Any advice on inconsistent info on a transaction, please!

[zebehn]

Hi all,

My transaction, initiated on 16/12/2017, seems strange.

Inspecting it via btc.com I see it's height is 'Removed / DoubleSpending', but via blockchain.info it's just an unconfirmed one. How can the two sites show different information on the same transaction?

1) https://btc.com/b99956124c522855e8a4bb997c3cc0f95e226f7a145267e3ef5715f29915f53a
2) https://blockchain.info/tx/b99956124c522855e8a4bb997c3cc0f95e226f7a145267e3ef5715f29915f53a

What happened to the tx? Any advice please??

THANK YOU SO MUCH IN ADVANCE!!

[Xynerise]

The inputs haven't been spent elsewhere as far as I can see.

Perhaps BTC.com is the cause of the error, because it is not showing double-spent on other block explorers.

[Thirdspace]

Inspecting it via btc.com I see it's height is 'Removed / DoubleSpending', but via blockchain.info it's just an unconfirmed one. How can the two sites show different information on the same transaction?

1) https://btc.com/b99956124c522855e8a4bb997c3cc0f95e226f7a145267e3ef5715f29915f53a
2) https://blockchain.info/tx/b99956124c522855e8a4bb997c3cc0f95e226f7a145267e3ef5715f29915f53a

What happened to the tx? Any advice please??

different node has different policy on dropping transaction, noone can dictate but there are some basic rules
btc.com Removed / DoubleSpending status means dropped/removed from its mempool
for more accurate status on doublespending, try https://bitaps.com/b99956124c522855e8a4bb997c3cc0f95e226f7a145267e3ef5715f29915f53a
for now it seems your tx has been dropped by almost all nodes, are you sender or receiver?

[bob123]

As already mentioned, the transaction seems to be dropped from almost all mempools.
I tried to push your raw transaction, some sites gave an error when doing so (min mempool fee not reached).
You might try a few more online services to broadcast your transaction or use core and broadcast it 'manually'.

Your can broadcast your transaction in hex format:

Code:

