So what would my next step be?
Are you the person who sent it (as in you control the private keys) or did coincafe send it (as in they control the private keys)? If the former, make sure your wallet is synced and send again. If the latter, contact coincafe's support.
"So sorry for the trouble. Our engineering team is working on the bitcoin servers this weekend. Some users like yourself are experiencing incorrectly calibrated outgoing transactions. We anticipate a fix to come soon from our dev team. Certainly everything should be back to normal by end of day Monday at the latest."
Just my luck.