow both on the forum, in PM, my email, my twitter,... is more than i can possibly handle by myself.
During this anwering round, i won't be able to spoonfeed answers to anybody... I'll try to push you in the right direction, but you'll have to do some of the grunt work yourself... I'm swamped with questions lately.If, for some reason, i forgot to answer your question (check back in a couple of hours after i'm done editing), don't hesistate to re-ask
First Questiontransaction id: 29e9816c86691e0bd447416b52f7f679092249d2c9928f2494ba60942e50ba8e
sender/receiver: receiver
addresses: 1Fn4vRvXoL76Xx3dFv9AQvZrYdXpYW8XL4 is my address, 1KNZJAPxy5A1AY5ZKTQMgMqUZB9ahnGaz4 is the sender's address
wallet software: my wallet is an exchange wallet. Not sure about the sender, maybe blockchain.info
mempool: yes, i have checked
http://www.mocacinno.com/page/getraw, entered my transaction id, and i was shown the raw transaction, so this transaction is in your mempool
something strange: no, i have checked for unconfirmed parents, dust outputs and double spends on blockchain.info, and could not find any anomalies
rectified situation: yes, in the future i'll use dynamic fees, and set the slider all the way to the right AND i'll use
http://www.mocacinno.com/page/feeestimate for a second opinion
tip: no, thanks and appreciate ur service tho.
Since you are the receiver, that leaves you with a CPFP or paying a miner to confirm your transaction.
If it was a huge amount of BTC, i'd probably contact your exchange's support dept, and ask them to do a CPFP, but since the amount is relatively small, the best thing you can do right now is keep re-broadcasting the raw transaction:
01000000019adfef30e3ec434b399a270c470e7631c9ff91c261d6446c0acc396179dce050000000006b483045022100e00dc96b68255e0ecee65e99655274e4355903fe7a2c046b71c473d3d16536720220361557ff846ddf2f38d79c6ff17a38219da386f47170ef81d11b024d4c83db9a012103f6b1f5135c64283f8dddabfbcebb49728d4f931b8cf3ff7d5db00ab85d33ba32ffffffff02e4da0400000000001976a914a217c0a45abc30f3bfeb148c210c27b60ceffad088ac280f0800000000001976a914e5c1cdf88a82f81267b748afe771d116ace3d46488ac00000000
--snip--
Transaction ID: 3bf2e0fdd4a9ad01b83c679f83c247d019ecfa6f18c4fd075978b2c47075200a
--snip--
Appologies for the lack of intel.
I am both sender (from MultibitHD) and receiver (to Kraken). I have learned so far that the problem is caused due to low fee per byte.
I do hope to settle this transaction within the next few days, any idea what I can do best in this situation? Would waiting a little longer cause a the transaction to be refunded or what would happen if it doesn't get confirmed in the next few days?
Thanks for any help!
Since the receiver is an exchange, this pretty much rules out CPFP, the tx isn't opt-in RBF so that's out of the question to...
Multibit HD is no longer supported, if you move away from multibit HD to electrum (tutorial can be found here:
https://multibit.org/blog/2017/07/26/multibit-shutdown.html), you SHOULD be able to follow my wizard on
http://www.mocacinno.com/page/feechecker to create, sign and broadcast a transaction double spending the inputs of the unconfirmed transaction using electrum
Thirth Question--snip--
Thanks a lot for your fast reply mocacinno.
I think that unfortunately Mycelium rebroadcasts unconfirmed transactions as I can see you have the manual options to DIY in the interface, and it's been like 8 days (I have read most transactions drop out before 3 days but I may be wrong).
Also I have looked around and it seems there is no way to get the private keys for the input addresses you're mentioning unfortunately, even with the recovery seed... And Coinjar is an Australian exchange for BTC.
Seems like my only hope is to get in touch with a miner directly and get it sorted for a fee. Would you happen to have a preferred contact?
Thanks again!
I think you *should* be able to get your hands on the private keys by using the offline sourcecode
https://iancoleman.io/bip39/ and the correct derivation path. I don't really have time to look up the derivation path myself (answering tons of questions).
