Shipping to Ohio can be done overnight? I don't see an issue, good luck though.
If I am accepted as one of the purchasers, I would need to send friedcat the coins in a very short amount of time, or risk being labeled a "scammer." I don't want that, and I don't want to add any elements of uncertainty. What if it gets lost and I have to deal with an insurance claim? Even if I ship it to you overnight and it gets to you, I am assuming you would want escrow, which I can't blame you for, which also adds an element of uncertainty which could delay my funds availability. What if you simply don't check your e-mail for a day or two and fail to notify the escrow person that you received it in a timely manner? What if he takes his sweet time as well? Time is critical, so I am sticking with local pickup.
To top it off, you are offering face value, which is the value I can get by simply removing the sticker
What incentive is there for me to go through with this deal at all? The terms are all in your favor, and you bear none of the risk. I also see you resell Casascius coins, which may explain that part, but anyway, thanks for the interest.