0200000014f2bda5db02d98978d19348e5a80fcd587feb6877deba16e4882b19f1738a7da41b0000006b483045022100f6ea88c9ba9c12a38919042a5e88126ed7df3d61b820900c37b6875
14c5ed88a022058df0a2f300e54cd6ef38999835e744f0d94654448813465ed44aecd6fd3e096012102fb2c0c712caca9d704418f7f0c8f5057a34a550db825893fb79207073d554d5ffeffffff0
63de1208c7236e29a55411c39878d19937308ea8efdd5d4afaef3058d6b7a77010000006a473044022071d8574a8f6a8836c870ba53279be8aed8eac5fe27fd76b22d8bf78a6153189002200
abc471fd432c91d447c11c4a5f2e92d273c29784d8e2a41689e656824202e2501210303cd9a5eabad2ec3dae3b1d8c25f80514a632447894f2b8bfe2ef6b9ac59e61afeffffff2c044ec58e9a7
6b89c220bb9d786cb4b5778fee2b1662bace3f5dd3e725514720a0000006b483045022100d34b0697258f6f05f31703c5d94d659edcb1304615035f4fd222b0a8f8f86e79022075541d43f5fe5
9d72575da1cb9ca110cf9a896cdc7d60b4a4b791c2d040723d00121027d70c0493ac543e8cfeba00516064151e3d451ff0dcfb3bd26c77e6b319c7a1dfeffffffd851300742b268a8f91845d4a
5f585e31210b71ec8b9f73e056dd8fb130dade0010000006a4730440220569d0ad34ce45b0f3e2e928ff5b0bc09993d54ec5f294fc168396d1636d10bd802202c96d150c3a6e5522b4f0418b7
7bdffd1fa6bbe6df081113a0e77e7335f5dad4012102b4693ad8f06e96464fca7a8684c4624bafd84ae83ba848ca2a79d69fe2a3c549feffffffcccff3d60f8c68b4baa619affa7f7e656c79ff76a3
6d479763775546dc80a63a070000006a47304402206ee3860a1fd70773f91203f36893f20f192a4f4d39f63a74bdec9b5f12330fca02205c47e210f17f9104a3ab628f722a2b1cc10eb7d184c7
20a3a2044cd5c3e664020121027dd09f923f131f1d7e33a09c3d8e82d0be18f2a8cbd70b5efb7bbc4d6dd8c102feffffff874022d024ae406ae464aa208d5a137858d0fe8b68dc6857b0188f593
b3f5a850e0000006a47304402204ddab5e2d49585258be7c8cab72f609fc7353036ee0be5d161b5f19bb38d2baf02203b5a131ed438aa2c0468dc7e6281e1e7199cd77daa28a1322abf8dd7a
b64bb140121034f13ff0c237143991740ec2e5f14da3a3908e717cc322234ecc36ffaaa36d90bfeffffff70b0756a2d0e63af81cf16319ab3d0e46fc12f7a760e1653d569a6d1f485b40d5d00000
06a47304402206a8e243c30fa160f2f026bcad38f7554433889f9f648fe35dc4d880cab7e5954022020b94d9d1197d43b3d4667e4614baf36327df4f1498dcf7bbd1308fd09bcee20012102e2b
9cd87876c039fdca84ded9fb5a24044907fd2bb2e96a22273446d4869596afeffffffdcc51b235ac799c0c5e4a6a0c764cfb6490cf9ea79978f889af7fe7a67f7edca010000006b483045022100
806600a4fe35ede8ab1e4f02bed63462bd3bb314015df7798a5baa65d4ca8e40022074653324adf940b18a4eccd2e4779fa827f897c8c54b30e9c1b504d8f92c1db7012103194876b8d37989
fbe47182642c2b6cff246cd0d58168364c7802015d168e273afeffffffbec9c5c4cc4d2ba96015487353e8c94d63d9ade1d09ff10891d335cfe69bf9dd0e0000006b483045022100bb8283fb083
9fea2f4f18827f318eca67ab1d9e389b911fe948f9565cfa81cd502207765e0ff98031e234f19dcd62ca109620ef181f77355988f4e78abf86f29311d0121022e84de5bdf6c94855e0bc2f67ac03
700ee4463bc0ee713d268f3d20ffd4f1387feffffff9c5f1ffeb1519addfbe1cd24fc2c141612691fedfe6f15b88eb5a16a69038db90b0000006b483045022100abed9e9d1090ab877ed30ce92b36
2f2c59532538664b93042a74760256c0e11802204a6f5561bf1b030c214dfd16a0af9a1e7b94080eb8fca74141cb15e7dab73281012103aba22d0f02c6516acb9e8e0b45d8583fe0351aee04
b019ee2b3874a8f18c74a1feffffffd4ff68425c5fa88f749e1ec25f8892100d9ccf6fc3733720ec26375b32630f9d000000006b4830450221008f582e167e975285238af5cc15352e5f92767733f
5a27cac37be4a5c38ade7be022038505a42ce92787c35336afb5d91082cbe8bf87e9eea09750de2c49af2767450012102ac4e2bbe17a7628d25d1bb72996c5a5c1bd8e5391f35b6dbab5c4f
837636385efeffffff13e7b6707a461b3892130cab1a47e3545bbe886d70c2742aa9301dae9e84fcf0010000006a47304402200acda0b5104f5170fd57cceba4b5c8bbb1ec4ec2aeaf35ec2c21
6ed94d688c00022016d442e7c79d1ae84d3b0e3d11a9bcf561d847552a9e512192f7b8da9de31e8701210207d74a308166b3a570982418d990fcc444db9134d197eb7b875110bbd3569ee2f
effffff39ab9ef9082e5a7771f2f29dba5b7906e75e4c85cc0ad8e9d58019a60e21bc41040000006a473044022025ad20726c386057b4d4f8133c5e03113365deb68f39346bf6556eed38ed70c
502207ccd54e45fd432f51ea55251f16b60091b3cf6f501b5740d73d1a4d311ac18830121034f13ff0c237143991740ec2e5f14da3a3908e717cc322234ecc36ffaaa36d90bfeffffff897c0c7e5
1c3f198a30f46ed28ac2a2f0a1c573e5aaf18131e2e3ae652c7e535010000006b48304502210081106206fe4dcdc93dec2cb499733b46970c906c08b7c828966947b0de392de20220798588
601d059e632032a12efa05e70772538cdc154f8dea80b90468ba3e2d6a0121024bc1d730d4bca1ed87f91bea14dd12167ee2407d94cf35ed21445359e2a6d100fefffffffb7880561d8aef6226
405fd9fcc809ceb5edf65400a3214f8ba87cbdf62fa157090000006b483045022100c786f81cd5afe0cdb72b0062fc157b4220ab97cc2615ff6606e1b5410b2437e502202b2e0a480efab91d60
a1e178b559df7b9ac15bccc9b181c8bcfdb485bed9f2c701210318d8227cfb525f2a7ebb0f430dda34ee19688452958e0460def782f804e85040feffffff3509c7d4219b4b540af03c5bf7b72862
0eb1d2efa75adabb4aaa0dc0dffb51e3010000006a473044022016f45ad0a9f5fa00af7e32765dcddfdb09fec8a1ecc225d75495d0f657c59341022031a82904d4b2ac7e73956c33dc85598bcf
f7f280b95187fe183d20c31c5e89bd012103b0a8ae66690c5d040ea7359d7c874cb692b424c8427336ca7279c2289dfaf660fefffffff7db60d0681dcdf1755a05686eae5cfe6648a37ff8da7d59
c4d32f6aa8066587130000006a473044022063d2d0c1467ec0ea1cd592c1f84ae2d383311a4a1f4d4f5266269f30ff1e5a5c0220261e8f3579fce5ac4fe9a2feb3cd0b781b071c854b642ceb0b
deb8cd4a7e374601210246dead73906f88f8adc1da9f80e66a743ce7ba0b33ce88a0403fbde92de81ef5feffffff3231513427e38b2f9e5f72e231a6b5d8261c4a198b38a7ad267164fa99f71a6
a020000006a47304402201b909864fdd8d7971f7709755260fc65bd4fc6c031fd530bf50d8469ce5de2e602206ce529f92c97640ba7b45a848e61c803944fda80c3d7162cf1166857a9d592eb
0121027a7d2724bae9d1b755183bb44d66ee5dba89202edb125311f00d8b8cc910575ffeffffff2c7d4fb34574c110c9d024b7e932d2854aa414a4356472115d57abf8b09160ec150000006b48
3045022100908cd5e0e3e2de3009d0c56986cf8c85ed460339dce519f2f2d053bec612f93a02202814bc49fcfa6987b95ee3f44328e1431cc0f35478a5eb85eab8382d7ffb71900121030ef288
acf106fd14fca0856e3e40032ea4fbe704b07be0f7766eb3101d8c1bd1feffffff53fbc8bd1ea43b964f1fe75b27f74d0ba90f40cb90490ea36a44f204da0f8a09010000006a4730440220685d7c8
3f63d4f54adc30ad02809d5bcd101d67bc353aeaa82c820a14e46f0db02203da8caf72e9d89626a32f5dfe8ee10e914fd6fe022bce6929d979c6d326bb6ff01210302d2bb8924a8fd9d5228966
af47dd890d8a597302aa42da135f3780bd7b043e1feffffff0262f80c00000000001976a914ab60b047c619ef91fb6a92e571e66aa824d9cf5a88acb0a508060000000017a91404acdf34bd583c
8d53a765b06d43e8c27eab3376879d9f0700

