It really doesn't have much to do with maximising profit.
It's a fallacy that easy to suck any gambler into.
You make profit when you sell the 'coins' so since no one has a crystal ball and can tell you when in the future you will sell the coins or when in the future the price will get you more, it's easier to go the most obvious route - mine BTC and hold it until it's worth a lot more.
Most people who use these switching ideas are dealing with tiny amounts and I guess they can pretend they're making a fortune due to switching, when in reality it's most likely a long term loss.
I tend to agree with
kano when it comes to most of the auto-switching/multi-pool "hype". The only reason I even know about it is because they played it up to be some new big thing when in reality it's not! In my eyes, it was more or less for some free publicity that will likely attract some ignorant people to their mining pool.
When it comes to sha256 ASIC miners, your best bet (in my opinion) is to mine Bitcoin (and on
kano's pool if your like me and/or in this for the long-mid term).
Kano's pool had a great day yesterday and is off to another one already today - our last block (
Block 481716) was worth over 17 Bitcoin - LOVE those blocks with BIG rewards)!
Anyway, I can confirm that the new auto-switching
ViaBTC URL is exactly what you thought - it simply switches between Bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash based on whichever is the most profitable at any given time. The only thing to keep in mind is that (I assume) determining the most profitable one is based solely on respective prices from their own Exchange, and doesn't take into factor or use any sort of averaged price. To me, that could present some very one-sided data with the possibility to be inaccurate at times, especially when looking at the market as a whole and using averaged prices from top Exchanges.