If you can't get it fixed, i do know btc.com, viabtc.com and f2pool accept such transactions for a big premium. the first two have a webpage selling their service, f2pool can be contacted on bitcointalk (macbook-air is the owner, and quickseller has push privileges)
Fourth Question10 days the transaction has been stuck1. Transaction id: 9777d77394951cb87b9d07b93a32631d2b351c26fc34419258c3c87e7164a742
2. Sender/receiver: receiver
3. Addresses: 133aV7JThuKCYmBSJWdExZNeE15yMK3Vux is my address
Wallet software: Bitcoin Core 15.1
Mempool: yes, i have checked
http://www.mocacinno.com/page/getraw, entered my transaction id, and i was shown the raw transaction, so this transaction is in your mempool
Extra Info: I have contacted the exchange support team, they told me to use an acceleration service that will cost me around $7,000 USD!!
Please help!!
The problem here is that this tx is using inputs from an unconfirmed parent transaction (e0f15412adeef065b24b184ef0def8495ee78cb1bf9815f9abe21a57333ae3cf).
Your transaction can only be confirmed once it's parent is confirmed.
You could potentially do a CPFP, but you'll have to pay the fee for both your stuck transaction AND it's parent...
The total size of both tx's is 35502 bytes + 225 bytes + 225 bytes (for the CPFP tx) = 36 kb.
The optimal fee at tis point is 700 sat/byte.. So the CPFP tx should have a fee of 0.25 BTC, which is about $4300.. You basically got a bad deal here...
The other option is to contact the sender and force him to clean up his act... He used the outputs of an unconfirmed transaction as input for a new transaction, and that's not a cool thing to do!
Fifth Questionwell many of your problems above are worse then mine.
I paid 215 in fees and unstuck my major transactions. I used btc.com as they totaled more then 50,000 usd. and much of that was not truly mine to hold for as long as i want 215 was a bargain.
I have used viaduct.com to move tx ids but now nothing works with them.
I have 1 transaction left that is stuck
d04fd0649f560f365247f3102fb2910748766132fd9cdeab3cb12e9c09f2bb10
tx id
https://blockchain.info/tx/d04fd0649f560f365247f3102fb2910748766132fd9cdeab3cb12e9c09f2bb10So this was sent via blockchain.info wallet to one of my trezor wallets. it is about 300 usd
I am not paying like 200 usd to unstick it. So does block chain wallet let it drop since it is one of my wallets to one of my other wallets and I don't care about that money at the moment will it drop out?
raw info
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
So I now can't move fund without huge costs. That ends my escrow business. I can live with it ending.
I prefer to mine, but this locked transaction shit is hard to deal with.
https://blockchain.info/address/1JdC6Xg3ajT3rge3FgPNSYYFpmf53VbtjeHi Phil, sorry to see you leave the escrow business... You were one of the guys i actually looked up to. I always loved guessing the next diff jump on your threads
As for your transaction, it has a fee of almost 400 sat/byte... I'm pretty sure it'll be confirmed sooner or later, i did push it to antpool for you, since the fee is reasonable, this one *might* actually have a chance of getting into one of their blocks!
Sixth Question--snip--
How to prevent wallet rebroadcasting?Can I do CPFP with electrum wallet? How to double spend the unspent output?or Would you please help me to confirm?
I need some instructions of manipulation. Thanks some much!
Btw, the tipping sent to you successfully by paying 0.001BTC as the fee, so maybe you can only receive 0.00171645.
I really don't know bither... If you want to know wether they rebroadcast or not, and if they do how to stop it, i would suggest reading/posting in their Ann thread:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=498382.0doing a CPFP from electrum should be as easy as right clicking on the pending, incoming transaction in the transaction history tab. There *should* be an option "Child pays for parent", just follow their wizard and you *should* be OK... If the option isn't shown, make sure you run a recent version (i think they're up to 3.0.3 now, i don't know when this feature was introduced, but older versions might be lacking it).
