I never did have PGP or a Bitcoin address associated. I don't have any reason to believe that my email address was ever altered from the holding e-mail address.
The main problem is that the web UI email address recovery process will not complete a success recovery flow flow for the account.
I was going to attach screenshots but this time around it sent the email out and I'm back in.. thank you very much for the help/info!!
-vect0rx
Did you ever quoted any Bitcoin address or PGP key you may have owned in the past with your lost account?
If so, you can always sign a message with that address/pgp key and send to theymos to request a password recovery.
Check out this thread for more info:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=497545.0