bitcoin symbol adjustment proposal

[edgeworth]

I'd put this in one of the threads discussing the design of the bitcoin symbol but as I am limited to this forum I'll post it here. I was thinking and reading a lot about the design of the bitcoin symbol and came up with a proposed solution. Have a read and see what you think:

http://dl.dropbox.com/u/48235/BITCOINSYMBOLADJUSTMENTPROPOSAL.pdf

https://i.imgur.com/KZzx4.png

Downloads:
EPS: http://dl.dropbox.com/u/48235/BITCOINSYMBOLVECTORS.eps
SVG: http://dl.dropbox.com/u/48235/BITCOINSYMBOLVECTORS.svg
PNG: http://dl.dropbox.com/u/48235/BITCOINSYMBOLPNGS.png


If you don't want to read the PDF, here's the tl;dr:

Problems with the currently used bitcoin symbols include: One is the Thai baht and the other is a B with two extra vertical slashes (for a total of 3) which can look cramped if written manually and interpreted in other typefaces. It also takes time to write.

Problems with designing any new symbol: Can't look remarkably different to the ones being used now.

My proposed solution: Combine the # sign with a B to give the symbol meaning and simplicity.

[Blackhawke]

I like your idea of having a unique symbol for bitcoin, and the double slashed B is as good an idea as any. The real trouble, of course, is in getting in incorporated into symbol sets so that it can be as easily used as the dollar or the euro.

[wumpus]

I like it

[TiagoTiago]

There has already been several threads discussing adopting an official symbol and making it typeable, including a big one that even spawned an article in the Bitcoin wiki

[Giraffe.BC]

+1

[netrin]

I think this, and the plethora of earlier discussions like it, is as fascinating as wanking off, and just as entertaining. But like always, premature, and in the end not as intellectually, emotionally, or physically satisfying as the real thing. But to save time and expedite climax:

Don't use the Thai Baht symbol.

Don't use extant symbols that have meaning in specific contexts, cultures, languages.

Don't base it on double slashes, just like the major fiat currencies we are turning our backs toward - both dollars and euros have double slashes through a character S or E respectively. Why double slashes through a B?

Why do we need a symbol anyway? Is anyone writing digital values down on paper? Is a decentralized currency going to incant symbols by committee?

Don't you expect, hope, or prepare for SI units such as mega, kilo, milli, micro, nano, pico? Wouldn't ASCII characters be most convenient in the digital age? That is what we're after, isn't it?

As you can see, I like to masturbate too. https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Bitcoin_symbol

EDIT: OK, nice PDF, I like the presentation. I disagree with the slash-premise, but applaud your initiative!

[edgeworth]

Any bitcoin symbol is more than just a symbol, it's a logo. Just like people have 'paypal or visa accepted here' banners on their websites that are easily identifiable, bitcoin needs a symbol that identifies itself.  

Like it or loath it, backed by popular usage, a 'B' with either one or two slashes has become symbol and logo for bitcoin. Other good suggestions were made, but nothing else took off. There are some problems though with using a B with one slash as the bitcoin symbol because it is already used by the Thai baht. The problem with using a B with two slashes is that the symbol becomes cramped, time consuming to write and will be difficult to create in some typefaces.

My proposed solution to the problem is to keep the B with two slashes, yet specify that one of these slashes is also the definite vertical baseline of the character. The symbol has a total of two vertical lines, not three like the most common symbol being used and not one like the Thai baht. It's a small adjustment, but one I think makes sense. I also explain in the pdf that the symbol carries some added meaning as it was created by combining '#', a character often associated with code along with the character B.

Needless to say, I disagree that discussing the symbol for bitcoin is akin to wanking off.

[netrin]

Any bitcoin symbol is more than just a symbol, it's a logo. Just like people have 'paypal or visa accepted here' banners on their websites that are easily identifiable, bitcoin needs a symbol that identifies itself.  

That is a good point and I agree. I strongly discourage the Baht symbol. It just present ignorance or apathy and Thailand is a country where bitcoin could really take off.

Like it or loath it, backed by popular usage, a 'B' with either one or two slashes has become symbol and logo for bitcoin.

That may be true. I do loath it. I don't know if you like it (certainly you've invested time in it), but why follow the herd? You're clearly talented. TiagoTiago proposed a brilliant idea. Maybe if you grok its innovation, you can give it some of your typographic expertise.

https://en.bitcoin.it/w/images/en/a/ad/Bat.png

My proposed solution to the problem is to keep the B with two slashes, yet specify that one of these slashes is also the definite vertical baseline of the character

Is that your proposal? I don't recall seeing the double slash any other way. I present http://bitcoin.org/

added meaning as it was created by combining '#', a character often associated with code along with the character B.

That was not immediately apparent to me, but I do like the idea of a hash symbol, which has very significant meaning to bitcoin value/stability/security. Perhaps if you are committed to the double slashed B that you emphasize the hash symbolism.

Needless to say, I disagree that discussing the symbol for bitcoin is akin to wanking off.

Please excuse me. It is only that anything discussed frequently with intensity that results in little change tends to remind me of wanking off. Maybe I'm just doing it wrong.

[TiagoTiago]

Are you searching for the big thread to read it or do you need one of us to do it for you?

[Test Bank Guy]

double slashed b sounds too much like /b/

 

[edgeworth]

That is a good point and I agree. I strongly discourage the Baht symbol. It just present ignorance or apathy and Thailand is a country where bitcoin could really take off.