If you were the recieving part of this transaction you should contact the person who sent this TX.
Only regard transactions as completed when they at least recieved 1 confirmation.

Additionally you could contact a miner and ask them to include your transaction into their block (as long as its not conflicting with other transactions).
This will most likely cost an appropriate fee.

[zebehn]

Inspecting it via btc.com I see it's height is 'Removed / DoubleSpending', but via blockchain.info it's just an unconfirmed one. How can the two sites show different information on the same transaction?

1) https://btc.com/b99956124c522855e8a4bb997c3cc0f95e226f7a145267e3ef5715f29915f53a
2) https://blockchain.info/tx/b99956124c522855e8a4bb997c3cc0f95e226f7a145267e3ef5715f29915f53a

What happened to the tx? Any advice please??

different node has different policy on dropping transaction, noone can dictate but there are some basic rules
btc.com Removed / DoubleSpending status means dropped/removed from its mempool
for more accurate status on doublespending, try https://bitaps.com/b99956124c522855e8a4bb997c3cc0f95e226f7a145267e3ef5715f29915f53a
for now it seems your tx has been dropped by almost all nodes, are you sender or receiver?

thank you, sir! greatly appreciated by your inspection work.
initially i requested the tx at a Korean exchange called Coinnest to send BTC coins to an exchange called Upbit.
I've been trying to contact the Coinnest's support but with no avail... :-(

[zebehn]

As already mentioned, the transaction seems to be dropped from almost all mempools.
I tried to push your raw transaction, some sites gave an error when doing so (min mempool fee not reached).
You might try a few more online services to broadcast your transaction or use core and broadcast it 'manually'.

Your can broadcast your transaction in hex format:

Code:

