I didn't include a fee, that's the problem. The transaction has two outputs, one of which is under .01.
https://blockchain.info/tx/49bc932d55dc7aa902346f04cb1f2e9d750bcabed1e29d6c48d0baaf1413e20f?show_adv=falseWhen I originally sent the transaction, it complained about not having enough funds as I only had the two imported wallets as a balance. I then adjusted my amount to accommodate a .0005 fee and it ended up sending without a fee and sent the change back to the wallet. If I had just left the full 19.99 as the amount and sent without a transaction I would have been fine.
It's the change that is making this such a problem. At this point, I'd be happy to lose the change if the transaction would just clear lol.