What do you mean wigh agnostic? i think that you are talking about other things i guess. Because it doesnt have any correlation at all.
We can not just follow the market, if we all were supposed to do that, then probably most of us should be investing on bitcoin cash and moving all our funds to there, and it is not happening.
You just dont have to pay attention to your feelings, and this is the only way to make profit from it. Just be greedy when the others are scared, this is the only way to make profit from any situation.
What I mean by agnostic is: that it does not matter to me whether BTC or BCH is crowned king of the heap. I am here to make money. ( I also share the libertarian ideals of the community)
What I see in the "Bitcoin Core" community is similar to the mid to late 90's opinions of Netscape. Where is Netscape now. I also remember when Everyone thought AOL was the one and only must have Internet service provider. My personal opinion is that competition is good. Am I a Bitcoin believer ? Absolutely yes! Does it bother me there is BTC and BCH? Absolutely not, I think it is a good thing and competition brings innovation at a faster pace.
Maybe Segwit and the Lighting Network is "the scaling answer" . Bitcoin legacy with its high fees is like a burning house, I guess the hope is, the Core team is acting fast enough to put out the fire of high fees.
I am open minded and I don't care which coin wins. They can both win and possibly serve different purposes. The market will decide.