0200000014f2bda5db02d98978d19348e5a80fcd587feb6877deba16e4882b19f1738a7da41b0000006b483045022100f6ea88c9ba9c12a38919042a5e88126ed7df3d61b820900c37b6875
14c5ed88a022058df0a2f300e54cd6ef38999835e744f0d94654448813465ed44aecd6fd3e096012102fb2c0c712caca9d704418f7f0c8f5057a34a550db825893fb79207073d554d5ffeffffff0
63de1208c7236e29a55411c39878d19937308ea8efdd5d4afaef3058d6b7a77010000006a473044022071d8574a8f6a8836c870ba53279be8aed8eac5fe27fd76b22d8bf78a6153189002200
abc471fd432c91d447c11c4a5f2e92d273c29784d8e2a41689e656824202e2501210303cd9a5eabad2ec3dae3b1d8c25f80514a632447894f2b8bfe2ef6b9ac59e61afeffffff2c044ec58e9a7
6b89c220bb9d786cb4b5778fee2b1662bace3f5dd3e725514720a0000006b483045022100d34b0697258f6f05f31703c5d94d659edcb1304615035f4fd222b0a8f8f86e79022075541d43f5fe5
9d72575da1cb9ca110cf9a896cdc7d60b4a4b791c2d040723d00121027d70c0493ac543e8cfeba00516064151e3d451ff0dcfb3bd26c77e6b319c7a1dfeffffffd851300742b268a8f91845d4a
5f585e31210b71ec8b9f73e056dd8fb130dade0010000006a4730440220569d0ad34ce45b0f3e2e928ff5b0bc09993d54ec5f294fc168396d1636d10bd802202c96d150c3a6e5522b4f0418b7
7bdffd1fa6bbe6df081113a0e77e7335f5dad4012102b4693ad8f06e96464fca7a8684c4624bafd84ae83ba848ca2a79d69fe2a3c549feffffffcccff3d60f8c68b4baa619affa7f7e656c79ff76a3
6d479763775546dc80a63a070000006a47304402206ee3860a1fd70773f91203f36893f20f192a4f4d39f63a74bdec9b5f12330fca02205c47e210f17f9104a3ab628f722a2b1cc10eb7d184c7
20a3a2044cd5c3e664020121027dd09f923f131f1d7e33a09c3d8e82d0be18f2a8cbd70b5efb7bbc4d6dd8c102feffffff874022d024ae406ae464aa208d5a137858d0fe8b68dc6857b0188f593
b3f5a850e0000006a47304402204ddab5e2d49585258be7c8cab72f609fc7353036ee0be5d161b5f19bb38d2baf02203b5a131ed438aa2c0468dc7e6281e1e7199cd77daa28a1322abf8dd7a
b64bb140121034f13ff0c237143991740ec2e5f14da3a3908e717cc322234ecc36ffaaa36d90bfeffffff70b0756a2d0e63af81cf16319ab3d0e46fc12f7a760e1653d569a6d1f485b40d5d00000
06a47304402206a8e243c30fa160f2f026bcad38f7554433889f9f648fe35dc4d880cab7e5954022020b94d9d1197d43b3d4667e4614baf36327df4f1498dcf7bbd1308fd09bcee20012102e2b
9cd87876c039fdca84ded9fb5a24044907fd2bb2e96a22273446d4869596afeffffffdcc51b235ac799c0c5e4a6a0c764cfb6490cf9ea79978f889af7fe7a67f7edca010000006b483045022100
806600a4fe35ede8ab1e4f02bed63462bd3bb314015df7798a5baa65d4ca8e40022074653324adf940b18a4eccd2e4779fa827f897c8c54b30e9c1b504d8f92c1db7012103194876b8d37989
fbe47182642c2b6cff246cd0d58168364c7802015d168e273afeffffffbec9c5c4cc4d2ba96015487353e8c94d63d9ade1d09ff10891d335cfe69bf9dd0e0000006b483045022100bb8283fb083
9fea2f4f18827f318eca67ab1d9e389b911fe948f9565cfa81cd502207765e0ff98031e234f19dcd62ca109620ef181f77355988f4e78abf86f29311d0121022e84de5bdf6c94855e0bc2f67ac03
700ee4463bc0ee713d268f3d20ffd4f1387feffffff9c5f1ffeb1519addfbe1cd24fc2c141612691fedfe6f15b88eb5a16a69038db90b0000006b483045022100abed9e9d1090ab877ed30ce92b36
2f2c59532538664b93042a74760256c0e11802204a6f5561bf1b030c214dfd16a0af9a1e7b94080eb8fca74141cb15e7dab73281012103aba22d0f02c6516acb9e8e0b45d8583fe0351aee04
b019ee2b3874a8f18c74a1feffffffd4ff68425c5fa88f749e1ec25f8892100d9ccf6fc3733720ec26375b32630f9d000000006b4830450221008f582e167e975285238af5cc15352e5f92767733f