I completely agree with you here. Commandeering the baht symol is lazy and as bitcoin desires to be used globally, I think being able to differentiate it from the baht is important. I'm not totally against using the baht symbol in place of a bitcoin symbol unofficially until unicode accepts a dedicated bitcoin symbol and this is becoming common, but I would prefer if people for now only delineated bitcoins using the currency code ( ISO 4217)  'BTC'. From the list of proposed unicode characters I also don't mind 'there does not exist' and one other I found 'does not contain as member' but I do think bitcoin needs its own symbol.

That may be true. I do loath it. I don't know if you like it (certainly you've invested time in it), but why follow the herd? You're clearly talented. TiagoTiago proposed a brilliant idea. Maybe if you grok its innovation, you can give it some of your typographic expertise..

I don't hate it. It is the most obvious choice and popular consensus seems to have dictated that something resembling a 'B' with currency slashes be the symbol. I do like some of the other proposals but none of them gained traction. If I created or worked on one of the other symbols, I doubt it would gain any traction either. I also like my solution to the problems the current symbols have.

Is that your proposal? I don't recall seeing the double slash any other way. I present http://bitcoin.org/

If you look closely at that symbol, you will notice that the character B, having one vertical stroke already, gets introduced to two more vertical slashes. While this work visually, using the typeface used as two of three vertical lines in the character share half a space, but if you attempt to write this symbol with a pen manually, you will notice that the space is cramped and it takes time to write, two slashes will become one slash, and soon everyone is writing it as the baht. Other typefaces will run into difficulty trying to interpret it and displaying it on a small scale. With my slight adjustment, and specs, it is clear that only two vertical strokes are to be used like the baht but it still has its own independant identity.

That was not immediately apparent to me, but I do like the idea of a hash symbol, which has very significant meaning to bitcoin value/stability/security. Perhaps if you are committed to the double slashed B that you emphasize the hash symbolism.

I don't think it needs to emphasized any more than it is already apparent. It acts as a good story as to why character looks the way it does and what idea it grew from. A lot of people don't notice the arrow in the Fedex logo as obvious as it is. My vertical lines are set at a diagonal like most # signs but I'm not against them being styled as true verticals as some typefaces might dictate that they need to be.

Please excuse me. It is only that anything discussed frequently with intensity that results in little change tends to remind me of wanking off. Maybe I'm just doing it wrong.

Ha ha!

[edgeworth]

Are you searching for the big thread to read it or do you need one of us to do it for you?

I've read all the threads and documents about the symbol. I can't post anywhere but this forum for the time being on account of my newfishness.

[netrin]

I don't hate it. It is the most obvious choice and popular consensus seems to have dictated that something resembling a 'B' with currency slashes be the symbol.

Are we discussing an abstract symbol (glyph) or logo? If it is decided (against my lone protests) the abstract symbol is a B with two slashes, then I think your logo is lovely. It has clean lines, no cramping, I agree you accomplished your goals. But are you also suggesting a modification to the abstraction? That other logos imply three vertical lines whereas you propose only two (something like a 3 with || rather than a B with ||). These seems a question of penmanship or font rather than glyph. Am I mistaken (I'm willing to bow to your typographic superiority on this one)?

I don't think it needs to emphasized any more than it is already apparent. It acts as a good story as to why character looks the way it does and what idea it grew from. A lot of people don't notice the arrow in the Fedex logo as obvious as it is. My vertical lines are set at a diagonal like most # signs but I'm not against them being styled as true verticals as some typefaces might dictate that they need to be.

I am not much concerned with the logo. I appreciate the need for a logo and am happy to see consensus come up with one without me. If B with slashes is final, then your logo is as fine as any I've seen. But in common writing we will use ASCII. I don't expect a Unicode addition in this decade, nor do I think using an arcane greek, diacritic, or any other clever appropriation from the basic multilingual plane will help bitcoin's adoption. When it becomes as common as gold, I hope the glyph question will have already been answered by a billion humans. In the meantime, I think it will be more important to handle SI prefixes: millebtc, microbtc, nanobtc, and hopefully picobtc. I don't expect pico฿ gaining much traction, ever.

[BitcoinPorn]

Well done pdf, I wish this was out during the creating of the B, but it is already there, I think hard to change at this point as you pointed out.  Even with the changes so minimal and making it better to use, it's just too late.

[dr_nix]

I like your work!

Someone mentioned that he'd rather not associate Bitcoin with regular (fiat) currencies through the use of double slashes. I on the other don't think this is a problem: When you see a B with two slashes and haven't seen it before, it already looks like a currency symbol. Which it is. Just through it's appearance.

[BitCoinBarter]

I only don't one thing about it.

While looking at it, one the upper left side, you see  light.

This is to give the appearance that light is shining on it from the upper left (my guess). This I don't like (probably only me).

I support this design (even if this is never changed).

Can I use it freely myself?

[BitcoinPorn]

Can I use it freely myself?

Good question, I was wondering if this was royalty free as well.

[edgeworth]

It would be royalty free if people want to use it of course. Let me get back to my main work station and I will upload some different image formats including the original vectors so people can easily play around with the gradients themselves and have the coin shine whichever way they prefer. I'll do some myself too and answer the other questions later. What I was really just interested to hear for now was what people thought of the design.

[edgeworth]

added downloads to vector formats and PNG in top post. Will add some more soon.

[bb]

From the list of proposed unicode characters I also don't mind 'there does not exist' and one other I found 'does not contain as member' ...

That must be the worst idea ever.