If you can't get CPFP to work, and you need some extra help, i'd like you to find out if you can use your seed words to restore your bither wallet in electrum. If you can, i can walk you trough doublespending (it might also be possible with bither, i just don't know, nor have the time to really dig into it).
Thanks for the tip, it is greatly appreciated
Seventh Questiontransaction id: 0cd5edf1c339ce6a5d8e62bc1897bdebf0b087e7a14cc49f06270e1b575ddf96
sender/receiver: receiver (and also sender, but from an online exchange service account on IndependentReserve so I dont fully control wallet)
addresses: 1NwH7g6JSuyqNYfnJFS49dRTyZ6AdPuCkF is my address, 1J948EMDqPdEAqphjAGEbFDWHyFnDRo1rM is the sender's address (and their change address is 1Nhzwjrt7rmQUCcCob3umHcMMkEe2pNCyS)
wallet software: IndependentReserve website
mempool: yes, i have checked
http://www.mocacinno.com/page/getraw, entered my transaction id, and i was shown the raw transaction, so this transaction is in your mempool
something strange: no, i have checked for unconfirmed parents, dust outputs and double spends on blockchain.info, and could not find any anomalies
rectified situation: yes, I wont use Independent Reserve for these, as they picked the fee, AND i'll use
http://www.mocacinno.com/page/feeestimate for a second opinion
tip: yes, once I can access any BTC, or can send LTC or BCH.
Thanks!
Well, the main problem is that you are using unknown (to me) independant online wallets... You're basically stuck with the feature set they provide (or with their support dept) UNLESS you can export the private keys of either wallet... Would it be possible to find out which feature sets are offered by the sending/receiving wallet, and if you can export private keys from either one?
Eight Questionyou paid 267 sats it may go over night but your 267 sats may be high enough
Thanks for your reply.
At this stage it's been unconfirmed for 23 hours and counting whereas previous transfers (of lesser amounts) were confirmed within 1-2 hours max. The fee is the default fee set by BTCMarkets which they say is a 'fee charged that get's it processed with the highest priority'. Do you know what could be holding this up if my fee is high enough?
Just want this sorted asap as some of the alts I've been watching are at a good buy in price and it's just a matter of time before I think they will rebound.
Your fee is sufficient to get a confirmation sooner or later, but defenatly not high enough to have a decent chance of getting confirmed right away...
The fee for a 95% chance of getting into the next 3 blocks is 700 sat/byte at the time of writing!
Nineth Question1. Transaction id: 9b7b959579a4e52773b9a7a6597d0447e4eea42d958859af0485f7a91855a25b HAS BEEN STUCK FOR 14 DAYS !
2. Sender/receiver: BOTH...Was unable to set the fees and it bit me
3. Addresses: 12xag4i7LyQ8KAmpsLPCtSNyqdL6y9RaVA is my address
Mempool: yes, i have checked
http://www.mocacinno.com/page/getraw, entered my transaction id, and i was shown the raw transaction, so this transaction is in your mempool
Extra Info: Tried everything, accelerators, etc....No luck this my first stuck transaction, apologies for the noobness
No problem, could you share witch wallet you used to create the transaction, and which wallet was receiving?
Tenth Questionwhy are you doing this for free, is this for your own personal gain or is it because you want to help
(sorry for being so cynical but genuinely curious. I might start off a service like this as well)
or is it some bitcoin cash hack thing that i dont even understand how it works, electron cash deleted my walelt so i have no idea what is going on.
I did this because i could... I used to be able to help about anyone who had a problem in the past.. However, nowadays, a lot of the tools i used to use are heavily abused by people cheaping out on fees. It has come to the point where i'm happy when i'm able to help just 1 or 2 people a day.
I'm not affiliated with bitcoin cash, nor with any of the pools i used to use. When i send somebody to a pool, i don't get a cut. I must admit i sometimes send people to my own site for more information, and i do get some ad revenue from that (about 0.005 BTC/year, i estimated)