5a27cac37be4a5c38ade7be022038505a42ce92787c35336afb5d91082cbe8bf87e9eea09750de2c49af2767450012102ac4e2bbe17a7628d25d1bb72996c5a5c1bd8e5391f35b6dbab5c4f
837636385efeffffff13e7b6707a461b3892130cab1a47e3545bbe886d70c2742aa9301dae9e84fcf0010000006a47304402200acda0b5104f5170fd57cceba4b5c8bbb1ec4ec2aeaf35ec2c21
6ed94d688c00022016d442e7c79d1ae84d3b0e3d11a9bcf561d847552a9e512192f7b8da9de31e8701210207d74a308166b3a570982418d990fcc444db9134d197eb7b875110bbd3569ee2f
effffff39ab9ef9082e5a7771f2f29dba5b7906e75e4c85cc0ad8e9d58019a60e21bc41040000006a473044022025ad20726c386057b4d4f8133c5e03113365deb68f39346bf6556eed38ed70c
502207ccd54e45fd432f51ea55251f16b60091b3cf6f501b5740d73d1a4d311ac18830121034f13ff0c237143991740ec2e5f14da3a3908e717cc322234ecc36ffaaa36d90bfeffffff897c0c7e5
1c3f198a30f46ed28ac2a2f0a1c573e5aaf18131e2e3ae652c7e535010000006b48304502210081106206fe4dcdc93dec2cb499733b46970c906c08b7c828966947b0de392de20220798588
601d059e632032a12efa05e70772538cdc154f8dea80b90468ba3e2d6a0121024bc1d730d4bca1ed87f91bea14dd12167ee2407d94cf35ed21445359e2a6d100fefffffffb7880561d8aef6226
405fd9fcc809ceb5edf65400a3214f8ba87cbdf62fa157090000006b483045022100c786f81cd5afe0cdb72b0062fc157b4220ab97cc2615ff6606e1b5410b2437e502202b2e0a480efab91d60
a1e178b559df7b9ac15bccc9b181c8bcfdb485bed9f2c701210318d8227cfb525f2a7ebb0f430dda34ee19688452958e0460def782f804e85040feffffff3509c7d4219b4b540af03c5bf7b72862
0eb1d2efa75adabb4aaa0dc0dffb51e3010000006a473044022016f45ad0a9f5fa00af7e32765dcddfdb09fec8a1ecc225d75495d0f657c59341022031a82904d4b2ac7e73956c33dc85598bcf
f7f280b95187fe183d20c31c5e89bd012103b0a8ae66690c5d040ea7359d7c874cb692b424c8427336ca7279c2289dfaf660fefffffff7db60d0681dcdf1755a05686eae5cfe6648a37ff8da7d59
c4d32f6aa8066587130000006a473044022063d2d0c1467ec0ea1cd592c1f84ae2d383311a4a1f4d4f5266269f30ff1e5a5c0220261e8f3579fce5ac4fe9a2feb3cd0b781b071c854b642ceb0b
deb8cd4a7e374601210246dead73906f88f8adc1da9f80e66a743ce7ba0b33ce88a0403fbde92de81ef5feffffff3231513427e38b2f9e5f72e231a6b5d8261c4a198b38a7ad267164fa99f71a6
a020000006a47304402201b909864fdd8d7971f7709755260fc65bd4fc6c031fd530bf50d8469ce5de2e602206ce529f92c97640ba7b45a848e61c803944fda80c3d7162cf1166857a9d592eb
0121027a7d2724bae9d1b755183bb44d66ee5dba89202edb125311f00d8b8cc910575ffeffffff2c7d4fb34574c110c9d024b7e932d2854aa414a4356472115d57abf8b09160ec150000006b48
3045022100908cd5e0e3e2de3009d0c56986cf8c85ed460339dce519f2f2d053bec612f93a02202814bc49fcfa6987b95ee3f44328e1431cc0f35478a5eb85eab8382d7ffb71900121030ef288
acf106fd14fca0856e3e40032ea4fbe704b07be0f7766eb3101d8c1bd1feffffff53fbc8bd1ea43b964f1fe75b27f74d0ba90f40cb90490ea36a44f204da0f8a09010000006a4730440220685d7c8
3f63d4f54adc30ad02809d5bcd101d67bc353aeaa82c820a14e46f0db02203da8caf72e9d89626a32f5dfe8ee10e914fd6fe022bce6929d979c6d326bb6ff01210302d2bb8924a8fd9d5228966
af47dd890d8a597302aa42da135f3780bd7b043e1feffffff0262f80c00000000001976a914ab60b047c619ef91fb6a92e571e66aa824d9cf5a88acb0a508060000000017a91404acdf34bd583c
8d53a765b06d43e8c27eab3376879d9f0700

If you were the recieving part of this transaction you should contact the person who sent this TX.
Only regard transactions as completed when they at least recieved 1 confirmation.

Additionally you could contact a miner and ask them to include your transaction into their block (as long as its not conflicting with other transactions).
This will most likely cost an appropriate fee.

wow! i am touched by your thorough and thoughtful reply.
i am the receiving part and it seems it's almost impossible to contact the sending part, an exchange firm that does not answer to my call... :-(
would it help in my case to use paid accelerator service from pushtx.com? an estimated cost of accelerating my tx is $788.53 according to the site, btw.
i don't know what to do...

[bob123]

wow! i am touched by your thorough and thoughtful reply.
i am the receiving part and it seems it's almost impossible to contact the sending part, an exchange firm that does not answer to my call... :-(
would it help in my case to use paid accelerator service from pushtx.com? an estimated cost of accelerating my tx is $788.53 according to the site, btw.
i don't know what to do...

There are a few people around here on this forum which have access to mining pools.
They may confirm your TX into their next block. But this will definetly cost 50$+.
You might also try to wait until the backlog of transaction has calmed down. Then you can try a child-pays-for-parent transaction.
In such a CPFP-transaction you are sending your (non-confirmed) output to another address of yourself with a fee which is big enough to cover both TX fees.
If a miner comes across your 2nd TX he will then confirm both of your TX's if its lucrative.
Currently this would exceed the amount of BTC in your transaction.. but after mempool has cleared its a viable option.
Until then you can either pay a huge amount to get your TX into a block by a miner or you just wait until the mempool has calmed down.
But definetly keep on contacting the support, with 50 sat/B it could take forever to get confirmed (or won't get confirmed at all..).